Steve Young: “How can you choose between Rembrandt and Van Gogh.”
Jim Kelly: “Before this season I would’ve gone with Brady, but he’s coming back from a major injury. Tom in his prime, it gets no better. But Peyton is used to running that quick-paced offense and is the best at running the no huddle.”
John Elway: “I’d have to lean to Brady because he’s been in more tough situations, had to come back in big games. Plus, he has three rings to one for Peyton, and he played really well in the big games. Brady has had more chances, more of a track record in big games.”
George Blanda: “I like Brady, but if I was starting a team I would take Peyton Manning. He's very accurate, and he really seems to love the game, plus he played in the SEC,” laughed the former quarterback and kicker from the University of Kentucky.
Warren Moon said that two years ago he might have said Brady, but now he must factor in the reconstructive knee surgery.