He annoyed me when he had a go at Rooney for getting Kompany sent off, and then proceeded to spend the next three or four games shamelessly patrolling the touchline, trying to influence referees into sending opponents off. This was around the same time he started complaining about injuries and lack of resources, because he was missing about 2 players. I've lost my sympathy since then.
He strikes me as being weak. He comes out, he says something that makes him sound weak, and then he leaves. As a player, it's not what you need when the pressure's piling up and you're begining to doubt yourself or lose your nerve.
I'm sure he's a likable bloke, but that means diddly squat really. It wont stop people scrutinising him if even after spending more money than any other manager in history, he still finishes second behind a walking injury list.
He kind of needs to lose to Fergie to learn from him though, but it's whether City will be patient enough to give him the chance.