I’ve put this post in the end of season review thread, but I‘m just going to cut/paste it here simply because it belongs here as much as it does in the other thread:
As a somewhat dispassionate observer and having watched my own side go through decades in the wilderness after a prolonged period of success not dissimilar to united’s travails post Ferguson, just a few points -
1) last night’s game was a collective failure not to dispatch Villarreal in normal time rather than anything to do with de gea’s inability to save penalties which is guff - as the Swiss ramble points out, this is truly David vs Goliath stuff with Utd having quadruple or more Villarreal’s turnover, wage bill, squad value etc.
2) the answer absolutely isn’t to spend hundreds of millions seeking marginal gains on the right wing or in midfield or in defence by buying a sancho or a Kane or a grealish. That’s just lazy and basically a game of roulette throwing good money after bad and hoping some of it sticks.
3) You have plenty of world class or potentially world class players that a number of top managers would be licking their lips at having the opportunity to work with - rashford, martial, greenwood, cavani, fernandes, pogba, de gea, maguire all fall into this category. Only Fernandes and cavani are playing at what would be considered par for their level.
4) around these players you have a number of pretty decent players who would sure as hell be elevated if they were playing for a coach who could extract the maximum and have a coherent plan - fred, mctominay, shaw etc are exactly the sort of tenacious players with a modicum of skill who’d be a mainstay in a decent klopp side for example.
5) the glaring weak link here is your manager. I recognise this isn’t a popular opinion on here, but having ole as your manager is like us playing Rhys Williams in defence, midfield and attack and hoping to make it work. It just won’t. He’s far below the level of the players he’s coaching and whatever progress you’ve seen is purely down to the individual skill of your world class players rather than any coherent plan.
6) it would be criminal negligence if your owners aren’t looking to upgrade your manager when the likes of conte are available. The upgrade from Greenwood or martial to Sancho will be a few more goals or assists and will cost you nearly £100m. The upgrade from OGS to conte revolutionises the club, tactical setup, playing environment etc and costs precisely zero.