Rooney is finished

Is Rooney done at the required level?


  • Total voters
    1,105
Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't know. You would think there are stipulations but who knows? Moyes is not the brightest tool in the shed and most likely Woody just followed his lead (and tbf was under pressure to keep a 'big player' for sponsorship reasons). Who knows what Rooney and his agent managed to extract from us..

Is it any wonder guys who know little about football as Moyes and Woodie would get fleeced in such a deal when you've got guys on the caf like Pogue who only now realised Rooney is past it.
 
I'd forgotten about that match, he was dire. I remember an away game at Swansea not long after where he fluffed every chance he got too. He was terrible until the New Year last season before he got a few goals yet whoever replaces him has to perform miracles in a single game or its proof they're not good enough.
 
Shameful from Nev, and no doubt he'll be on his TV pulpit this weekend talking snide about fans not understanding football.
 
Shameful from Nev, and no doubt he'll be on his TV pulpit this weekend talking snide about fans not understanding football.


He'll be making a 2 minute compilation of "what Rooney brings to United". The trouble is that there won't be the 20 minute complation of how he spoils us.
 
He'll be making a 2 minute compilation of "what Rooney brings to United". The trouble is that there won't be the 20 minute complation of how he spoils us.

That will be his and Phil's project for the week, desperately scouring frames for moments to pad out a full 2 minutes, Carragher must be killing himself laughing inside seeing this bizarre protection of a guy hurting the club those guys all supposed to love.
 
I've got to vote no. He's been poor at the back end of last season and worse at the start of this season but he's still got enough technical quality to rediscover some form and spend another 3 or 4 years at the top level. Clearly he shouldn't be starting and it might well be the beginning of the end but to write him off would be a mistake.

Remember when Giggs was shit for a solid 6 months as he entered his mid thirties and everyone said he was done?

3 or 4 years, my fecking god :wenger:

This. He deserves to be in the squad, and deserves to get minutes every now and then. I'm sure he will benefit from this as well. Put him on when the opposition is tired, so the physical difference between Rooney and more fit players (that would be basically any player) would become less obvious/relevant. With 20-30 minutes every other game, he would overtake Sir Bobby, he would show the world and his teammates that he puts the team first, and he would get a chance to catch his breath after 16-ish years in the top flight.

Great post but I'd sooner he fecked off completely, we have enough better players to start and cover as subs for him so I'd prefer to use them over him any day.



Fecking idiot :nono:
 
Yaya isn't the England captain with FA backing and a load of mates in the media.


It's Casillas all over again.

Yaya, Hart, Casillas or Raul's situation can't be compared to Rooney's. Rooney has almost 3 years left on a £250k+ per week contract, plus any penalties written into it. So to terminate the contract, the club would likely need to pay him off, and have a massive writedown.
 
Metro (i know) reports that Rooney will be dropped for the home game aganst Leicester City.
 
It'll be good to see him dropped but I wish it was an easier game than Leicester, that will be tricky and if we don't win it'll be the usual we're better with Rooney proof nonsense.
 
I wouldn't be surprised if Zlatan is rested during the game against Leicester, so Rooney is played up front to give him one final chance to prove himself. If he fails to score, he would then be benched.
 
I wouldn't be surprised if Zlatan is rested during the game against Leicester, so Rooney is played up front to give him one final chance to prove himself. If he fails to score, he would then get a final final final chance to prove that he's a class midfielder after all.

Fixed. This cycle has been going on for a while it seems.
 
Sturridge is only ever fit for half the games. The games he is fit for, he is always "coming back from injury". I'd rather have a player who can be relied upon.

Giroud is just the most average striker amongst the top teams. He can get at the end of things sure but he's playing for Arsenal who create a lot more for him so he has goals to show for him.

Plant Rooney as a striker for the current Liverpool or Arsenal and he'll get you 15 goals this season while also contributing more to the play than Giroud and actually being able to play more games than Sturridge.
Is this the same Giroud that has outscored Rooney in every single season since he arrived in English football?
 
I wouldn't be surprised if Zlatan is rested during the game against Leicester, so Rooney is played up front to give him one final chance to prove himself. If he fails to score, he would then be benched.
Would you like to be the one to tell Zlatan that? I would do it from another country. Could you imagine the fallout with Zlatan if that happened and Rooney didn't play well? There will be blood spilled.
 
Would you like to be the one to tell Zlatan that? I would do it from another country. Could you imagine the fallout with Zlatan if that happened and Rooney didn't play well? There will be blood spilled.

I'd love to see Zlatan leave the bench and do a Cantona mid match on Rooney after another awful first touch.
 
Is this the same Giroud that has outscored Rooney in every single season since he arrived in English football?

Rooney(12 goals) scored more PL goals than him in 2012/13 season under Fergie while playing as a number 10 behind RVP compared to Giroud(11 goals) playing as the sole striker for Arsenal that season. Not to mention Rooney had 10 assists compared to Giroud's 3.

Since then Rooney has played about half his games as a centre forward, under incompetent managers, for a team which has been far inferior to Arsenal in terms of chances created. And yet Rooney's PL goals/assist stats are comparable or better in the PL than Giroud in 3 out of the last 4 seasons.
 
Hasn't performed for two years now.

Used to be absolutely quality, but always had weaknesses, now they're becoming more and more evident.

It's a worry because he's on massive money and I don't see anything to suggest he will turn it around.
 
Rooney(12 goals) scored more PL goals than him in 2012/13 season under Fergie while playing as a number 10 behind RVP compared to Giroud(11 goals) playing as the sole striker for Arsenal that season. Not to mention Rooney had 10 assists compared to Giroud's 3.

Since then Rooney has played about half his games as a centre forward, under incompetent managers, for a team which has been far inferior to Arsenal in terms of chances created. And yet Rooney's PL goals/assist stats are comparable or better in the PL than Giroud in 3 out of the last 4 seasons.

That's great, but Giroud is currently better at football.
 
If you look at the things Rooney can bring (now and again) like the drive from the byline against Hull to set up Rashford - it's a typical mark of a substitute. Someone you bring on because in short bursts they've got passion and some brute force to make something happen. I don't even think he shows that enough necessarily but it is what you get with him. And penalties I suppose.

You don't start players like that. Not a top team, nor any team aspiring to be one.
 
Rooney(12 goals) scored more PL goals than him in 2012/13 season under Fergie while playing as a number 10 behind RVP compared to Giroud(11 goals) playing as the sole striker for Arsenal that season. Not to mention Rooney had 10 assists compared to Giroud's 3.

Since then Rooney has played about half his games as a centre forward, under incompetent managers, for a team which has been far inferior to Arsenal in terms of chances created. And yet Rooney's PL goals/assist stats are actually better in the PL than Giroud in 2 out of the last 3 seasons.
I see the lovely play Rooney as 9 argument and he will score more goals has reared it's heard again.

It was just a few months when this was all the rage.He was promptly moved to 9 and failed abysmally.Then he was then being hyped up as a midfielder instead.

Rooney doesn't play striker simply because he isnt good enough there. It's not because we haven't tried him there either.We sold off his entire competition last season and he struggled so badly that we had to rope in an 18 year old instead who lo and behold scored goals in such an underperforming team.

It's always the same.When Rooney plays at 9 and struggles,then his best position is actually 10.Play at him and he struggles,then he is actually a 9 instead.We've seen this time and time again.It's always some hypothetical scenario brought up to defend how well he will do. Having seen him as striker for both England and United in the last two years I'm pretty sure this dreamed up scenarios about him scoring heavily at Arsenal and Liverpool aren't happening.
 
3 years. Goes to 2019. We'd owe him around £40M I think if we cancelled his contract. Don't know if any penalties and such are included - it could be more.

And we thought david moyes sacked would be the end, Moyes not accepting chelsea's offer, shafting us with that contract, signing fellaini, DAMN has Moyes left a legacy in place alright. We have guys like rashford who scores goals, what do we do play him out wide but keep rooney playing off zlaten, when it would be better having zlaten play off rashford, but we have to keep rooney in the team for some strange reason
 
I see the lovely play Rooney as 9 argument and he will score more goals has reared it's heard again.

It was just a few months when this was all the rage.He was promptly moved to 9 and failed abysmally.Then he was then being hyped up as a midfielder instead.

Rooney doesn't play striker simply because he isnt good enough there. It's not because we haven't tried him there either.We sold off his entire competition last season and he struggled so badly that we had to rope in an 18 year old instead who lo and behold scored goals in such an underperforming team.

It's always the same.When Rooney plays at 9 and struggles,then his best position is actually 10.Play at him and he struggles,then he is actually a 9 instead.We've seen this time and time again.It's always some hypothetical scenario brought up to defend how well he will do. Having seen him as striker for both England and United I'm pretty sure this dreamed up scenarios about him scoring heavily at Arsenal and Liverpool aren't happening.

You pretty much ignored my entire point and the post. Maybe you thought my facts were incorrect or the point I was making doesn't stand. But in no way have I suggested that Rooney could do well playing #9 role for us. That dead horse has been beaten enough so please spare me the pain.

You brought up the topic of Giroud scoring more than Rooney in every season since coming to Arsenal without actually specifying in which competitions. It is only natural that I brought a bit of context to that argument by saying that Rooney hasn't played as a lone striker for us which is factual and not an excuse. Even then, Rooney has outscored Giroud in the league 2 out of last 4 seasons in PL.

Rooney could very well be an average centre forward like Giroud if he was playing as a focal point for Arsenal. He would still score 10-15 goals a season like Giroud while also contributing a whole lot more to the team. If you disagree with that, do look at their assists since Giroud arrived in England.
 
You pretty much ignored my entire point and the post. Maybe you thought my facts were incorrect or the point I was making doesn't stand. But in no way have I suggested that Rooney could do well playing #9 role for us. That dead horse has been beaten enough so please spare me the pain.

You brought up the topic of Giroud scoring more than Rooney in every season since coming to Arsenal without actually specifying in which competitions. It is only natural that I brought a bit of context to that argument by saying that Rooney hasn't played as a lone striker for us which is factual and not an excuse. Even then, Rooney has outscored Giroud in the league 2 out of last 4 seasons in PL.

Rooney could very well be an average centre forward like Giroud if he was playing as a focal point for Arsenal. He would still score 10-15 goals a season like Giroud while also contributing a whole lot more to the team. If you disagree with that, do look at their assists since Giroud arrived in England.

He would do well to trap 15 balls in half a season, let alone scoring 15 goals a season
 
I've got to vote no. He's been poor at the back end of last season and worse at the start of this season but he's still got enough technical quality to rediscover some form and spend another 3 or 4 years at the top level. Clearly he shouldn't be starting and it might well be the beginning of the end but to write him off would be a mistake.

Remember when Giggs was shit for a solid 6 months as he entered his mid thirties and everyone said he was done?

It's honestly not surprising that human beings fight each other and start wars when I see posts so disagreeably wrong as this one.

What the feck are you smoking?
 
Hasn't performed for two years now.

Used to be absolutely quality, but always had weaknesses, now they're becoming more and more evident.

It's a worry because he's on massive money and I don't see anything to suggest he will turn it around.
I just want to know the opinions of people at the club. I can't imagine it isn't being discussed behind closed doors.
 
Hasn't performed for two years now.

Used to be absolutely quality, but always had weaknesses, now they're becoming more and more evident.

It's a worry because he's on massive money and I don't see anything to suggest he will turn it around.
Bloody hell you know things must be bad when even you are criticising him.
 
I'm actually so bored of this situation now, that I try to avoid all Rooney related topics.

I've been having debates about Rooney since 2012. I could see his decline before me. I'm just amazed that it has finally come full circle.
 
Just the thought of him milking the club dry with the 3 years left on his contract boils my piss. I think he's just the type to do just that though. He doesn't give a damn about anyone other than himself. I suppose on that contract others would do the same, but the fact he's so shit just makes it sooooo unbearable. His well documented 'previous' a few years ago just adds more shit to the fan. Yuck.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.