Protests following the killing of George Floyd

On wokes twitch stream the police seem to be broadcasting over radio that they are going to block in every car and person on Santa Monica and arrest every single person.
 
Covid hasn't gone away.
Coming back with a storm in USA and France and UK is in the middle!

At least when UK had our scandal last week, we were all very British about it by writing letter of outrage to our MPs :lol:

Still am sure BrExit will sort out all our issues and ensure Rule Brittainia
 
Trying to be objective: Presumably curfew suspends 1st Amendment rights?

So why aren’t people respecting that?
I am no legal scholar but what is the purpose of a constitution or amending it if it can just be suspended?

Also not entirely sure what you are trying to get at. The curfew is just an excuse for the police to end protests against the police. Shame on anyone who respects that.
 
I am no legal scholar but what is the purpose of a constitution or amending it if it can just be suspended?

Also not entirely sure what you are trying to get at. The curfew is just an excuse for the police to end protests against the police. Shame on anyone who respects that.
All I’m saying is that if curfew does temporarily suspend constitutional rights, security forces have legal authority to enforce with special measures. ie: certain forms of police ‘brutality’ would be allowed and not contestable in court thereafter.
 
All I’m saying is that if curfew does temporarily suspend constitutional rights, security forces have legal authority to enforce with special measures. ie: certain forms of police ‘brutality’ would be allowed and not contestable in court thereafter.
Possibly but they'd still remain scmu. Just legal scmu.
 
It may be a cover up but that is the story they are running with


I'm not saying it necessarily is a cover up, it may have happened exactly as they say, I don't know. I've just stopped believing them by default.
 
Spun? What Coolaid have you been drinking? Black people being killed by the police isn't spin. It is straightforward and obvious institutional racism in most cases.
What are you talking about? A murder isn't a rapist because they killed someone and not raped them. Really? I'd never have guessed.

Black people are actually being killed in disproportionate numbers along racial lines. So killings by the police are demonstrably influenced by institutional, and in some cases personal, racism.




Well that's ok then. A Netflix doc found something quirky so we should just ignore decades of institutional racism and in many cases state sanctioned (or at least ignored) murder. Got it.
The society including the media creates an image that black people present with more threat. We internalize these ideas passively and they root deep down in our heart. This doesn't necessarily make us a racist, we may still make friends and get along with black people. However, under certain circumstances (e.g. when we face a danger), this bias may affect our decisions in that split second and cause the officers to overreact.

In the social experiment from the episode I mentioned, subjects were given a fake gun. They were asked to shoot at those who carried a gun, and hold their fire to those who carried a phone. In the last round of the experiment, a black guy they knew and a white guy popped up together, both carring a phone. It turned out most of the participants took the shot against the black guy, who was a friend of theirs. This didn't only apply to white partcipants, but also black, Hispanic and Asian.

I know these conversations make me look like a racist, I'm not. I'm an Asian (as suggested from my username) who lived in the UK for some time and some of my friends are still there, and we are also the victims of racism. Trust me I hate it more than many of you, but it doesn't necessarily mean that we have to relate everything to racism. Chauvin may also be a racist after all, but there has been no direct evidence supporting that theory so far. So why not focus and condemn police brutality, which is apparently happening and much more legitimate?
 
The Republicans and their gangs are already blatantly misreporting stuff now, they aren't even trying to make it subtle.

This could lead to bigger than Arab Spring, if Donald against everyone's better judgment sending in the military and they shed a drop of blood it will get very, very ugly. I already can envision Donald and the republicans doubling down on their stance.

If protest persist for 1 more week, military will come in, and from there on it'll be civil war.
 
The society including the media creates an image that black people present with more threat. We internalize these ideas passively and they root deep down in our heart. This doesn't necessarily make us a racist

It really does. Nobody likes to think of themselves as racist but the majority of us are to some degree or another.

, we may still make friends and get along with black people.

You probably don't mean it that way but "I can't be racist because I have a black friend" means nothing. One of the most racist people I've every met was married to someone from a very different ethnic background.

However, under certain circumstances (e.g. when we face a danger), this bias may affect our decisions in that split second and cause the officers to overreact.

It doesn't matter why a Police Officer treats black people differently or how deliberate an act it is. Especially when it is the difference between you being killed based on your skin colour.

In the social experiment from the episode I mentioned, subjects were given a fake gun. They were asked to shoot at those who carried a gun, and hold their fire to those who carried a phone. In the last round of the experiment, a black guy they knew and a white guy popped up together, both carring a phone. It turned out most of the participants took the shot against the black guy, who was a friend of theirs. This didn't only apply to white partcipants, but also black, Hispanic and Asian.

That is irrelevant because a) it was a reality show and not a scientific experiment and b) they thought it was a video game and everyone of all colours knows that the bad guy in a video game is more likely to be black and c) even if it did show what you think it does then that also displays the widespread and institutionalised racism that occurs in the states. It is so pervasive that even black people are absorbing these harmful stereotypes about their own ethnic grouping.

I know these conversations make me look like a racist, I'm not. I'm an Asian (as suggested from my username) who lived in the UK for some time and some of my friends are still there, and we are also the victims of racism. Trust me I hate it more than many of you, but it doesn't necessarily mean that we have to relate everything to racism. Chauvin may also be a racist after all, but there has been no direct evidence supporting that theory so far. So why not focus and condemn police brutality, which is apparently happening and much more legitimate?

They do I'm afraid. And being ethnically Asian doesn't make you inherently any more or less likely to be racist. What is important is that we fight against our biases but denying they exist is a terrible way to do this. And we are also talking about a combination of individual and institutionalised racism here and the data is unequivocal.

It also happens almost everywhere https://www.theguardian.com/comment...-to-aboriginal-people-dying-in-police-custody
 
Last edited:
While I think that there is definitely a bias towards shooting black people, I feel that an even bigger problem here is the police shooting, full stop. The police are trigger happy, more than in any other first-world country (if we call the US a first-world country). In fact, more white people are killed by police than black people, though per capita, if you are black, chances of getting killed by the police are 2.5 times as high as if you were white.

Source: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-02601-9

US Police compared to European countries

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Police_firearm_use_by_country

From this we can see that Austrian police shot & killed 12 people in 12 years (2000–2011), Danish police 11 from 1996 to 2006, Finnish police 2 from 2003 to 2013, France - 85 in 2005–12, Germany - 47 in 2010–2015, Netherlands - 20 in 2009–2015, Norway - 2 in 2002–14, England & Wales - 24 in 2003/4 to 2015/16.

Germany, with roughly 25% of the US' population has on average 3 people killed from the police per year. The US has around 1000, which is 2 orders of magnitude higher (adjusted for population). Essentially, if you live in the US, you are 100 times more likely to be killed from the police than if you live in Germany. Statistic wise, if you go for a week per year in the US, you are more likely to be killed from the Police there, then in the remaining 51 weeks you're in your country (providing you live in a decent country).

I believe that the main root of the problem is the number of guns. Without addressing it, the problem won't be solved. Even if the police become less violent and less racist, a shitload of lives will be lost purely cause of guns in the US. So while I am happy about the protests that try to address the problem of police racism, and police brutality, I feel that they are relatively small parts of the bigger problem.
 
I have a weird question, some may not even like it.

And don't get me wrong, the cop is an arsehole and deserves the hardest punishment for what he did. And my feelings are with Floyd and his family.

But why is this about racism? Is it known that the cop is a racist? Why is it different, if a white person kills a black person to if a black kills a black or a white kills a white? Shouldn't we be ahead of this in time?

Would there be a debate like this if a black cop kills a white? If the cop had no racial intends (but other assholerys), wouldn't it be racism against white people to accuse them of racism like that in general (not talking about the cop as an idividual, but about all white people in US)?


Sorry, to me stuff like this is always hard to understand, because for me every human is just a human, no matter the race or color. But i witnessed many times that a black killed a white and never a racism debate comes up (at least not to this extent), while the world goes crazy if the opposite thing happens. I obviously know about the past of black people in US, but times have changed drastically compared to the last centuries. However, unfortunately human beings will keep killing each other in future, no matter where they are coming from, so topics like this are always likely to come up, or not?

In a topic like this i just wonder what would happen, if for example a stupid and criminal german would kill a jew in Germany. Would the whole country have to suffer because of one idiot? It basically shows to me, how fragile this world and its peace really is.
 
While I think that there is definitely a bias towards shooting black people, I feel that an even bigger problem here is the police shooting, full stop. The police are trigger happy, more than in any other first-world country (if we call the US a first-world country). In fact, more white people are killed by police than black people, though per capita, if you are black, chances of getting killed by the police are 2.5 times as high as if you were white.

Source: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-02601-9

You just quoted the statistics by yourself.
Shootings by police are a big problem in the US, but as you stated yourself, this is about, that Blacks and people of color would be "happy" to be victims as often as whites of police violence. But they are not. Even if police violence would be reduced in general, it woudn't change that blacks are 2,5 times likelier to be brutalized by police. And that is the issue at hand.
The way you've written it, my conclusion is, you want police violence reduced, but you do not care about the fact, that blacks and other minorieties are much more often the victm of this violence due to structural reasons/racism
 
Last edited:
I have a weird question, some may not even like it.

And don't get me wrong, the cop is an arsehole and deserves the hardest punishment for what he did. And my feelings are with Floyd and his family.

But why is this about racism? Is it known that the cop is a racist? Why is it different, if a white person kills a black person to if a black kills a black or a white kills a white? Shouldn't we be ahead of this in time?

Would there be a debate like this if a black cop kills a white? If the cop had no racial intends (but other assholerys), wouldn't it be racism against white people to accuse them of racism like that in general (not talking about the cop as an idividual, but about all white people in US)?


Sorry, to me stuff like this is always hard to understand, because for me every human is just a human, no matter the race or color. But i witnessed many times that a black killed a white and never a racism debate comes up (at least not to this extent), while the world goes crazy if the opposite thing happens. I obviously know about the past of black people in US, but times have changed drastically compared to the last centuries. However, unfortunately human beings will keep killing each other in future, no matter where they are coming from, so topics like this are always likely to come up, or not?

In a topic like this i just wonder what would happen, if for example a stupid and criminal german would kill a jew in Germany. Would the whole country have to suffer because of one idiot? It basically shows to me, how fragile this world and its peace really is.
You already got an answer in the other thread you posted the same exact question. And to save everybody time, I just qoute the answer from @Sigma again:

"I think it's pretty clear that institutional racism exists within the US police force. Black people are way more likely to be charged with an offence than a white person (for the same offence). However, that doesn't mean that white Americans don't face injustices too, just that they may be less frequent and the injustice may not have the persons skin colour as a factor but solely due to the incompetence of the officers."
 
While I think that there is definitely a bias towards shooting black people, I feel that an even bigger problem here is the police shooting, full stop. The police are trigger happy, more than in any other first-world country (if we call the US a first-world country). In fact, more white people are killed by police than black people, though per capita, if you are black, chances of getting killed by the police are 2.5 times as high as if you were white.

Source: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-02601-9

US Police compared to European countries

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Police_firearm_use_by_country

From this we can see that Austrian police shot & killed 12 people in 12 years (2000–2011), Danish police 11 from 1996 to 2006, Finnish police 2 from 2003 to 2013, France - 85 in 2005–12, Germany - 47 in 2010–2015, Netherlands - 20 in 2009–2015, Norway - 2 in 2002–14, England & Wales - 24 in 2003/4 to 2015/16.

Germany, with roughly 25% of the US' population has on average 3 people killed from the police per year. The US has around 1000, which is 2 orders of magnitude higher (adjusted for population). Essentially, if you live in the US, you are 100 times more likely to be killed from the police than if you live in Germany. Statistic wise, if you go for a week per year in the US, you are more likely to be killed from the Police there, then in the remaining 51 weeks you're in your country (providing you live in a decent country).

I believe that the main root of the problem is the number of guns. Without addressing it, the problem won't be solved. Even if the police become less violent and less racist, a shitload of lives will be lost purely cause of guns in the US. So while I am happy about the protests that try to address the problem of police racism, and police brutality, I feel that they are relatively small parts of the bigger problem.

I alluded to this fact the other evening - the systemic murdering across the pond is another level.

But the availability of firearms in singularity doesn't explain that. POC are still killed/harassed disproportionately.
 
The Republicans and their gangs are already blatantly misreporting stuff now, they aren't even trying to make it subtle.

This could lead to bigger than Arab Spring, if Donald against everyone's better judgment sending in the military and they shed a drop of blood it will get very, very ugly. I already can envision Donald and the republicans doubling down on their stance.

If protest persist for 1 more week, military will come in, and from there on it'll be civil war.
“the republicans and their gangs“, your entire post is an overreaction. These protest will end because of looting and thugs that are out there for their best interest and the violence will eventually make it too dangerous for those that are protesting for the right reason and in the right manner. It will be just like Ferguson, larger scale but eventually the looting and violence will drown out the real message.
 
While I think that there is definitely a bias towards shooting black people, I feel that an even bigger problem here is the police shooting, full stop. The police are trigger happy, more than in any other first-world country (if we call the US a first-world country). In fact, more white people are killed by police than black people, though per capita, if you are black, chances of getting killed by the police are 2.5 times as high as if you were white.

Source: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-02601-9

US Police compared to European countries

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Police_firearm_use_by_country

From this we can see that Austrian police shot & killed 12 people in 12 years (2000–2011), Danish police 11 from 1996 to 2006, Finnish police 2 from 2003 to 2013, France - 85 in 2005–12, Germany - 47 in 2010–2015, Netherlands - 20 in 2009–2015, Norway - 2 in 2002–14, England & Wales - 24 in 2003/4 to 2015/16.

Germany, with roughly 25% of the US' population has on average 3 people killed from the police per year. The US has around 1000, which is 2 orders of magnitude higher (adjusted for population). Essentially, if you live in the US, you are 100 times more likely to be killed from the police than if you live in Germany. Statistic wise, if you go for a week per year in the US, you are more likely to be killed from the Police there, then in the remaining 51 weeks you're in your country (providing you live in a decent country).

I believe that the main root of the problem is the number of guns. Without addressing it, the problem won't be solved. Even if the police become less violent and less racist, a shitload of lives will be lost purely cause of guns in the US. So while I am happy about the protests that try to address the problem of police racism, and police brutality, I feel that they are relatively small parts of the bigger problem.
I think it is also necessary to account for the amount of violent crime in the US when compared with the same nations you listed. I’d assume the US dwarves the other nations given how readily available guns are.

I believe black people in America disproportionately commit violent crime when compared to other ethnicities (this is based off data back in 2014 so perhaps it’s no longer accurate), so the issue is a little more complex than what some have stated. Racism is rife in the US, sure, but there are complex societal issues which contribute to black Americans encountering police disproportionately. Through that lens, it makes sense that black Americans would be more likely to be seriously injured/killed by the police by virtue of them encountering police more frequently.

Perhaps the more pertinent issue is how to lower the contact black Americans have with police/the criminal justice system. It could simply be that higher arrests for black Americans is itself a problem of racism: ie they don’t commit more crime, they just get arrested more by racist cops.
 
I read somewhere that the MSP school district is cutting off their contract with MSP PD for security at their schools. Similar with the University. That’s going to hit the Police in the pocket, where it really hurts. Less overtime = smaller pensions.

Take the legal settlements out of their pension fund for their illegal acts too; why should taxpayers pay that? Cases would drop dramatically if that happened,
 
You already got an answer in the other thread you posted the same exact question. And to save everybody time, I just qoute the answer from @Sigma again:

"I think it's pretty clear that institutional racism exists within the US police force. Black people are way more likely to be charged with an offence than a white person (for the same offence). However, that doesn't mean that white Americans don't face injustices too, just that they may be less frequent and the injustice may not have the persons skin colour as a factor but solely due to the incompetence of the officers."
Can you please confirm what offences they are more likely to be charged with @Sigma? If you refer to violent crime, see my above post, but perhaps the reason they are more likely to be charged is that they are more often committing said violent crime. I know that sounds like a racist remark but I hope it is not perceived as such - it is based on data.
 
You just quoted the statistics by yourself.
Shootings by police are a big problem in the US, but as you stated yourself, this is about, that Blacks and people of color would be "happy" to be victims as often as whites of police violence. But they are not. Even if police violence would be reduced in general, it woudn't change that blacks are 2,5 times likelier to be brutalized by police. And that is the issue at hand.
The way you've written it, my conclusion is, you want police violence reduced, but you do not care about the fact, that blacks and other minorieties are much more often the victm of this violence due to structural reasons/racism
You caught me. I thought I was being subtle, but I guess you’re too smart for me and found me for being a racist.
 
Can you please confirm what offences they are more likely to be charged with @Sigma? If you refer to violent crime, see my above post, but perhaps the reason they are more likely to be charged is that they are more often committing said violent crime. I know that sounds like a racist remark but I hope it is not perceived as such - it is based on data.

Black men sentenced to more time for committing the exact same crime as a white person

Studies comparing 'justice' system for blacks and whites

“Blacks are almost twice as likely to be pulled over as whites — even though whites drive more on average,” “blacks are more likely to be searched following a stop,” and “just by getting in a car, a black driver has about twice the odds of being pulled over, and about four times the odds of being searched.” They found that blacks were more likely to be searched despite the fact they’re less likely to be found with contraband as a result of those searches.

blacks and Latinos were more likely to be searched than whites (5.4 percent, 4.1 percent and 3.1 percent, respectively), even though searches of white motorists were more likely than the others to turn up contraband (whites: 32 percent, blacks: 29 percent, Latinos: 19 percent).

A 2015 statistical analysis of police shootings from 2011 to 2014 found that the racial disparity in police shootings of black people could not be explained by higher crime rates in majority-black communities.

Another ACLU study, this time on the use of stop-and-frisk in Milwaukee between 2010 and 2017, found that in nearly half of the more than 700,000 such stops, the police failed to demonstrate reasonable suspicion as required by the Constitution. The study found that between pedestrian stops and traffic stops, black people were six times more likely to be stopped and searched than white people, and that less than 1 percent of those searches turned up any contraband. Here again, while black and Latino drivers were more likely to be searched, they were 20 percent less likely to be in possession of any contraband.

An NAACP survey of citizen complaints against police officers in North Charleston, S.C., between 2006 and 2016 found that complaints by white citizens were about two-thirds more likely to be sustained than complaints filed by black citizens. When the complainant alleged excessive force, white complaints were sustained seven times more often than black complaints.

Black people are consistently arrested, charged and convicted of drug crimes including possession, distribution and conspiracy at far higher rates than white people. This, despite research showing that both races use and sell drugs at about the same rate.

As of May, data from New York City showed that black people are arrested for marijuana at eight times the rate of white people. In Manhattan, it’s 15 times as much. Black neighborhoods produce far more arrests than white neighborhoods, despite data showing a similar rate at which residents complain about marijuana use.

According to figures from the National Registry of Exonerations (NER) black people are about five times more likely to go to prison for drug possession than white people. According to exoneration data, black people are also 12 times more likely to be wrongly convicted of drug crimes.

Black people comprise about 12.5 percent of drug users but 29 percent of arrests for drug crimes and 33 percent of those incarcerated.

In all, when blacks and whites committed similar drug crimes, blacks on average received a sentence that was two-thirds longer. In some parts of the state, it was two or three times longer.

A study of criminal cases from 1983 and 1993 found that prosecutors in Philadelphia removed 52 percent of potential black jurors vs. only 23 percent of nonblack jurors.

(The whole juries and jurors section is disgusting)

A 2012 study of Harris County, Tex., cases found that people who killed white victims were 2.5 times more likely to be sentenced to the death penalty than other killers.

Innocent black people are also 3.5 times more likely than white people to be wrongly convicted of sexual assault and 12 times more likely to be wrongly convicted of drug crimes. (And remember, data on wrongful convictions is limited in that it can only consider the wrongful convictions we know about.)

studies that assess the effects of race find that blacks are less likely to receive a reduced charge compared with whites,” and that “studies have generally found a relationship between race and whether or not a defendant receives a reduced charge.”

A 2016 review of nearly 474,000 criminal cases in Hampton Roads, Va., found that whites were more likely to get plea deals that resulted in no jail time for drug offenses. While facing charges of drug distribution, 48 percent of whites received plea bargains with no jail time, vs. 22 percent of blacks. Among those with prior criminal records who pleaded guilty to robbery, 36 percent of whites got no jail time, vs. 8 percent of blacks.

when black men and white men commit the same crime, black men on average receive a sentence almost 20 percent longer. The research controlled for variables such as age and prior criminal history.

When it comes to federal gun crimes, black people are more likely to be arrested, more likely to get longer sentences for similar crimes and more likely to get sentencing “enhancements,” according to the U.S. Sentencing Commission.

A study published last May found that when a white person and a black person are convicted of similar crimes, Republican-appointed judges sentence the black person to three months longer in prison.

A 2007 Harvard study found sentencing discrepancies among black people, depending on the darkness of their skin. The study looked at 67,000 first-time felons in Georgia from 1995 to 2002. The average sentence for white men was 2,689 days. The average for black men was 378 days longer. But light-skinned blacks received sentences of about three and a half months longer than whites. Medium-skinned blacks received a sentence of about a year longer. Dark-skinned blacks received sentences of a year and a half longer.

A 2011 study of bail in five large U.S. counties found that blacks received $7,000 higher bail than whites for violent crimes, $13,000 higher for drug crimes and $10,000 higher for crimes related to public order. These disparities were calculated after adjusting for the seriousness of the crime, criminal history and other variables