Not really. We already know Dalot can play there and we just let Wan-Bissaka go so needed a backup right back anyway (though I expect Mazraoui to start).
The left-back market…
- Thread starter Rozay
- Start date
I like the suggestion for Robinson from Fulham. He definitely gets up & down the flank and is decent as a defender. Maybe some type of swap deal for McT.
Well yeah, but the reason we would have gone for Mazraoui is because he can cover LB as well as RB. If he wasn't able to do that, it would have been a waste of funds.
Should we not sign a DM and wait for Collyer as well?
There are generally four separate species of modern fullback these days.
The Gvardiol (wide centerback, great positioning, good ability to defend wide spaces and out on the touchline, good ball carrying)
The Trent (inverts into the pivot during build up, great passing, vision, midfielder in disguise)
The Trippier / Robertson / Hakimi (ye olde standard attacking fullback. Overlaps constantly, provides a lot of threat from crossing)
The Porro / Cancelo (underlaps into the attacking half space, basically a winger in disguise with their goal threat and final ball)
Given the balance of the side and mostly inferring from what other successful managers do, I think we need someone who closely resembles the Gvardiol type at LB. RB will be the Cancelo / Trippier mould.
The Gvardiol (wide centerback, great positioning, good ability to defend wide spaces and out on the touchline, good ball carrying)
The Trent (inverts into the pivot during build up, great passing, vision, midfielder in disguise)
The Trippier / Robertson / Hakimi (ye olde standard attacking fullback. Overlaps constantly, provides a lot of threat from crossing)
The Porro / Cancelo (underlaps into the attacking half space, basically a winger in disguise with their goal threat and final ball)
Given the balance of the side and mostly inferring from what other successful managers do, I think we need someone who closely resembles the Gvardiol type at LB. RB will be the Cancelo / Trippier mould.
What part of my post says we shouldn't buy a left back?
Have to say I really like the idea of signing Hermoso. Free, wouldn't be on huge wages and can play on either LCB or LB position. Hasn't played games at LB since 21/22 (according to Transfermarkt) but guess he'd still do alright there when needed and when none of Shaw/Malacia/Mazraoui/Dalot is available. Also rarely gets injured and is experienced player with probably another few years left at top level. And obviously a left-footed player and cover for Martinez. Of course, we'd have to sell Lindelof first (possibly Maguire as well).
Buy a sht LB to cover for our crocked LB's. If we sign Regulon a Tottenham reject that was sht for us to wait for Amass, then we might as well bin Ugarte and sign Amrabat and wait for Collyer.
- Joined
- Sep 1, 2015
- Messages
- 18,175
- Supports
️
The Wan Bissaka (shuts down a winger 1v1)
Probably in Gvardiol territory. Or they do the same thing and a bunch of other stuff that Walker and Wan Bisakka struggle with.
Starting Mazraoui at LB against Fulham makes sense for that specific game, but I’m against making it a long-term solution for two main reasons. First, Mazraoui is primarily a RB, not a LB. While he has occasionally played on the left for the Moroccan national team due to Hakimi's presence, he's only done so in 10 matches compared to 193 as a RB (according to Transfermarkt). He was brought in to compete with Dalot and serve as an upgrade over Wan-Bissaka, not to fill a LB role. Besides that, Mazraoui has been injury prone himself, not as frequently as Shaw, but still missed several games each season.
Second, relying on him as LB cover would leave us with just 2-3 reliable full-backs for two positions, which isn't ideal. Ideally, we’d target Ferdi, who can comfortably play on both sides (with 37 games as a RB and 68 as a LB). However, Ferdi might be out of our budget, especially with Ugarte being a higher priority. Alternatively, there are several decent LBs available for probably under €20 million, such as Locko, Dorgu, and Truffert.
Shaw, Malacia, Mazraoui and Amass need to cover LB this year, given midfield needs to be prioritised. Next year it can be revisited when we are clearer on the 4 and how they are performing
We can't spend big on a LB when we have a first choice in Shaw, cover for him, a youth prospect in that position and a Malacia - whatever you can classify him as. Even 20m euro is more than we spent on Mazraoui, which is essentially the same role we're filling on the left.
I don't think Shaw will repeat last season's 10 or so appearances, I would assume we'd get 20 or so out of him, I would hope Amas gets around 5 appearances, Mazraoui/Dalot maybe 10 at LB and we've even got the odd Martinez appearance there. So potentially, we're looking at perhaps 10-15 games to fill, I don't see how that's a priority. A loan or a free transfer would be a much wiser use of funds when we desperately need to improve the midfield.
Its not about filling the LB spot. Its trying to compete with really strong teams to get top 4. The league is tougher than ever. Man City and Arse are givens. For the other spots we will compete with Villa, Spurs, Liverpool, Newcastle, Chelsea. And we are going to do this with one top class LB in Shaw that might play 20 games if God shines upon us? We filled the LB spot last year - Ambrabat, Lindelof, Dalot, WB all played there. We can always find bodies to play there. But they are not good enough. And its not just a matter of effecting us defensively. Its our attack. Our whole balance. It will fk up Rashford. You cant just build a team and then make do with one position. It fks everything up. And a loan isnt the answer because that loan will still be sht.
Would Kieran Tierney be worth a punt on a loan? Seems he doesn't fit the profile at Arsenal but was always a good player.
This. We need a left-footed LB to play on the left, let Mazraoui and Dalot fight for the RB spot (when fit) and push each other to higher levels.
If you have an infinite amount of money, I would obviously sign a new left back.
Our main issue last season was our gaping midfield, no striker besides Hojlund and lack of CBs. We've addressed the CB situation with De Ligt and Yoro, added Zirkzee to have another striker, but we haven't addressed the midfield. 4th priority is a LB, that means it's the least amount of cash earmarked for it. You have to make a priority decision, you can't just make everything no. 1 prioirty - you're sounding like my exec team at my company.
We first need to get Ugarte for less money than PSG want, sell McTominay, Lindelof and hopefully Sancho (although unlikely at this point). Then there's still money to get a 20m-rated LB I guess?
Good player but a lot of injury problems
Only the the 4 prospective deals holding this up then! I even think if something happens with Sancho with Chelsea, we'll likely include one of their left back, so it could be solved earlier than that. I think if we do get cash in, we'll go back for someone like Ait-Nouri (not sure he'd be my choice). Until then, a loan or free transfer is the best we can plan for.
Good player but probably has as many if not more issues with injury that Shaw.
How many United LBs do you need to change a light bulb at the opposite corner flag ?
Would it be crazy to try a loan for joão cancelo?
For those wishing for Bradley Locko, he's just suffered a Ruptured Achilles do that's him out of a move. Stade Brestois are my second team so just saw the confirmation now.
Why do people keep saying loan Regullion? He wasn’t great and was injured himself for a bit. It’s just literally getting a body
This is a better idea than Regullion
There will always be a space in the squad for a decent midfielder, left back at most is only ever going to have two spaces in each match day squad.
It’s unfortunate that Amass isn’t a few years older but we really can’t drop big money on a left back with such a promising player to come in soon. Ten Hag seemed to suggested he’s not far off being ready, so even cover for one year should be enough. Three permanent first team left backs ahead of Amass would be shit.
I wasn't very clear, but I meant a Regullion type transfer, as in low cost.
He's still a City player. Can't see them sanctioning that.
Is he still on loan from them? Oh then that’s a different matter. Shame. Bet he would have loved proving Pep wrong
Yep, I think City were hoping Barcelona would sign him permanently, but they couldn't find another financial lever lying around anywhere
noooooooo
Get in Antonee Robinson to replace Shaw.
Will cost a lot of money. His defensive performance today was OK, I like his aggressiveness. Attacking contributions were near zero.
Chilwell can’t stay fit either
Potential future French international LB. Locko would have been my first choive but Truffert is also good. If he's available for less than 15m, get him in.
Yeah if he could be obtained for similar money to Mazraoui then would be shrewd business
I’d rather go abroad and get in a younger, cheaper player and develop him rather than pay £50m for a premier league player.