I read that post earlier and strongly disagree with it. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion but it's clear by the developers leaning on realism, that gamers too infact want just that, their games to get more real everytime. You and the poster quoted clearly like the more mindless, arcadey games. And fair enough, for your sake I hope someone creates a game like that. I guess you should buy a Wi. But for me own, and I'm sure many others, we play these games to try and immerse ourselves in a reincarnation of the beautiful game itself and do things we can't do in real life. Like BE United for this weekends game against Liverpool. The thought is fascninating, to be in control of everything we do this coming weekend. That's the kind of feeling these games are trying to achieve.
No, I think you've missed my point there.
I'm no less a fan of immersive, realistic gameplay as you are -- when it is actually to the benefit of the game and not to the detriment. In fact I loved MGS4, CoD4 and Uncharted 2 for this very reason. It's like a big-budget action flick, yet instead of watching on in envy, as some annoyingly good-looking chap jumps across rooftops and saves the beautiful girl, while you sit there hopelessly picking your nose and scratching you arse with your girlfriend who wishes you were him, you actually get to
be the hero. You blow the shit out of armies, you sneak up on them and snap their necks. Lightning flashes, explosions explode all around you and you're fecking cool. I mean that's actually you kicking the shit out of that big freaky thing with tentacles, or taking somebody out with a headshot from half a mile away. It's fantastic.
The problem comes when you actually
change a winning formula, one that was once considered to be the most fun experience in gaming (scoring a well-worked goal on PES), in favour of attaining realism.
Well, of course there is a place for both, and something in the middle. No different to Mario Kart - Gran Turismo as extreme examples.
That's a great example tbf. Mario Kart is held in such high regard because the gameplay is so much fun. I loved the days of playing Mario Kart 64 and GoldenEye, when multiplayer actually meant getting a couple of mates around or playing with your brother in splitscreen, rather than some retard halfway around the world that keeps disconnecting on you. Gran Turismo on the other hand thrives on realism. From the handling of the cars to the stunning locations, it's a brilliant game.
Would you want to see them make Mario Kart more like Gran Turismo though? I mean surely it would be better if they made the handling more realistic, tone down the colours to a more appropriate pallet, and let's not forget that apes and mushrooms can't drive cars.....