Just as a barometer for comparison here is Pogba vs Kroos vs Thiago vs Verratti. Four players having good seasons, who are seen as key central midfielders for their clubs, who are expected to contribute to both defence and attack, without being either 10s, ball-winning midfielders or anchor men. They would all likely cost a world record fee or close to it to be acquired too.
Pogba
- #1 for shots
- #3 for shots in box;
- #9 for successful dribbles;
- #13 accurate long passes;
- #16 for key passes;
- #18 for passes;
- #21 for aerial duels won;
- #181 for tackles
- #201 for interceptions
Kroos
- #63 for shots
- #100 for shots in box;
- #49 for successful dribbles;
- #1 accurate long passes;
- #2 for key passes;
- #22 for passes;
- #207 for aerial duels won;
- #91 for tackles
- #179 for interceptions
Thiago
- #104 for shots
- #104 for shots in box;
- #13 for successful dribbles;
- #2 accurate long passes;
- #25 for key passes;
- #3 for passes;
- #83 for aerial duels won;
- #86 for tackles
- #1 for interceptions
Verratti
- #226 for shots
- #193 for shots in box;
- #11 for successful dribbles;
- #32 accurate long passes;
- #22 for key passes;
- #4 for passes;
- #223 for aerial duels won;
- #18 for tackles
- #212 for interceptions
What's the point of this? To try and illustrate that Pogba is pretty exceptional to cover the range of game that he does with the ball as a central midfielder. He's a good passer, he creates chances for teammates frequently, he can beat his man, he's also able to provide a threat in and around the box, and is still one of the top 10% or so midfielders in the air. He's not the best at winning the ball back and needs to work on that.
The whole Pogba diatribe is frankly ludicrous. I'm disappointed with his output, but he's doing what he needs to in order to contribute a high level of goals and assists. It'll come. Unfortunately, whilst he's having a cold finishing streak himself, he's also trying to assist a man and indeed an entire team in a similar predicament.