Stars and Reserves Draft - Winner: Gio

00229E6F00000258-0-image-a-23_1442318547326.jpg
 
1. GodShaveTheQueen - 1) *D. Dzajic 2) *K. Hamrin 3) O. Sivori 4) I. Netto 5) R. Bonhof 6) I. Rush 7) R. Ferri

2. Brwned - 1) *M. Laudrup 2) M. Salah 3) ^L. Sane 4) R. Varane 5) *L. Modric 6) *L. Junior 7) Leandro

3. Michaelf7777777/cubemine - 1) R. Bochini 2) G. Bulgarelli 3. R. Benetti 4) Germano (POR) 5) R. Gordillo 6) D. Bertoni 7) I. Casillas

4. Šjor Bepo/Pat_Mustard - 1) N. Liedholm 2) *O. Blokhin 3) E. Francescoli 4) A. Benarrivo 5) K. De Bruyne 6) Maicon 7) J. Terry

5. EAP/Indy/OneNil - 1) *U. Seeler 2) W. Sagnol 3) *B. Lizarazu 4) D. Blanchflower 5) L. Brady 6) G. Popescu 7) *Kaka

6. Jim Beam/Invictus - 1) *H. Stoichkov 2) F. Albert 3) *J. Bozsik 4) D. Villa 5) M. Silva 6) A. Amaro 7) O. Kahn

7. Don Alfredo - 1) *P. Nedved 2) C. Vieri 3) J. Heynckes 4) P. Evra 5) V. van Dijk 6) ^M. De Ligt 7) C. Gamarra

8. P-Nut0712/Arbitrium - 1) Neymar 2) ^J. Kimmich 3) J. Veron 4) *K-H Schnellinger 5) C. Puyol 6) N. Stiles 7) *A. Shesternyov

9. Moby - 1) *Jairzinho 2) *Rivelino 3) *B. Schuster 4) ^L. Hernandez 5) R. Bratseth 6) S. Lerby 7) M. Essien

10. green_smiley -1) K. Keegan 2) A. Simonsen 3) F. Ribery 4) H-G Schwarzenbeck 5) *E. Gerets 6) H. Blankenburg 7) *H-P. Briegel

11. Gio - 1) *F. Gento 2) D. Savicevic 3) H. Sanchez 4) W. Schulz 5) B. Bremner 6) *G. Rivera 7) R. Rosato

12. Physiocrat - 1) *T. Finney 2) J. Barnes 3) M. Olsen 4) *W. Overath 5. M. Tassotti 6. H. Crespo 7. E. Hughes

13. MJJ - 1) N. Kante 2) P. Pogba 3) W. Rooney 4) *Marcelo 5) K. Mbappe 6) O .Bergmark 7) ^M. Skriniar

14. Ecstatic - 1) *J. Greaves 2) *D. Beckham 3) *R. Giggs 4) *P. Vieira 5) K. Dalglish 6) D. Mackay 7) J. Armfield

15. Skizzo - 1) E. Cantona 2) A. Shearer 3) A. Hansen 4) D. Irwin 5) R. Donadoni 6) T. Adams 7) P. Shilton 8) P. Cocu

16. Himannv/2mufc0 - 1) *R. Kopa 2) A. Costacurta 3) E. Hazard 4) S. Aguero 5) S. Effenberg 6) G. Bale 7) *M. Amoros 8) G. Zambrotta

@Ecstatic
 
Anyone around to take my pick?
 
First Round Draw
1st round draw:

Šjor Bepo/Pat_Mustard vs Brwned
Ecstatic vs Jim Beam/Invictus
Michaelf7777777/cubemine
vs green_smiley
Himannv/2mufc0 vs Skizzo
GodShaveTheQueen vs Gio
MJJ vs Moby
P-Nut0712/Arbitrium vs Don Alfredo
EAP/Indy/OneNil vs Physiocrat

@Don Alfredo
 
@Gio What a pick. The best stopper in the reserve pool, I just couldn't pick him because I had him in the last draft. Crazy that he went in round 7.
Big big stretch IMO. Was surprised to see him in the block list initially. He has top credentials, but my impression of him is that he had a relatively short frame for a stopper, wasn't very agile and as an individual I wouldn't place him that much ahead of Giarneri or Ferri for example. Definitely below Bratseth and Adams.
 
Big big stretch IMO. Was surprised to see him in the block list initially. He has top credentials, but my impression of him is that he had a relatively short frame for a stopper, wasn't very agile and as an individual I wouldn't place him that much ahead of Giarneri or Ferri for example. Definitely below Bratseth and Adams.

Bratseth was a sweeper, he doesn't belong into the stopper discussion:D

Adams is a good one, although his England career wasn't that great.

Is it heresy if I say that the level in England wasn't that high in the early/mid 90s? I have heard it on several occasions (also as a stick to beat Cantona with) and English clubs have been much less prominent in the European Cup compared to Italian / German / Spanish clubs. It was clearly the 4th best league in Europe at that time and English clubs had just one appearance in the final of the EC/CL in that decade, which was United in 99.
 
MJJ picks Kenny Samson

1. GodShaveTheQueen
- 1) *D. Dzajic 2) *K. Hamrin 3) O. Sivori 4) I. Netto 5) R. Bonhof 6) I. Rush 7) R. Ferri

2. Brwned - 1) *M. Laudrup 2) M. Salah 3) ^L. Sane 4) R. Varane 5) *L. Modric 6) *L. Junior 7) Leandro

3. Michaelf7777777/cubemine - 1) R. Bochini 2) G. Bulgarelli 3. R. Benetti 4) Germano (POR) 5) R. Gordillo 6) D. Bertoni 7) I. Casillas

4. Šjor Bepo/Pat_Mustard - 1) N. Liedholm 2) *O. Blokhin 3) E. Francescoli 4) A. Benarrivo 5) K. De Bruyne 6) Maicon 7) J. Terry

5. EAP/Indy/OneNil - 1) *U. Seeler 2) W. Sagnol 3) *B. Lizarazu 4) D. Blanchflower 5) L. Brady 6) G. Popescu 7) *Kaka

6. Jim Beam/Invictus - 1) *H. Stoichkov 2) F. Albert 3) *J. Bozsik 4) D. Villa 5) M. Silva 6) A. Amaro 7) O. Kahn

7. Don Alfredo - 1) *P. Nedved 2) C. Vieri 3) J. Heynckes 4) P. Evra 5) V. van Dijk 6) ^M. De Ligt 7) C. Gamarra

8. P-Nut0712/Arbitrium - 1) Neymar 2) ^J. Kimmich 3) J. Veron 4) *K-H Schnellinger 5) C. Puyol 6) N. Stiles 7) *A. Shesternyov

9. Moby - 1) *Jairzinho 2) *Rivelino 3) *B. Schuster 4) ^L. Hernandez 5) R. Bratseth 6) S. Lerby 7) M. Essien

10. green_smiley -1) K. Keegan 2) A. Simonsen 3) F. Ribery 4) H-G Schwarzenbeck 5) *E. Gerets 6) H. Blankenburg 7) *H-P. Briegel

11. Gio - 1) *F. Gento 2) D. Savicevic 3) H. Sanchez 4) W. Schulz 5) B. Bremner 6) *G. Rivera 7) R. Rosato

12. Physiocrat - 1) *T. Finney 2) J. Barnes 3) M. Olsen 4) *W. Overath 5. M. Tassotti 6. H. Crespo 7. E. Hughes

13. MJJ - 1) N. Kante 2) P. Pogba 3) W. Rooney 4) *Marcelo 5) K. Mbappe 6) O .Bergmark 7) ^M. Skriniar 8) K. Samson

14. Ecstatic - 1) *J. Greaves 2) *D. Beckham 3) *R. Giggs 4) *P. Vieira 5) K. Dalglish 6) D. Mackay 7) J. Armfield 8) J. Popluhár

15. Skizzo - 1) E. Cantona 2) A. Shearer 3) A. Hansen 4) D. Irwin 5) R. Donadoni 6) T. Adams 7) P. Shilton 8) P. Cocu

16. Himannv/2mufc0 - 1) *R. Kopa 2) A. Costacurta 3) E. Hazard 4) S. Aguero 5) S. Effenberg 6) G. Bale 7) *M. Amoros 8) G. Zambrotta

@Physiocrat
 
Bratseth was a sweeper, he doesn't belong into the stopper discussion:D

Adams is a good one, although his England career wasn't that great.

Is it heresy if I say that the level in England wasn't that high in the early/mid 90s? I have heard it on several occasions (also as a stick to beat Cantona with) and English clubs have been much less prominent in the European Cup compared to Italian / German / Spanish clubs. It was clearly the 4th best league in Europe at that time and English clubs had just one appearance in the final of the EC/CL in that decade, which was United in 99.


Bratseth was both tbh. A bit like Figueroa. His individual credentials top Rosato in every sense IMO. He was incredibly fast for 193cm in height and was tough, strong and could read the game better. Rosato was a man marker and primarily stopper but put him against Vieri type who could bully him or Romario/Owen type with excellent technique and low center of gravity and he'll struggle.

The English league was hit by Heysel and they did serve a 5-6 years ban from playing in Europe. In the mid/late 90's still you had Arsenal, Chelsea, United playing in CWC and Uefa cup finals and also United making it into the latter stages of CL.

England had a good outing in the 96 EURO and generally had some quality players, especially United and Arsenal. Serie A was by far ahead of the pack and was brimmed with quality, but I wouldn't say the gap between each of Germany/Spain/England was that big at the time.
 
Big big stretch IMO. Was surprised to see him in the block list initially. He has top credentials, but my impression of him is that he had a relatively short frame for a stopper, wasn't very agile and as an individual I wouldn't place him that much ahead of Giarneri or Ferri for example. Definitely below Bratseth and Adams.



Needs more agility ;)

Bratseth was both tbh. A bit like Figueroa. His individual credentials top Rosato in every sense IMO. He was incredibly fast for 193cm in height and was tough, strong and could read the game better. Rosato was a man marker and primarily stopper but put him against Vieri type who could bully him or Romario/Owen type with excellent technique and low center of gravity and he'll struggle.
There isn't a centre-half in the pool who would excel in both of those scenarios.
Bratseth was a sweeper, he doesn't belong into the stopper discussion:D

Adams is a good one, although his England career wasn't that great.

Is it heresy if I say that the level in England wasn't that high in the early/mid 90s? I have heard it on several occasions (also as a stick to beat Cantona with) and English clubs have been much less prominent in the European Cup compared to Italian / German / Spanish clubs. It was clearly the 4th best league in Europe at that time and English clubs had just one appearance in the final of the EC/CL in that decade, which was United in 99.
Well true. Rosato's top-level credentials are first rate - best central defender in arguably the best World Cup of all time - when he shut out an on-fire Gerd Muller for 95 minutes in the semi until he went off injured. And then Muller quickly grabbed a double once he'd left the park. Also part of the miserly defence that won Euro '68. At club level he was the bedrock behind the great Milan team that won the European Cup in '69, the Intercontinental Cup and the ECWC in both '68 and '73.

For what it's worth @Don Alfredo Rosato was third on my 30-man list of non-starred stoppers and you could make a case for a small handful of CBs as being the best of that pool. But as ever it was about the fit and I thought he would complement Schulz nicely.
 
1. GodShaveTheQueen - 1) *D. Dzajic 2) *K. Hamrin 3) O. Sivori 4) I. Netto 5) R. Bonhof 6) I. Rush 7) R. Ferri

2. Brwned - 1) *M. Laudrup 2) M. Salah 3) ^L. Sane 4) R. Varane 5) *L. Modric 6) *L. Junior 7) Leandro

3. Michaelf7777777/cubemine - 1) R. Bochini 2) G. Bulgarelli 3. R. Benetti 4) Germano (POR) 5) R. Gordillo 6) D. Bertoni 7) I. Casillas

4. Šjor Bepo/Pat_Mustard - 1) N. Liedholm 2) *O. Blokhin 3) E. Francescoli 4) A. Benarrivo 5) K. De Bruyne 6) Maicon 7) J. Terry

5. EAP/Indy/OneNil - 1) *U. Seeler 2) W. Sagnol 3) *B. Lizarazu 4) D. Blanchflower 5) L. Brady 6) G. Popescu 7) *Kaka

6. Jim Beam/Invictus - 1) *H. Stoichkov 2) F. Albert 3) *J. Bozsik 4) D. Villa 5) M. Silva 6) A. Amaro 7) O. Kahn

7. Don Alfredo - 1) *P. Nedved 2) C. Vieri 3) J. Heynckes 4) P. Evra 5) V. van Dijk 6) ^M. De Ligt 7) C. Gamarra

8. P-Nut0712/Arbitrium - 1) Neymar 2) ^J. Kimmich 3) J. Veron 4) *K-H Schnellinger 5) C. Puyol 6) N. Stiles 7) *A. Shesternyov

9. Moby - 1) *Jairzinho 2) *Rivelino 3) *B. Schuster 4) ^L. Hernandez 5) R. Bratseth 6) S. Lerby 7) M. Essien

10. green_smiley -1) K. Keegan 2) A. Simonsen 3) F. Ribery 4) H-G Schwarzenbeck 5) *E. Gerets 6) H. Blankenburg 7) *H-P Briegel

11. Gio - 1) *F. Gento 2) D. Savicevic 3) H. Sanchez 4) W. Schulz 5) B. Bremner 6) *G. Rivera 7) R. Rosato

12. Physiocrat - 1) *T. Finney 2) J. Barnes 3) M. Olsen 4) *W. Overath 5. M. Tassotti 6. H. Crespo 7) E. Hughes 8) F. Collovati

13. MJJ - 1) N. Kante 2) P. Pogba 3) W. Rooney 4) *Marcelo 5) K. Mbappe 6) O .Bergmark 7) ^M. Skriniar 8) K. Samson

14. Ecstatic - 1) *J. Greaves 2) *D. Beckham 3) *R. Giggs 4) *P. Vieira 5) K. Dalglish 6) D. Mackay 7) J. Armfield 8) J. Popluhár

15. Skizzo - 1) E. Cantona 2) A. Shearer 3) A. Hansen 4) D. Irwin 5) R. Donadoni 6) T. Adams 7) P. Shilton 8) P. Cocu

16. Himannv/2mufc0 - 1) *R. Kopa 2) A. Costacurta 3) E. Hazard 4) S. Aguero 5) S. Effenberg 6) G. Bale 7) *M. Amoros 8) G. Zambrotta
 


Needs more agility ;)


There isn't a centre-half in the pool who would excel in both of those scenarios.

Well true. Rosato's top-level credentials are first rate - best central defender in arguably the best World Cup of all time - when he shut out an on-fire Gerd Muller for 95 minutes in the semi until he went off injured. And then Muller quickly grabbed a double once he'd left the park. Also part of the miserly defence that won Euro '68. At club level he was the bedrock behind the great Milan team that won the European Cup in '69, the Intercontinental Cup and the ECWC in both '68 and '73.

For what it's worth @Don Alfredo Rosato was third on my 30-man list of non-starred stoppers and you could make a case for a small handful of CBs as being the best of that pool. But as ever it was about the fit and I thought he would complement Schulz nicely.


Can I get the first two, by pm preferably, thanks!
 
1. GodShaveTheQueen - 1) *D. Dzajic 2) *K. Hamrin 3) O. Sivori 4) I. Netto 5) R. Bonhof 6) I. Rush 7) R. Ferri

2. Brwned - 1) *M. Laudrup 2) M. Salah 3) ^L. Sane 4) R. Varane 5) *L. Modric 6) *L. Junior 7) Leandro

3. Michaelf7777777/cubemine - 1) R. Bochini 2) G. Bulgarelli 3. R. Benetti 4) Germano (POR) 5) R. Gordillo 6) D. Bertoni 7) I. Casillas

4. Šjor Bepo/Pat_Mustard - 1) N. Liedholm 2) *O. Blokhin 3) E. Francescoli 4) A. Benarrivo 5) K. De Bruyne 6) Maicon 7) J. Terry

5. EAP/Indy/OneNil - 1) *U. Seeler 2) W. Sagnol 3) *B. Lizarazu 4) D. Blanchflower 5) L. Brady 6) G. Popescu 7) *Kaka

6. Jim Beam/Invictus - 1) *H. Stoichkov 2) F. Albert 3) *J. Bozsik 4) D. Villa 5) M. Silva 6) A. Amaro 7) O. Kahn

7. Don Alfredo - 1) *P. Nedved 2) C. Vieri 3) J. Heynckes 4) P. Evra 5) V. van Dijk 6) ^M. De Ligt 7) C. Gamarra

8. P-Nut0712/Arbitrium - 1) Neymar 2) ^J. Kimmich 3) J. Veron 4) *K-H Schnellinger 5) C. Puyol 6) N. Stiles 7) *A. Shesternyov

9. Moby - 1) *Jairzinho 2) *Rivelino 3) *B. Schuster 4) ^L. Hernandez 5) R. Bratseth 6) S. Lerby 7) M. Essien

10. green_smiley -1) K. Keegan 2) A. Simonsen 3) F. Ribery 4) H-G Schwarzenbeck 5) *E. Gerets 6) H. Blankenburg 7) *H-P Briegel 8) V. Jugovic

11. Gio - 1) *F. Gento 2) D. Savicevic 3) H. Sanchez 4) W. Schulz 5) B. Bremner 6) *G. Rivera 7) R. Rosato 8) R. Dzodzuashvili

12. Physiocrat - 1) *T. Finney 2) J. Barnes 3) M. Olsen 4) *W. Overath 5. M. Tassotti 6. H. Crespo 7) E. Hughes 8) F. Collovati

13. MJJ - 1) N. Kante 2) P. Pogba 3) W. Rooney 4) *Marcelo 5) K. Mbappe 6) O .Bergmark 7) ^M. Skriniar 8) K. Samson

14. Ecstatic - 1) *J. Greaves 2) *D. Beckham 3) *R. Giggs 4) *P. Vieira 5) K. Dalglish 6) D. Mackay 7) J. Armfield 8) J. Popluhár

15. Skizzo - 1) E. Cantona 2) A. Shearer 3) A. Hansen 4) D. Irwin 5) R. Donadoni 6) T. Adams 7) P. Shilton 8) P. Cocu

16. Himannv/2mufc0 - 1) *R. Kopa 2) A. Costacurta 3) E. Hazard 4) S. Aguero 5) S. Effenberg 6) G. Bale 7) *M. Amoros 8) G. Zambrotta

@Moby
 


Needs more agility ;)

Not sure what that has to prove :) Rosato wasn't even pinned for starter at that WC. He had a great one, but similar case can be made about someone like Gamarra.

Italy played in a back three that game as well and he had plenty of help to call it one man job.


There isn't a centre-half in the pool who would excel in both of those scenarios.

Well true. Rosato's top-level credentials are first rate - best central defender in arguably the best World Cup of all time - when he shut out an on-fire Gerd Muller for 95 minutes in the semi until he went off injured. And then Muller quickly grabbed a double once he'd left the park. Also part of the miserly defence that won Euro '68. At club level he was the bedrock behind the great Milan team that won the European Cup in '69, the Intercontinental Cup and the ECWC in both '68 and '73.

At the 68' EURO he didn't play. Not sure if he had any minutes but probably a game or so in the qualies. Guarneri and Burgnich were the preferred options in the stopper role.

He has excellent credentials as I've mentioned but individually hasn't struck me at being much better than the other Italian stoppers like Ferri, Collovati and Guarneri, who are in the lower tier to Gentile, Bergomi and the likes.
 
1. GodShaveTheQueen - 1) *D. Dzajic 2) *K. Hamrin 3) O. Sivori 4) I. Netto 5) R. Bonhof 6) I. Rush 7) R. Ferri

2. Brwned - 1) *M. Laudrup 2) M. Salah 3) ^L. Sane 4) R. Varane 5) *L. Modric 6) *L. Junior 7) Leandro

3. Michaelf7777777/cubemine - 1) R. Bochini 2) G. Bulgarelli 3. R. Benetti 4) Germano (POR) 5) R. Gordillo 6) D. Bertoni 7) I. Casillas

4. Šjor Bepo/Pat_Mustard - 1) N. Liedholm 2) *O. Blokhin 3) E. Francescoli 4) A. Benarrivo 5) K. De Bruyne 6) Maicon 7) J. Terry

5. EAP/Indy/OneNil - 1) *U. Seeler 2) W. Sagnol 3) *B. Lizarazu 4) D. Blanchflower 5) L. Brady 6) G. Popescu 7) *Kaka

6. Jim Beam/Invictus - 1) *H. Stoichkov 2) F. Albert 3) *J. Bozsik 4) D. Villa 5) M. Silva 6) A. Amaro 7) O. Kahn

7. Don Alfredo - 1) *P. Nedved 2) C. Vieri 3) J. Heynckes 4) P. Evra 5) V. van Dijk 6) ^M. De Ligt 7) C. Gamarra

8. P-Nut0712/Arbitrium - 1) Neymar 2) ^J. Kimmich 3) J. Veron 4) *K-H Schnellinger 5) C. Puyol 6) N. Stiles 7) *A. Shesternyov

9. Moby - 1) *Jairzinho 2) *Rivelino 3) *B. Schuster 4) ^L. Hernandez 5) R. Bratseth 6) S. Lerby 7) M. Essien 8) P. Rossi

10. green_smiley -1) K. Keegan 2) A. Simonsen 3) F. Ribery 4) H-G Schwarzenbeck 5) *E. Gerets 6) H. Blankenburg 7) *H-P Briegel 8) V. Jugovic

11. Gio - 1) *F. Gento 2) D. Savicevic 3) H. Sanchez 4) W. Schulz 5) B. Bremner 6) *G. Rivera 7) R. Rosato 8) R. Dzodzuashvili

12. Physiocrat - 1) *T. Finney 2) J. Barnes 3) M. Olsen 4) *W. Overath 5. M. Tassotti 6. H. Crespo 7) E. Hughes 8) F. Collovati

13. MJJ - 1) N. Kante 2) P. Pogba 3) W. Rooney 4) *Marcelo 5) K. Mbappe 6) O .Bergmark 7) ^M. Skriniar 8) K. Samson

14. Ecstatic - 1) *J. Greaves 2) *D. Beckham 3) *R. Giggs 4) *P. Vieira 5) K. Dalglish 6) D. Mackay 7) J. Armfield 8) J. Popluhár

15. Skizzo - 1) E. Cantona 2) A. Shearer 3) A. Hansen 4) D. Irwin 5) R. Donadoni 6) T. Adams 7) P. Shilton 8) P. Cocu

16. Himannv/2mufc0 - 1) *R. Kopa 2) A. Costacurta 3) E. Hazard 4) S. Aguero 5) S. Effenberg 6) G. Bale 7) *M. Amoros 8) G. Zambrotta

@P-Nut0712 @Arbitrium
 
260px-Revaz_Dzodzuashvili_c1970.jpg


Look at that 1000-yard stare. Revaz ain't fecking around.

@green_smiley
Nice. Best is so scared of him that he opted to stay out of the draft :drool:
Seriously though, proven record against Best, Dzajic, good showings against Jairzinho and Lubanski!
 
Snap! Unpicked player names everywhere!:nono:

There are loads of gems left, so

NO NAMING OF UNPICKED RESERVE / YOUNG PLAYERS!

You can talk about unpicked Star Players and Blocked players as much as you want, but it stops right after that:)

Just a reminder:)
 
At the 68' EURO he didn't play. Not sure if he had any minutes but probably a game or so in the qualies. Guarneri and Burgnich were the preferred options in the stopper role.
Well I said he was part of the squad - they were after all 3-game tournaments - and he played the final that was replayed when Italy defeated Yugoslavia 2-0.
Nice. Best is so scared of him that he opted to stay out of the draft :drool:
Seriously though, proven record against Best, Dzajic, good showings against Jairzinho and Lubanski!
At least George got his shirt:

DSouesjXUAgaLY9.jpg
 
1st round draw:

Šjor Bepo/Pat_Mustard vs Brwned
Ecstatic
vs Jim Beam/Invictus
Michaelf7777777/cubemine
vs green_smiley
Himannv/2mufc0
vs Skizzo
GodShaveTheQueen
vs Gio
MJJ
vs Moby
P-Nut0712/Arbitrium
vs Don Alfredo
EAP/Indy/OneNil
vs Physiocrat

@Don Alfredo

Oh, do feck off! Like ecstatic, hate seeing him go out in first round.
 
Can't believe I've drawn @Pat_Mustard in the 1st round again. Only now he's got backup! Time for revenge...

Its funny that our teams are shaping up quite similarly so far in terms of the profile of players...might need to change course to make it a bit more interesting!
 
Can't believe I've drawn @Pat_Mustard in the 1st round again. Only now he's got backup! Time for revenge...

Its funny that our teams are shaping up quite similarly so far in terms of the profile of players...might need to change course to make it a bit more interesting!

I'm like a turd you just can't flush ;)