SARS CoV-2 coronavirus / Covid-19 (No tin foil hat silliness please)

I have no evidence to suggest that the first lockdown in Italy was not strictly followed or enforced, do you?
It is widely known that from Around Dec to Jan the Chinese government was telling medical workers to stay quiet and was downplaying the human to human transmission capacity of the virus to the international community.

Based on the above plus the way the virus has acted in other countries my opinion is that the stats for China are like the guy in fifa or FM who edits his team stats and gives Xhaka 90/100 for discipline
Well we have 2 posters here who live in Italy who could answer that part for you

@Penna @11101
 
Well we have 2 posters here who live in Italy who could answer that part for you

@Penna @11101
It was strictly enforced, yes. Your movements were very limited and you had to fill in a form to carry with you every single time you left the house. There were lots of police around and they stopped you and checked your documents, even when you were on foot.
 
It was strictly enforced, yes. Your movements were very limited and you had to fill in a form to carry with you every single time you left the house. There were lots of police around and they stopped you and checked your documents, even when you were on foot.
That’s what I thought. I remember your posts at the time
 
It was strictly enforced, yes. Your movements were very limited and you had to fill in a form to carry with you every single time you left the house. There were lots of police around and they stopped you and checked your documents, even when you were on foot.

Yeah, we had Army helicopters overhead looking for people outside and directing police to them. It was no joke for that first few months.
 
That’s what I thought. I remember your posts at the time
Exactly what I thought too. I remember the news, I remember the coverage, I don’t think any of us will forget the images of people in their apartment balconies etc and dead streets of Rome, Milan, and other parts of Italy.
So I don’t really get why @horsechoker was insinuation that the lockdown in Italy wasn’t followed or enforced.

Also should be noted, China never had a nation wide lockdown as strict as Wuhan in other parts of China, it’s strict lockdowns were mostly regional. So yes the numbers for China’s first wave and the way its flattened since are very odd and most likely BS.
 
Exactly what I thought too. I remember the news, I remember the coverage, I don’t think any of us will forget the images of people in their apartment balconies etc and dead streets of Rome, Milan, and other parts of Italy.
So I don’t really get why @horsechoker was insinuation that the lockdown in Italy wasn’t followed or enforced.

Also should be noted, China never had a nation wide lockdown as strict as Wuhan in other parts of China, it’s strict lockdowns were mostly regional. So yes the numbers for China’s first wave and the way its flattened since are very odd and most likely BS.
I don’t think it takes a rocket scientist to work out that china’s numbers are inaccurate at best
 
For anyone with experience/clearer on the current rules - I'm heading to Berlin for a few days on Friday. Double vaccinated a while ago. From what I can find online, all I need is proof of this with no PCR testing going either way, is that correct?

Much appreciated in advance!
 
I was referring to people who cannot get a vaccine due to an immune response, as was evident by the second sentence.

Do you mean people who can't be vaccinated because they have an autoimmune condition?

Why should under 16's be part of the discussion when they have not been offered the vaccine anyway?

Over 12's are being vaccinated in many countries and the US and elsewhere are planning to vaccinate the over 5's when Phizer is approved for that age group before the end of the year. And it is important as HIT requires a certain % of the whole population to be vaccinated and not just adults.

Not all countries agree on what are the medical exemptions. There may not be agreement regarding which are the accepted vaccine manufacturers as well as dose intervals. There is also still no clear idea about how booster jabs will affect the passports . People who participated in trials have been left in limbo [1] [2]. Industry figures have also hinted that there are some logistical issues [3]. Have you got any data or articles which suggests otherwise?

There are very few real grounds for a medical exemption and I'm sure each country can work that out. Internationally I doubt medical exemptions will be accepted. Vaccinated or you aren't allowed in will be the rule.

There are bound to be logistic issues. So what? They can be sorted out.

People in trials of non or yet to be approved vaccines should either be granted special approval or allowed to take an approved vaccine.

Equally people with anti-vax views also work and pay tax, so they too should receive the same benefits as anyone else who pays tax.

Merely paying tax doesn't give you the right to do what you like. Drinkers and smokers are restricted and taxed to partially compensate for the burden they place on medical facilities. So should the unvaccinated. Increased Medicare levy, restricted employment opportunities and travel restrictions at the very least. And not just for covid.

There were 7000+ accidents related to drink driving alone in 2019 [4] and alcohol may cost NHS England £3.5 billion per year [5]. There are also numerous statistics which show alcohol influences crime which affects people in other ways such as violence and child neglect (see [6] and sources therein). It is certainly fair to say that in the short-term, Covid has had a profound affect but alcohol remains a serious issue in the UK.

What is your point in relation to covid passports?

Thankfully policy usually has to go several times through the commons and lords and is not passed on a whim.

And thankfully I no longer live in the UK.
 
The lockdown in Italy was very strict. Yet they have had 2-3 waves. I look at the stats, look at China’s early reaction which was based on silly PR and denial.. and think nothing has changed.
What you call a strict lickdown in italy is a breeze compared with the lockdown type in wuhan. Also the control type with subsequent outbreaks.

More astringent, people following the rules more and way way way more resources dumped on tracking in an astonishing fast reaction than any other country in the world could ever dream off
 
Do you mean people who can't be vaccinated because they have an autoimmune condition?

Yes.

Over 12's are being vaccinated in many countries and the US and elsewhere are planning to vaccinate the over 5's when Phizer is approved for that age group before the end of the year. And it is important as HIT requires a certain % of the whole population to be vaccinated and not just adults.

Okay, but that is already starting to happen [1].

There are very few real grounds for a medical exemption and I'm sure each country can work that out. Internationally I doubt medical exemptions will be accepted. Vaccinated or you aren't allowed in will be the rule.

There are bound to be logistic issues. So what? They can be sorted out.

Ah yes, let us ignore industry experts because you think they can be sorted out. :rolleyes: Also let us introduce a policy which discriminates against people with medical exemptions?

People in trials of non or yet to be approved vaccines should either be granted special approval or allowed to take an approved vaccine.

Based on what evidence?

Merely paying tax doesn't give you the right to do what you like. Drinkers and smokers are restricted and taxed to partially compensate for the burden they place on medical facilities. So should the unvaccinated. Increased Medicare levy, restricted employment opportunities and travel restrictions at the very least. And not just for covid.

Not doing anything illegal gives you all societal benefits with which you are applicable. This is just a fact. Why you keep debating this I am not sure.

What is your point in relation to covid passports?

Since you are so in favour of Covid passports, please comment on whether we should also introduce alcohol passports and other related health passports and would they equally have your full support.

And thankfully I no longer live in the UK.

So stop talking about the UK with regards to its politics, legislation and people when it no longer affects you?
 
Last edited:
For what it's worth there has been virtually no opposition to the extended Covid Pass in Italy, a country where ignoring rules is seen as a national sport. Everybody realises it's for the societal good.
 
For what it's worth there has been virtually no opposition to the extended Covid Pass in Italy, a country where ignoring rules is seen as a national sport. Everybody realises it's for the societal good.

Whether the majority supports something or not is no indication of whether it is a good policy. For example, in the UK, ~50% of people supported Brexit in the referendum which has to date, caused nothing but problems.
 
Whether the majority supports something or not is no indication of whether it is a good policy. For example, in the UK, ~50% of people supported Brexit in the referendum which has to date, caused nothing but problems.

No, but when those who think its a bad policy also think the earth is flat and George Bush blew up the twin towers, you're on safer ground.
 
No, but when those who think its a bad policy also think the earth is flat and George Bush blew up the twin towers, you're on safer ground.

Ah right, so no one can critique the policy without you thinking they have extreme views. This is despite the fact that you have yet to raise any counter-arguments to the issues raised. Honestly, that sort of mindset is no different to the very people that you mock.
 
Ah right, so no one can critique the policy without you thinking they have extreme views. This is despite the fact that you have yet to raise any counter-arguments to the issues raised. Honestly, that sort of mindset is no different to the very people that you mock.

There is really very little to critique about the concept of a Green Pass. The science behind the vaccine is overwhelming and policy is now moving away from encouraging people to overcome doubts and get the vaccine, its becoming about making sure the hardline anti-vaxxers can't be in a position to compromise other people as we get back to normal life.
 
policy is now moving away from encouraging people to overcome doubts and get the vaccine, its becoming about making sure the hardline anti-vaxxers can't be in a position to compromise other people as we get back to normal life.

So once again, you fail to address any of the issues raised.
 
For what it's worth there has been virtually no opposition to the extended Covid Pass in Italy, a country where ignoring rules is seen as a national sport. Everybody realises it's for the societal good.

In a democracy, a referendum for this type of measures should be organised... Not sure if "everybody" will vote yes.
 
I’ve no idea what that’s a photograph of but it isn’t a “covid detention centre”. There does seem to be plans for something along those lines in Victoria but they’ve only just started digging.

Is sharing fake news a thread bannable offence?
Even if it's not I think an exception should be made in this case.
 
Ah right, so no one can critique the policy without you thinking they have extreme views. This is despite the fact that you have yet to raise any counter-arguments to the issues raised. Honestly, that sort of mindset is no different to the very people that you mock.

You are absolutely right.

Let's say there are two type of extremists
(1) those who believe Covid does not exist, and
(2) those obsessed with the restriction of fundamental freedoms including the freedom of thought
 
I’ve no idea what that’s a photograph of but it isn’t a “covid detention centre”. There does seem to be plans for something along those lines in Victoria but they’ve only just started digging.

Is sharing fake news a thread bannable offence?
Even if it's not I think an exception should be made in this case.

I am also perfectly fine.

Looks like you struggle with people who do not share your views :)
 
I am also perfectly fine.

Looks like you struggle with people who do not share your views :)

If your views are comparisons between the Covid pandemic and Nazi Germany then you should feck off to be fair.
 
In a democracy, a referendum for this type of measures should be organised... Not sure if "everybody" will vote yes.

A referendum would take years, time which we do not have. The fact is we vote in governments to make these tough, time sensitive decisions for us. If we don't like what they do we vote them out.

At the moment the Covid Pass is proving a big vote winner and it's only increasing. 74% fully support it, up from 49% when it was first announced, and 63% think vaccination should be mandatory.
 
https://apply.joinsherpa.com/travel...inated=true&language=en-US&affiliateId=airbnb

stick your dates in and it’ll give you a fair idea. Things are subject to change though so check closer to your travel date to ensure nothing has changed
Travelers staying in the UK for less than 2 or 8 days are still required to book the tests, even if they will no longer be in the UK on the dates of the tests. They only need to take the tests if they’re still in the country on those dates.
I'll be in Manchester from Friday noon till Sunday noon (end of October), so I'll definitely need to book and pay for a Day 2 test but if I set my timing at Day 2 in the afternoon, I don't have to actually take the tests?

(Don't see what's the point either way since I'll be home before I get the results but don't wanna be fined afterwards or something like that)
 
Earlier in the day:
For what it's worth there has been virtually no opposition to the extended Covid Pass in Italy.... but when those who think its a bad policy also think the earth is flat and George Bush blew up the twin towers, you're on safer ground.

Later in the day:
At the moment the Covid Pass is proving a big vote winner and it's only increasing. 74% fully support it [in Italy], up from 49% when it was first announced,

So not only were the original claims exaggerated but at one point, they may have thought that 1 in 2 people believed the Earth was flat. :rolleyes:
 
I'll be in Manchester from Friday noon till Sunday noon (end of October), so I'll definitely need to book and pay for a Day 2 test but if I set my timing at Day 2 in the afternoon, I don't have to actually take the tests?

(Don't see what's the point either way since I'll be home before I get the results but don't wanna be fined afterwards or something like that)
Personally I don’t think they’ll chase you for that

also I think I read that rules are due to change again in October so keep an eye out
 
Personally I don’t think they’ll chase you for that

also I think I read that rules are due to change again in October so keep an eye out
Cheers. I thought the rules were indeed changing as from October 4th (e.g. I don't need a pre-departure PCR test anymore).

Just don't want it to be more of a hassle than what's necessary but we'll see how it goes. Personally feel like a pre-departure PCR might even be more useful than a Day 2 test in England when I could have infected dozens of people in pubs/stadium/plane.
 
Somewhat frequent reminder that it would be great if everyone stopped lining the pockets of people profiting off Covid.

I’ve used Testing For All a bunch. They’re not for profit.

Testing For All
 
Earlier in the day:


Later in the day:


So not only were the original claims exaggerated but at one point, they may have thought that 1 in 2 people believed the Earth was flat. :rolleyes:

I think you need to learn the difference between 'fully support' and 'oppose'. 74% fully support does not mean 26% oppose.