Comes down to whether you want to load up the stoppers with modern all-rounders, or put them in with the sweepers and liberi. It's almost 3 different types of player.
RedCafe's Top 20 (30) by Position | Please check out the last threadmark
- Thread starter Stobzilla
- Start date
Yeah they are really are. Three lists would be excessive because the genuine sweeper list is so small comparatively. I reckon the complete CBs should be dealt with on a case by case as to whether they are more of a creator or stopper type. This partially correlates with whether they are the main organiser in defence, those tend to be the ball player/libero type
After looking at strikers list, I think in hindsight a few like Rooney and Elkjaer maybe should have been forwards.
Are you the glavisted from: http://glavisted.blogspot.com?
Great blog if you are and welcome to the draft forum!
Thinking about it today, I’m not sure why I put Henry as a forward as he should clearly be in that Law/Sheva category. But we’ll never be completely happy with those lists 
In my mind, all of this is the great test run for the Caf All-Time Rankings 2024, when we'll do everything properlyThinking about it today, I’m not sure why I put Henry as a forward as he should clearly be in that Law/Sheva category. But we’ll never be completely happy with those lists
We may never do that, but it sure helps for being relaxed about the bumpy parts & little inconsistencies.
Yes mate, I'm. Thank you very much.
@Lay
I guess that list is only comprised of strikers you've seen?
I guess that list is only comprised of strikers you've seen?
Yes. If it’s a problem I can redo it with players I know about and their reputation rather than what I’ve seen. I was too young to see Van Basten, Muller, Riva but I know about them and their reputation.
Understandable, I think we all have that problem to whatever degree.
But yes, it would be cool if you could do an all-time list for the vote (since 1950, that is) - only reason is to keep voting as even as possible, so the oldies don't lose out by default. Can be shorter than 30 names too.
But leave your original list in if you want, it's of course interesting as a personal perspective.
Final call for the strikers voting, the thread will (probably) be closed some time tomorrow.
Thanks for the heads up. Been procrastinating on that. Keep finding where some players are a bit mind-boggling.
Welcome! Your blog is fantastic and it's good to have additionally passionate people here with a great knowledge
Great work @harms. I actually read all of it!
Aye, fantastic job @harms . Thoroughly enjoying reading it.
Lovely post about Bochini.
Hi everyone, you won't believe it, but something is happening with the all-time voting project!
We have decided to no longer sit on the results, and the missing positions (AMs, wingers, forwards, strikers) will be published in the upcoming days.
When the first round of results is posted, I'll tag those who have voted but haven't been regularly on here lately.
We have decided to no longer sit on the results, and the missing positions (AMs, wingers, forwards, strikers) will be published in the upcoming days.
When the first round of results is posted, I'll tag those who have voted but haven't been regularly on here lately.
All positional rankings are up now, with the exception of the #10s. If you want to see that one, you have to prod @harms a bit more.
They're in the OP, I've edited them in as soon as we agreed upon it.
Oops sorry harms, didn't notice