The Mourinho Thread: Should he stay or go? | Sacked

Is Mourinho’s time as United manager up?

  • Yes

    Votes: 2,296 77.1%
  • No

    Votes: 293 9.8%
  • Not yet - needs more time to see if he can turn it around

    Votes: 388 13.0%

  • Total voters
    2,977
Status
Not open for further replies.
The worst thing that board can do is to leave this as it stands. They must say to players that Mourinho is staying no matter what or sack him.
 
He's 8/13 to be gone before Christmas day. I fully expect him to go in the next 6 games.
 
I still like him. Doesn't mean I want him to manage United. Everyone has their sell by date and he's done as top level manager. It is what it is.

Now with Moyes, there is irrational dislike for that man.

I feel exactly the same way
 
The worst thing that board can do is to leave this as it stands. They must say to players that Mourinho is staying no matter what or sack him.
When players down tools this early on, not saying ours 100% have, the manager usually doesn't last very long. To be fair, after a bit of thought I don't think the board will wait as long as they have in the past. They already seemed to be in two minds after the summer and not backing Mourinho's choice, all speculation on my part though.
 
If I was Woody I would bring in Zidane to Carrington while Mou is training. Then the former will go on signing a contract while the latter is shown the door.
 
Well, you can't say we didn't know what we were letting ourselves in for. There's no better man to bring this sort of situation into the trenches and make the parting of ways infinitely more damaging than it has to be. Football is a game of opinions and all that, but I struggle to see how anyone thinks he's going to turn this around (and by turn it around, I mean to do the job he was brought in for, win big trophies). Best case scenario right now, he gets us top 4 and the whole cycle starts again next summer i.e. do we back him or sack him? Both sides will walk away dissatisfied. The club will feel that they hired a super manager who has failed to improve very many of the players he has worked with. Mourinho will feel that he hasn't been given the tools to challenge City. Both are correct, I suspect.
 
947 people in the 'out' column at the time of writing.

His supporters are decreasing at an alarming rate.
 
I'm still Jose in because I believe the players have let him down massively over the past few years Whether that's because they never believed in his philosophy, weren't motivated enough to follow his instructions or just did not suit... I don't know. I also think that the board messed up this summer as we'd had a relatively successful season and needed the players Jose had identified for the next push.

HOWEVER a change in management right now seems the best possible solution to save our season. His signing was polarising for fans from the beginning and for some fans, the only way that he and his style of football would have even been accepted is through continual success which he did not achieve last season.
 
It is not easy to do so, as much as I'd love that to happen, think we sadly need another two, three bad results. Jose is a manager superstar, strong personality, that's on one hand, on second, there has to be a plan how to replace Mourinho. I am sure they had a thought about it already. I think the most sensible would be not to jump the gun and give Carrick and McKenna run till the end of season, it cannot be less organized and fecked up, just give them a chance, players are not bad at all, just need some confidence positivity, attacking football, ditch old tactics, let players enjoy themselves. At the end of the season we might be talking to Pochettino or Zidane or there might be other options available, you never know. Shame the best managers I'd want for the brand of football they play are now at our worst enemy teams Liverpool, City, and Leeds. God I'd love Bielsa to put this team into shape
Completely agree with everything, keeping Jose is not an option though and I’d rather enter into unknown that Carrick and McKenna currently personify.
 
Players aren't playing for him, and he's stuck in past tactics wise.i like him gone asap so a new manager could judge squad before next summer and sell the players that he doesn't want or need.
 
Just when I thought Moyes and LvG had broken almost all dubious records, Jose makes it one more with worst start in 29 years.
 
Turmoil is primarily around Jose though. Think a new manager would totally change atmosphere around the club.

It also gives the new coach a chance to work with players and see who he rates and who doesn't suit however he wants to play. Plenty of upsides to getting someone in mid season

Fair enough.
 
947 people in the 'out' column at the time of writing.

His supporters are decreasing at an alarming rate.
You can still support him but think its time to go.
If we don't get top 4 then the board needs to go as well.
 
Frankly this season was so predictable i don't know why we all convinced ourselves that it wouldn't happen. Not at United, cause we're too special for it. Mourinho is Mourinho, he wasn't going to change for us. The signs were there when he willingly threw the club under the bus to deflect blame from himself. But we convinced ourselves that he was "telling things how they were", "fighting for the fans" or even more unbelievably, "protecting his players".
 
He's 8/13 to be gone before Christmas day. I fully expect him to go in the next 6 games.

Christmas Day/New Year’s was my prediction before the season started, but just about every week that passes it dwindles. I was saying sacked by Halloween to some friends after the league cup game.
 
He's 8/13 to be gone before Christmas day. I fully expect him to go in the next 6 games.
We've got some very difficult games in the next 6 too. Valencia, Chelsea and Juventus could all be dropped points, in fact all of October could end up being tricky, we play Everton and Newcastle too.
 
I support him but the players seem to have turned against him so realistically speaking, his time is up.
 
We've got some very difficult games in the next 6 too. Valencia, Chelsea and Juventus could all be dropped points, in fact all of October could end up being tricky, we play Everton and Newcastle too.

Yeah that's why I expect him to go. I can't see where the next win is coming from.
 
Yeah that's why I expect him to go. I can't see where the next win is coming from.
I'd like to think we could easily do Newcastle at home but I'm not confident of anything at the moment :lol:
 
We've got some very difficult games in the next 6 too. Valencia, Chelsea and Juventus could all be dropped points, in fact all of October could end up being tricky, we play Everton and Newcastle too.

If we lose to Valencia, Chelsea and Juventus, our season is effectively over.
 
We've got some very difficult games in the next 6 too. Valencia, Chelsea and Juventus could all be dropped points, in fact all of October could end up being tricky, we play Everton and Newcastle too.
Yikes, this place is going to be fun...
 
I'd like to think we could easily do Newcastle at home but I'm not confident of anything at the moment :lol:

Exactly. You'd think that but again the way were playing I'd not be surprised if we dropped points against Newcastle. Plus Rafa would fecking love it.
 
McTominay in a back 3, is he actively trying to sabotage this season? Knows he is going down, wants the club to go down with him?

Poisonous man.
 
Frankly this season was so predictable i don't know why we all convinced ourselves that it wouldn't happen. Not at United, cause we're too special for it. Mourinho is Mourinho, he wasn't going to change for us. The signs were there when he willingly threw the club under the bus to deflect blame from himself. But we convinced ourselves that he was "telling things how they were", "fighting for the fans" or even more unbelievably, "protecting his players".

You and some may have convinced yourselves of that, there was a sizable portion of us who felt Mourinho was a disaster waiting to happen. Not only will he be gone soon, but the damage he has done will not be easy to repair for the next manager either. Whether it's his tactics, man-management, or attitude, Mourinho has been a massive, massive failure.
 
Really wanted him to do well, always thought he was meant to manage the club but it isn’t working out. The camp is apparently divided, the football is awful and the results are poor.
 
Get the fraud out. I'm 100% done with him and half the team if I'm honest.

There's two things though, that I hope ALL of us on this board are prepared for:

1) Carrick and McKenna will have us finishing around 10th, so be prepared for a really demoralising remainder of the season.

2) Any new manager, regardless of who he is, is not going to make mid-table dross like Valencia, Jones, Lindelöf, McTominay, Lingard et al look world class. And that set of absolute frauds are still going to be around, stinking up the place. So be prepared for more of the same next season, albeit with probably better attacking football fingers crossed.
 
12m to pay him off? If that's it, do it, took bigger hits before. Lost more on Veron 15 years ago..
Am sure Woodward can make it back from some obscure noodle sponsor
 
Status
Not open for further replies.