Robin van Persie

Status
Not open for further replies.
:lol: @ Pete. Why do you people bother with him and Gillespie they are hurting big time just leave them be. We would be the same if our heros kept leaving us season after season.

Agreed, I would've gone mental if Ronaldo or Rooney went to Arsenal or Citeh. Tevez was a cnut so i didn't really give a shit.
 
Arsenal fans have every reason to be positive for the coming season, especially if they manage to hang onto RVP, if Wilshere manages to get back to fitness they are just as likely as us to win a trophy.

They've managed to do very well so far in the transfer window so far, it's not really a silly claim once you get past being offended by him suggesting it
I do think Wilshere's return and the probability of Arsenal winning something next season do not have to be mutually exclusive. I can't see why they can't win one cup and finish in third/fourth next season, with a Diaby in midfield.

The problem is they purposely get out of cups or just don't put the effort in. Which betters their chances of finishing in the top four. The one season they tried like mad to win something, they lost the League Cup final to Birmingham and everything went pear shaped. Arsenal do not have a squad to last three competitions in April, let alone two. They just have a good 'league' team, nothing more. Perhaps that riles Van Persie.
 
The answer to the "Is peterstorey on a WUM or is he a realistic football fan?" question is somewhere in the middle.

Arsenal are not as likely to win a big cup as United this season. While they have bought well, it takes time for new signings to gel. As with Chelsea, I don't think we'll see them click into any kind of league winning from until next season (13/14) at the earliest. Saying United are no more likely to win a cup is just not true. The claim that RVP switching means he's only after the cash is also untrue. He stands a better chance of winning trophies with United.

But it is in no way ridiculous to suggest Arsenal have a decent chance of winning things this year. One could even say they are overdue. Pete, like every other football fan, is biased towards his own club and like all Arsenal fans atm, is optimistic about the future given his club's signings this summer. He's no more blinkered than many United fans on here, holding him to a different standard doesn't really make sense.
 
Complete rubbish City hadn't won anything in 40-odd years.

They had hundreds of millions of pounds worth of investment. You got Podolski.
:lol: @ Pete. Why do you people bother with him and Gillespie they are hurting big time just leave them be. We would be the same if our heros kept leaving us season after season.

We really shouldn't should we. Suppose there is a skill to his art form.
The answer to the "Is peterstorey on a WUM or is he a realistic football fan?" question is somewhere in the middle.

Arsenal are not as likely to win a big cup as United this season. While they have bought well, it takes time for new signings to gel. As with Chelsea, I don't think we'll see them click into any kind of league winning from until next season (13/14) at the earliest. Saying United are no more likely to win a cup is just not true. The claim that RVP switching means he's only after the cash is also untrue. He stands a better chance of winning trophies with United.

But it is in no way ridiculous to suggest Arsenal have a decent chance of winning things this year. One could even say they are overdue. Pete, like every other football fan, is biased towards his own club and like all Arsenal fans atm, is optimistic about the future given his club's signings this summer. He's no more blinkered than many United fans on here, holding him to a different standard doesn't really make sense.

Of course it's not. It never is. They can win the two domestic cups every season. The big two are out of question for them, not so for us. It was the categoric certainty with which he said they're 'at least as likely if not more likely than Man Utd' to win something.
 
I do think Wilshere's return and the probability of Arsenal winning something next season do not have to be mutually exclusive. I can't see why they can't win one cup and finish in third/fourth next season, with a Diaby in midfield.

The problem is they purposely get out of cups or just don't put the effort in. Which betters their chances of finishing in the top four. The one season they tried like mad to win something, they lost the League Cup final to Birmingham and everything went pear shaped. Arsenal do not have a squad to last three competitions in April, let alone two. They just have a good 'league' team, nothing more. Perhaps that riles Van Persie.

Their squad has improved massively so far though. Cazorla - cracking player, great upgrade to the dross like Rosicky and Arshavin. Giroud - Joint topscorer in Ligue Un, will provide great backup/partnership to RVP compared to average strikers like Park, Bendtner and the wimp. Podolski - quite proven with Germany, direct (which Arsenal needs), great upgrade on the crap they have had to put up with on the wide attacking positions.

Get Sahin in there (if that loan ends up being made) and Wilshere and they have a good squad perfectly able to challenge.

Chesny
Sagna Kosc Verm Santos
Sahin (Arteta) Song
Cazorla Wilshere Podolski
RVP​

Walcott, Giroud, Arteta, Mertesacker, Gervinho, Oxlade etc on the bench.

They have made massive improvements compared to last season, but they are really not that far off us anymore, if every thing clicks for them man management wise. They could definately do with a new left back, but there is a lack of proper ones around really.
 
So, Wilshere has been out for how long ? well long, and Arsenal fans think he will just jump into the form he was in playing Barcelona in the CL?
 
He doesn't come across as someone who would go to the club who offers him the most and if he does want trophies then he knows where to find us.
 
Their squad has improved massively so far though. Cazorla - cracking player, great upgrade to the dross like Rosicky and Arshavin. Giroud - Joint topscorer in Ligue Un, will provide great backup/partnership to RVP compared to average strikers like Park, Bendtner and the wimp.

Chamakh ring any bells?
 
Relevated;12061668; said:
and if he does want trophies then he knows where to find us.

City won more than us last year. Joining City these days guarantees trophy challenges and big wages.
 
Do you know what I find more annoying than fans of other sides?

The treatment that they are given when discussing football. Pete (an Arsenal fan) is suggesting Arsenal are just as likely to win a trophy (not an outlandish claim, despite what people may see), in a thread about an Arsenal player potentially joining United, and people are suggesting he should be banned from the football forums.

It's ridiculous, his claims are no way as ridiculous as half of those spouted by the United fans on here.

Too right. Pete is a good footy poster, far better than the majority on this forum.

Really don't understand the criticism towards him.
 
Too right. Pete is a good footy poster, far better than the majority on this forum.

Really don't understand the criticism towards him.

He's a great poster when he wants to be, but he does enjoy the odd WUM. He insults as much as he gets though.

Any way back to Van Persie - would like him but doubt he will come. Still would prefer a a first choice (not a rotation) midfielder though.
 
Chamakh ring any bells?

Not sure what you're getting at, completely different players. One shined far more in the french league becoming top scorer in the progress, the other often relegated to the bench in favor of Cavenaghi.

Not saying he'll be a great success, but you can't really compare them since they never were at the same level in the same league.
 
Keen followers of the Van Persie thread, I just saw some quotes on the Sun's website. Have they been posted/endlessly interpreted and re-interpreted?
 
Have the signed the fecked alright or not? If not are we going to sign him?
 
Ferguson is determined to get his man, having already missed out on Lucas Moura after the Brazilian's move to Paris Saint Germain was confirmed earlier on Wednesday.

But after watching his side lose a high-profile friendly on penalties to Barcelona in Gothenburg, Ferguson said about Van Persie: "I can't give you any more information.

No gut feeling

"We have made a bid and they (Arsenal) have been trying to negotiate with other clubs. We just have to persevere.

"Hopefully it will come our way. We are trying our best but there is no progress at this moment in time.

"I do not have a gut feeling on it at the moment, I must admit. We are not getting any breakthrough with Arsenal.

"It is difficult to say why they are operating this way. I do not know what their thoughts are because they are not giving anything away."

Meanwhile, Ferguson thinks PSG's €45million (£35.5m) signing of teenager Moura is further evidence of the transfer market spiralling out of control and is interested to see how it works with UEFA's Financial Fair Play rules.

United waiting on RVP | SkySports
 
"I find it quite amazing that a club can pay €45million for a 19-year-old boy," Sir Alex continued. "To make a mark on everyone - to tell everyone that PSG are here - they've signed Thiago Silva from Milan and Zlatan Ibrahimovic.

"They must have spent about £150m in the last month. As you know, the only deterrent to that is UEFA. In the conditions of European football, you don't qualify for Europe by winning the league or coming second - you only get in by invitation. That's where, hopefully, UEFA can have some power. When somebody's paying £45m for a 19-year-old boy you have to say the game's gone mad."

Wayne Rooney's fee for his transfer from Everton to Manchester United in 2004 at age 18:
£26,500,000

Adjusted for inflation to today's market:
£31,744,000.

And finally, converted to euros:
€40,200,000

So that's a WHOPPING €4,800,000 less than what PSG have paid for Moura. Funny how the game's only "gone mad" when it's not us blowing other teams out of the water by overpaying for players.

Exactly :lol::lol:
 
You'll be struggling to stay in the top 4, just as for several recent seasons past. If RvP goes, that struggle will just get more desperate.

He produced 53% of Arsenal’s 74 goals (30 goals, 9 assists) last season. Take that away, and couple it with your leaky defence, and you have big problems.

Well i am glad, you take such keen interest in our squad & it's shortcoming.

We shall do the same with yours too.
You guys should sack Harry Rednapp, he is awful.
 
Surely you see the difference between quality and potential between Rooney and Moura even at that age?

PSG doesn't. that's not the point.
Ferguson has no right to say the world has gone mad, when he himself has been one of the initiator.
 
Rooney was a homegrown talent who had been EPL tested and was fresh from a superb international tournament were he cemented himself as an English international. Lucas Moura is a highly talented Brazil U23 reserve.
 
The massive mark up on the exchange rate really distorts those sums. Funnily enough, we didn't sign Rooney with the eurozone on the verge of collapse. We also didn't pay for him in euros. The inflation mark-up is also wilfully misleading. Football transfer fees aren't index-linked. Don't let that get in the way of some juvenile sniggering though.
 
PSG doesn't. that's not the point.
Ferguson has no right to say the world has gone mad, when he himself has been one of the initiator.

Realistically, how much would you pay for Moura?

Rooney was far from unproven at the time, he had played in the Euros and was one of the most influential players for England. What has Moura done so far in his relatively short career?

Sir Alex isn't implying that paying that much money for a youngster means the world has gone mad, he is implying that paying that much money for an unproven youngsters means that the world has gone mad. Massive difference.
 
The funny thing is that when I said that Rooney was not worth 30m (rumors reported prior the Euros 2004 when he was still just an illustrate Everton reserve). I was laughed at. The same people wouldn't have minded spending 30m on Brazil's U23 reserve.
 
The funny thing is that when I said that Rooney was not worth 30m (rumors reported prior the Euros 2004 when he was still just an illustrate Everton reserve). I was laughed at. The same people wouldn't have minded spending 30m on Brazil's U23 reserve.

Rooney was worth £30m though, hence the laughter directed towards you. What's your point?
 
I reckon RVP is on a level with Rooney, so no. But it's about improving the worst areas of your squad. If you've got the money to improve that midfield and bring in RVP, great. If not, then this is a gross misuse of funds. I'd much rather make Hernandez play a greater role than allow Scholes/Giggs to carry the burden again next year.

Clearly, Ferguson's thinking is premised on Anderson/Cleverley staying fit.

And before anyone says: "yeah, but that's a long shot", it's no different to Arsenal saying they're relying on Wilshere staying fit.
 
Clearly, Ferguson's thinking is premised on Anderson/Cleverley staying fit.

And before anyone says: "yeah, but that's a long shot", it's no different to Arsenal saying they're relying on Wilshere staying fit.

Well that's a bit worrying. I'd like us to be in a stronger position than Arsenal.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.