Ekeke i'm not neccessarily disagreeing with your points about WOW gameplay wise it is simplistic however the number of players it has is astonishing and that what FF will be up against, WOWs players have become so indoctrinated and ingrained into its community that wrestling them away will take something spectacular imo. If all FFXIV does is repeat its previous incarnation and copy/steal things from WOW its got nothing to offer other than console support which will make it crucial to its success (in the west anyway)
i never got to play XI, dont think it came to PS though i know it did the 360, from what i know it is still supported and has a reasonable following in the east but very little in the western terrotories
I really liked XII, i think its underated - its as good as VIII imo which was too emo-like for my tastes
XIII was a massive disappointment, i finished the story but have no desire to go back and fight the bigger enemies