Russian invasion of Ukraine | Fewer tweets, more discussion

But you are talking more about moral and sequels, but no doubt that there are many that learnt more in 6 months than any soldier that didnt see action in their lifes.

Yeah no doubt that the experience they have is handy.
 
Either way we can be sure that fresh recruits aren't the best soldiers and will not strengthen the Russian army but just slow down their downfall.

Debatable. They are certainly not the best. But if they do a good mix and in the proper positions, they will learn or die. Im sure putin prefers +100.000 recruits, some for cannon fodder, some that woud learn, thst have nothing
 
Debatable. They are certainly not the best. But if they do a good mix and in the proper positions, they will learn or die. Im sure putin prefers +100.000 recruits, some for cannon fodder, some that woud learn, thst have nothing
Sure, the problem is that Russia needs to drill them at the front as there are few good instructors left in Russia that aren't in the fight. Ukraine on the other hand can send their soldiers to western countries for training and therefore doesn't have this problem.
 
Also morale has to be low. Most soldiers should be thinking by now, "what the hell are we doing here?".

100% .

The CNN piece by I posted a page back interviewing the Russian soldier who escaped the war says a lot about Russian morale.

Soldiers sleep outside and are having to scavenge for food. No wonder the Russian war results are so dismal.
 
Probably the best troops are the ones they have now. they have a 6 month experience war and that counts much more than training
If the reports of KIA are anywhere close to real numbers, there are not so many left in Ukraine who were there in February.
 
Sure, the problem is that Russia needs to drill them at the front as there are few good instructors left in Russia that aren't in the fight. Ukraine on the other hand can send their soldiers to western countries for training and therefore doesn't have this problem.

But how do you know all that information with that degree of confidence?
 
If the reports of KIA are anywhere close to real numbers, there are not so many left in Ukraine who were there in February.

If someone showed us the last 6 months is that know one knows much about the numbers of casualties (man and machines) and even less on the remsining forces. Lots of propaganda and speculation and also mostly about KIA from russia but not from ukraine (smaller population) that sure someone put then there, but not a mediatic bombardment. And its normal, is a a media warfare also and only negative things from the enemy is being pushed as only negative things rom ukraine is pushed in russia media, even if they are even lies.

The truth is that we know little
 
If someone showed us the last 6 months is that know one knows much about the numbers of casualties (man and machines) and even less on the remsining forces. Lots of propaganda and speculation and also mostly about KIA from russia but not from ukraine (smaller population) that sure someone put then there, but not a mediatic bombardment. And its normal, is a a media warfare also and only negative things from the enemy is being pushed as only negative things rom ukraine is pushed in russia media, even if they are even lies.

The truth is that we know little

Not sure I agree. I think various groups of people know a lot, and the rest are feeding off their scraps. It's more a case of finding those who know the truth AND tell the truth, rather than assume everyone is guessing. I do accept that first hurdle (finding the truthful ITKers) is perhaps impossible.
 
Which civilians? It's a ghost town.
Like any other obliterated frontline village/town by Russian artillery, the contested places are being level to the ground by Russian fascist forces but Amnesty thinks Ukrainian positions are what’s endangering civilians.
 
Like any other obliterated village/town by Russian artillery, the contested places are being level to the ground by Russian fascist forces but Amnesty thinks Ukrainian positions are what’s endangering civilians.

That's not what the report you're referring to said at all, what's the point in making stuff up weeks after the fact?
 
What did report say?

You know what it said, because people in here spent pages upon pages whining about it. It was about some instances, fighting out of places like populated shools and hospitals, not general defenses of cities and towns. For instance, they found no evidence of Ukrainian soldiers endangering civilians during the defense of Kharkiv, so why would they find evidence in a ghost town like Pisky? You're just making stuff up.
 
What did report say? I’m just exposing Amnesty for being paid Russian shills.
You realize Amnesty have heavily criticized and reported on the Russians, right?

While there's something to be said about how Amnesty approached the release of that one particular report, they are not "paid Russian shills".
 
You realize Amnesty have heavily criticized and reported on the Russians, right?

While there's something to be said about how Amnesty approached the release of that one particular report, they are not "paid Russian shills".
Yeah, sure.

Believe me…I have been living in a county under a strong influence of Russian propaganda from all sorts for a very long time…I can tell one when I see one. Unsurprisingly, people living near Russia always end up being the most accurate about Russian tactics and motives.
 
Last edited:


Glorious nation of Kazakhstan!

But seriously, it's interesting that Kazakhstan feels comfortable doing this. I guess they know Russia doesn't have the forces to attack it anytime soon?
 


Glorious nation of Kazakhstan!

But seriously, it's interesting that Kazakhstan feels comfortable doing this. I guess they know Russia doesn't have the forces to attack it anytime soon?

That is quite fast for Kazakhstan to switch sides... remember just weeks before the war started there was public unrest and Russian troops where needed to keep the president in his office.
 

Shoigu sidelined and Putin has taken the charge himself, the history didn’t teach them anything.
 
Shoigu getting side-lined, eh? What happened to Gerasimov?
FOh-E6-X0-AABIpg.jpg
 
Seems that the war has turned into an almost total stalemate, with very little movement from either side? Just old fashioned untargeted artillery from the Russians and a few headline Ukrainian moves workout too much immediate impact in terms of the front line?

How do they consistently nullify the artillery disadvantage without an airforce to speak of?