The Mourinho Thread: Should he stay or go? | Sacked

Is Mourinho’s time as United manager up?

  • Yes

    Votes: 2,296 77.1%
  • No

    Votes: 293 9.8%
  • Not yet - needs more time to see if he can turn it around

    Votes: 388 13.0%

  • Total voters
    2,977
Status
Not open for further replies.
How the hell are Manchester United on minus-two goal difference? Scandalous.

After 7 games. It's utterly bizarre, Steve. Chris Smalling is our second highest goal scorer in 2018 I heard somewhere. It's just crazy.
 
Most of them aren't good enough to be challenging for the league. I'd say that's probably a large reason why we aren't doing so.

Replace Jose with Zidane, I'd be fine with that. But it wouldn't shock me at all if the same problems reared their head until we buy some actual quality. Zidane isn't suddenly going to transform Phil Jones into Cannavaro.

Agree that they probably can't win the league on their quality alone, but they're certainly capable of good performances and a good league finish. If the next manager comes in and proves that he can get the players playing to their potential then yeah I'd trust him with more money to improve the squad. The horrible performances right now are a direct result of Mourinho being abysmally poor at coaching attacking play.
 
Right now it feels like just a matter of time before the axe falls. However, I don't think he'll be sacked in the next few weeks, so he must now find a way to get some results and save his skin. Time is running out, he knows that.

If/when Jose is sacked, Woodward needs to go with him. The leadership at the club just now seems non-existent.

There is no way this group is going to even challenge for Top 4 under Jose. I reckon Woodward will have no choice after 4-5 more games.
 
After 7 games. It's utterly bizarre, Steve. Chris Smalling is our second highest goal scorer in 2018 I heard somewhere. It's just crazy.
Good grief, Maxi. :(
 
The squad all needs to be sold, they're all clearly sucking Pogba off and don't deserve to play for us. Part of me wishes Jose digs in, makes it to January.. sell that wannabe gansta to Barca along with his brother from another mother Martial and we can start to instil some fighting spirit back into the squad. First thing we need to do is get in Willian to sort out that right flank and throw whatever money it takes at Inter to get Perisic, so we finally get some proper width and support to Lukaku.

I think we also need a new centre back, Maguire is looking like a no brainer to shore things up. If we get them three in - we will finish top 4 and in the summer, I'd bin everyone bar De Gea and let Jose build his own team without restrictions. It has been a shitshow, him having to deal with bad purchases by Moyes/LVG and not being allowed to get rid of them.

Stay strong Jose, the real United fans are with you mate.

Shouldn't you be concern with what Chelsea's going to do to your team later today,eh?
 
Maybe you've got a bigger sack than others.

:lol:

So you're going with "we have been unlucky"? I'm sure you have heard the expression "great teams do not rely on luck, but when they do get lucky it is because they created it themselves"

Okay, I kinda made that up (sort of) but you get the picture I'm sure.

I see what you're saying. At some point it's no longer luck, it's the setup and the manager. I'm nearly at that turning point. And at that point I'll block this thread and move over to the dark side
 
You're joking right? He's spent over 400mil€ how much more does he need to beat the likes of Derby County, WHU, Wolves and the likes?
Jesus christ some of you on here....
I'm literally speechless at some of the comments in this thread

The players gave up which is why we didn't beat Derby, Wolves and West Ham. He only got two players this summer which is inadequate given he need a CB and RW. If Mourinho had backing, we wouldn't be in this mess.

Before I go, tell me if you think Conte or Zidane can turn this around because good luck if you think they can. This season is over and October is about to start.
 
Our best player is McTominay. The rest clearly aren't bothered. A new manager and a lot of new players needed.
 
After 7 games. It's utterly bizarre, Steve. Chris Smalling is our second highest goal scorer in 2018 I heard somewhere. It's just crazy.
:lol: Fecking hell

Slightly off topic but just as depressing, I also read that since we sold Ronaldo every single number 7 we've replaced him with has scored a combined total of 13 league goals. In 9 fecking years...
 
The players gave up which is why we didn't beat Derby, Wolves and West Ham. He only got two players this summer which is inadequate given he need a CB and RW. If Mourinho had backing, we wouldn't be in this mess.

Before I go, tell me if you think Conte or Zidane can turn this around because good luck if you think they can. This season is over and October is about to start.
Why does he still need a CB when he bought 2 of them already ?
 
I don't disagree with you. I just don't think sacking him will make everything rosy again. It might be a start, and that's good enough. But it will be just that.
You are completely right, Jose has left an almighty mess that will take a few seasons to fix.
 
Most of them aren't good enough to be challenging for the league. I'd say that's probably a large reason why we aren't doing so.

Replace Jose with Zidane, I'd be fine with that. But it wouldn't shock me at all if the same problems reared their head until we buy some actual quality. Zidane isn't suddenly going to transform Phil Jones into Cannavaro.

Honestly that's wrong, I'm not saying that they are great but history shows that players as a group can look very poor when the coaching staff is having a meltdown. Just in recent years, you can look at Chelsea or Bayern with Mourinho and Ancelotti. As much as people don't like that fact, the main influence of a manager is mental, they have the ability to destroy or build the spirit of a team.
 
This was a dig. You know that Jose is bigger than the club though so its alllowed.
Waiting for @VP89 to pop-up and tell us how by doing this he’s protecting the team and the club again and surely not trying to shift the blame from himself and save his brand.
 
At the start of his second season I made a thread on his there’s no way this will end well. Unfortunately the mods didn’t wanna hear it and it got deleted . We get papering over the cracks with fluke wins here and there . It was evident from season one that he wasn’t up to the task
 
If you're not there yet, what do you think he can still do about the current situation ?

Settle on a starting 11 and ride that unit with minimal changes. Find a way to have the side generate more quality chances. And make us solid again. We've conceded 12 goals already, the bleeding has to be staunched, and he knows how to do that.
 
That is a reasonable post and I know I will never have to write such a post ever again - we may have more managers who fail, but I don't think we'll ever see such a manipulative toxic manager ever again.

When his methods function, he can work wonders. But when they don't, he can really fail miserably. His manipulation skills have worked for him while he was successful. Although, I wouldn't even say he is that good at manipulating. If he was, he would have realised at some point that his old ways aren't getting him what he wants, and he would be trying hard to let the fans and players hear what they want to hear. To save his own arse and buy himself some time, which obviously wouldn't have been good for the club.

His ego is to big for him to be capable of that though. But without it, he probably wouldn't have been so successful during his career in the first place. Unfortunately, it has only worked against him lately.
 
:lol: Fecking hell

Slightly off topic but just as depressing, I also read that since we sold Ronaldo every single number 7 we've replaced him with has scored a combined total of 13 league goals. In 9 fecking years...

We seemed to be suffering the same curse as Liverpool did with their no 7 after Kenny. They got Suarez eventually. Hopefully we can spot someone like that too.
 
Right now it feels like just a matter of time before the axe falls. However, I don't think he'll be sacked in the next few weeks, so he must now find a way to get some results and save his skin. Time is running out, he knows that.

If/when Jose is sacked, Woodward needs to go with him. The leadership at the club just now seems non-existent.

It won’t save our skins though. Even if he pulls some wins out of his arse, he’s clearly not the right man for this club now. He was when we needed a quick fix, but enough is fecking enough.
 
I think he is a quality manager, and I think the results so far are "unlucky".

If this form persists for a few more weeks I'm willing to admit that this is far more than variation. However I think the mindset of "fire him and then deal with it" is misguided and the reason why us fans shouldn't be involved in club management. I'd be willing to see him go as part of a wider strategy.

Five years or so not enough?
 
Genuine question to those who still support him. What is the logic behind it ?How do you see him turning things out around properly (not for a few games here and there) ?

Whoever supports Jose at this point must be the same type of folks that wanted to give moyes more time as well
 
If the club was pulling in one direction and we were playing badly and getting bad results, I’d be more inclined to ride it out.

My biggest issue is no one seems to be on the page. No one wants to be on the same page. Clear rifts. Clear divides.

Given all the rubbish we’ve seen in the news lately, if the players wanted Mourinho you’d have seen a reaction. You’d have seen desire. A willing to fight. And we didn’t. And that concerns me as it means they don’t like nor want him there.

Now, that doesn’t put blame solely in Mourinho. He needs to go, but heck if we think a new manager would fix our underlying problems, we are deluded. And it says a lot about our team if they act like this.
 
Right now it feels like just a matter of time before the axe falls. However, I don't think he'll be sacked in the next few weeks, so he must now find a way to get some results and save his skin. Time is running out, he knows that.

If/when Jose is sacked, Woodward needs to go with him. The leadership at the club just now seems non-existent.

Th club wants to hire a DoF which I have to think takes Woodward further away from personnel decisions
 
I'm not saying he's not responsible for overall results! He selects the players and tactics, so yes the buck stops with him.

My sack threshold is just high.

Fair enough. But, would you be disappointed/up in arms if he were to get sacked now?
 
Agree that they probably can't win the league on their quality alone, but they're certainly capable of good performances and a good league finish. If the next manager comes in and proves that he can get the players playing to their potential then yeah I'd trust him with more money to improve the squad. The horrible performances right now are a direct result of Mourinho being abysmally poor at coaching attacking play.

They are capable of it, for sure. We saw that last season with our 2nd place finish. We're being coached badly, and are horribly low on morale, not to mention effort. I don't think there's any doubt about that, and the manager has to be held accountable. I do however think we actually overachieved last season.

You are completely right, Jose has left an almighty mess that will take a few seasons to fix.

It's bizarre. I was cautiously optimistic after last season that we'd have an excellent window and start challenging in earnest. But I think that poor window killed us.

Honestly that's wrong, I'm not saying that they are great but history shows that players as a group can look very poor when the coaching staff is having a meltdown. Just in recent years, you can look at Chelsea or Bayern with Mourinho and Ancelotti. As much as people don't like that fact, the main influence of a manager is mental, they have the ability to destroy or build the spirit of a team.

They do. I won't disagree that the team are being coached poorly.
 
We could try something with our current no. 7 like playing him upfront, since he actually can play well as a striker.

Yeah I have hopes for Sanchez to start playing if we bring in a decent attacking coach.
 
Why does he still need a CB when he bought 2 of them already ?

Because Lindelöf is crap and Bailly need a cool headed partner to complement his aggressive style. Most of the goals we conceded is bad defending. If Alderweirld was signed I bet we conceded only half of the goals and not look so shaky at the back.

If you still doubt Mourinho, look at last season defensive record. He's a master of setting up a tight defence but he needed a world class centre back which we don't have since Vidic and Rio.
 
The similarity between Jose's third season with Chelsea and his current season with United is glaringly obvious, so much so that I'm shocked you do not see it.

I laughed at people when they suggested the same thing would happen with United, I couldn't for the life of me imagine us suffering the same fate, but it has happened. They were right. People need to be honest and admit it.

You echo my sentiments completely. I feel such a mug for believing and arguing that he would be different here... But it is what it is, we need to cut out the rot now.

We've seen sides be successful post Jose with the same players Jose has waged war on in the past so hopefully we also have that fate. Obviously I'd be super happy if he magically turned it around and we won the league miraculously but let's be real.

He's created a divisive atmosphere at the club, our own fans fight at every juncture its sad to watch. It's time to go.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Theonas
Status
Not open for further replies.