mignoet ------ de Gea
Clyne --------- Damian
Skrtel -------- Jones
Sakho --------- Mike Smalling
Moreno -------- Shaw/Rojo
Can --------- Scneiderlin
Henderson ------- Schweinsteiger
Milner ------------ Herrera
Firmino ---------- Depay
Coutinho --------- Mata
Sturridge/Benteke ------- Rooney
Depth :
Flanagan, Toure, Lovren, Enrique, Lucas, Allen, Ibe, Markovic, Lallana, Ings, Origi
Rafael, Evans, McNair, Blackett, Carrick, Feilani, Wilson, young, Valencia, Hernandez?
I think we're a better all round side and have more depth and attacking options on the bench (has to be a first in comparison to United) but I think in terms of starting XI's they lack ability at the back particularly at centre half and we could probably do with more creativity from CM although Coutinho can also play there.
I think our side is more suited to a pressing game by a long shot and if that's the way Van Gaal wants to play theyll struggle to press effectively. In contrast Milner, henderson, Coutinho and Firmino are 4 players you can press effectively from the front.
Where United have an advantage on us is big game management. Van Gaal has proven both at international and for United he can win points unexpectedly against the top sides, Rogders has not.
It'll be an interesting race for 4th, who knows both clubs could go better and maybe City or Arsenal will drop out but I feel itll depend on if there are any more signings in key starting XI positions for either club and whether Rodgers can improve vs the top 6 sides.
Personally at the moment I'm leaning towards United as I feel they'll Bring in a top goalscorer, if they don't then we may well do it especially if sturridge can stay injury free.