It's not just one result. I have not been happy since after Arsenal in the FA cup really (25th Jan). So 3 months. Since then, there have been 2 other matches where we played well in. Chelsea away in the FA cup and Fulham away on 9th Feb. Even then, let's be honest, Chelsea were in turmoil under Sarri who didn't know whether he was coming or going and Fulham are a travesty.It's mental that people are getting into a frenzy over a game in mid April right after an massive Champions League fixture and just after another one? How many times has that defence played together before? Zero? How many times has that midfield played together before? Zero? And the attack? Once or twice?
This time of your you have to take gambles and prioritise. It's a scrappy win but we got over the line, we were due it after Arsenal and Wolves.
It's threads like these that make me think the toxic boom-bust entitled attitude that comes after a period of success just is totally incurable and clubs aren't going to see any success with it until that generation of the fanbase die off or get too old to have any influence over the atmosphere around the club. It happened at Liverpool and they're finally coming out of the shadows a bit. God knows how long it will take for this lot.
As does Klopp. In fact pretty much every successful manager doesn't directly handle the training duties because clubs can afford larger teams of coaching staff to allow them to take an overview of proceedings rather than have to watch from right in the middle.
But we just had a scrappy win, so feck logic. If he's not chasing players round with a stick then he must not be doing his job properly.
Okay the players need to be cleared off that's for sure. I'm not sure about him being a competent coach relative to our expectations though. Since he took Spurs by surprise (which we probably should have lost), has he come up with any similar ideas since then? I can't say he has. That's worrying for me. He needs to show he's capable of competing vs the top end coaches. Even Pellegrini manages mid-table West-Ham nowadays. It's no walk in the park. He's not going to get by on romanticism alone.
Would love to see Ole chasing players around with a stick. It'd be more entertaining than the football we playAs does Klopp. In fact pretty much every successful manager doesn't directly handle the training duties because clubs can afford larger teams of coaching staff to allow them to take an overview of proceedings rather than have to watch from right in the middle.
But we just had a scrappy win, so feck logic. If he's not chasing players round with a stick then he must not be doing his job properly.
Jesus christ, bringing young attacking players on to try and win the game (and winning it) isn't good enough now? How happy were you when it was Fellaini coming on?
Bringing on Rashford and Greenwood was literally the right thing to do tactically in that situation. Of all the things to moan about that has to be the most utterly, incomprehensibly stupid.
Yes indeed..Utterly embarrassing forum.
Jesus christ, bringing young attacking players on to try and win the game (and winning it) isn't good enough now? How happy were you when it was Fellaini coming on?
Bringing on Rashford and Greenwood was literally the right thing to do tactically in that situation. Of all the things to moan about that has to be the most utterly, incomprehensibly stupid.
Their players does not look clueless on the pitch.Fergie used to delegate his coaching duties as well. Plenty of managers actually do that.
It wasn't the right thing though. We were being slaughtered in midfield by Declan Rice at that point. He should have brought on McTominay to try to win that battle first. Pogba was atrocious at that point, and should probably have been hauled. We fluked a goal through that West Ham mistake, and it sort of "worked", but I disagree with the priority. Bringing Rash on was alright, though, and he played pretty well today.
I remember the Arsenal match but equally, we have been fortunate in a lot of results though. We want to be careful to not be results orientated. Looking at the matches game by game. The actual football on display is not good imo. There's a lack of ideas in our play.I'd be very surprised if a manager that is competing with City and Liverpool wasn't competent. He has maintained a 2.375 points per game over 16 games in the league (90 points over a season), and the major black mark against him is the loss in the FA cup. This is in his first season with none of his players, I think he deserves a pre-season and transfer window at least.
We completely outplayed Arsenal only for us to miss sitter after sitter. They got a freak goal and undeserved penalty to win the game. Many people have erased that from their memories because it was a loss.
Funnily the two players most people were calling to drag off were instrumental in us scoring the winner.Funny, my point is that whatever he is doing isn't really working, we were poor today, and very lucky, and Ole seems out of ideas just now.
It's not just one result. I have not been happy since after Arsenal in the FA cup really (25th Jan). So 3 months. Since then, there have been 2 other matches where we played well in. Chelsea away in the FA cup and Fulham away on 9th Feb. Even then, let's be honest, Chelsea were in turmoil under Sarri who didn't know whether he was coming or going and Fulham are a travesty.
Performances have just been glossed over because Ole was riding the 'chosen one' wave. In truth, the performances haven't changed since Jose was here. I don't care about 'lack of rest' being the cause for the performance today. West Ham deserved to beat us today. It's not acceptable no matter what. What are we actually doing in training? We look like we're not coached properly which is completely on Ole'.
Wasn’t a good day at the office for the manager. We looked very disjointed and the changes baffled frankly. Lukaku looked our most promising outlet second half, yet we pulled him for Greenwood, who offered sweet FA, but who is a kid ultimately. Again we just threw forwards at the problem, which for me is the sign of a weak manager. If playing with an overload of attackers was the best way to win matches then you’d start games like that.
The real issue was not controlling the game and being able to exert concerted pressured. Instead of putting more forwards on, we should have pulled one and put an extra body in midfield. We never addressed that and really got lucky to escape with a win.
I remember the Arsenal match but equally, we have been fortunate in a lot of results though. We want to be careful to not be results orientated. Looking at the matches game by game. The actual football on display is not good imo. There's a lack of ideas in our play.
Football is a results business. Liverpool have had a lack of ideas for months but are still winning games. Very rarely will you get a manager that gives you 90+ points and consistent good performances. Barcelona don't do it, Juventus don't do it. Man City are the closest thing to it, but they have spent ludicrous amounts and have one of the best modern managers.
It's perfectly normal to bring on attackers as you need a goal towards the end of the game. Teams don't start games like that because it's a defensively risky tactic.Wasn’t a good day at the office for the manager. We looked very disjointed and the changes baffled frankly. Lukaku looked our most promising outlet second half, yet we pulled him for Greenwood, who offered sweet FA, but who is a kid ultimately. Again we just threw forwards at the problem, which for me is the sign of a weak manager. If playing with an overload of attackers was the best way to win matches then you’d start games like that.
The real issue was not controlling the game and being able to exert concerted pressured. Instead of putting more forwards on, we should have pulled one and put an extra body in midfield. We never addressed that and really got lucky to escape with a win.
Their players does not look clueless on the pitch.
This thread is a pretty miserable read right now. No reason to turn on him now as he will obviously be here come next season. It does feel as if some here are looking for any chance to have a go at him.
Anyway, give him the summer to form his own squad and there will be no excuses come next season.
People have forgotten what an actually good football team looks like week in week out because they don't watch anything but United games. They think every game you're slugging teams for 2-3 goals.
You can perhaps do it when you are controlling the game and want more of your better finishers for crosses to fall to, but it’s a naive thing to do when you can’t even get forward. Chance creation is far more important than just having better finishers on the pitch.It's perfectly normal to bring on attackers as you need a goal towards the end of the game. Teams don't start games like that because it's a defensively risky tactic.
I agree. For some reason there is an impossible standard on this forum. Sometimes you play well, sometimes you play bad, sometimes you win or lose when doing it. Points and trophies is what matters in the end. Winning while playing badly is usually a good thing, but it is turned into a bad thing on here.
That's demonstrably false. We were great in preseason only to shit the bed when the actual season started. We won three out of the first 10 games under LVG. His start was anything but smooth .Were clueless at everything at the minute though. I wonder what we do in training. Him being here 3 months is no excuse. For instance, LVG had us drilled much more confidently within a few weeks of pre-season. So it can be done if you have competent coaches.
Not with 15 minutes left it isn't. You might only get one chance based on bad luck or the flow of the game. You have to maximise your chance of putting it in the net.You can perhaps do it when you are controlling the game and want more of your better finishers for crosses to fall to, but it’s a naive thing to do when you can’t even get forward. Chance creation is far more important than just having better finishers on the pitch.
Of course i watch Liverpool and City sometimes, not all the time as it's too depressing for me to see how far we've fallen behind. Come on, they're completely different. Their build up & general play is levels above us. I wouldn't have as much criticism about our play this time of the year if we already had a body of work where we've played well. But today is more of the same. Nothing is changing.We had 14 shots today. We've very clearly changed how we play since Mourinho. Your entire post is totally daft. Have you watched Liverpool or City lately? They look knackered and badly coached too. Do people just not have memories longer than 3 months or something? The end of the season is always a shit show.
Indeed. It’s like we were slaughtering everyone 5-0 every week with Fergie.
I think it's got a lot to do with how well the coaching is being done by those the duty is delegated to. If the team is showing next to no cohesion on the pitch, then it is on the coaching team, led by the head coach.I don’t think it has much to do with whoever does the coaching.
Of course i watch Liverpool and City sometimes, not all the time as it's too depressing for me to see how far we've fallen behind. Come on, they're completely different. Their build up & general play is levels above us. I wouldn't have as much criticism about our play this time of the year if we already had a body of work where we've played well. But today is more of the same. Nothing is changing.
Looking at our matches individually and game by game performance wise since Ole took over, we've been the 3rd best side in the league I'd say. Which is fair and probably the best we can hope out of this set of players without fixing the big issues we have.I remember the Arsenal match but equally, we have been fortunate in a lot of results though. We want to be careful to not be results orientated. Looking at the matches game by game. The actual football on display is not good imo. There's a lack of ideas in our play.
I agree. For some reason there is an impossible standard on this forum. Sometimes you play well, sometimes you play bad, sometimes you win or lose when doing it. Points and trophies is what matters in the end. Winning while playing badly is usually a good thing, but it is turned into a bad thing on here.