Next permanent manager | Poll updated

Who should be the next permanent manager?

  • Luis Enrique

    Votes: 113 7.4%
  • Erik ten Hag

    Votes: 1,300 84.7%
  • Julen Lopetegui

    Votes: 10 0.7%
  • Mauricio Pochettino

    Votes: 79 5.1%
  • None of the above

    Votes: 32 2.1%

  • Total voters
    1,534
Status
Not open for further replies.
If it was Poch we would have announced it by now. PSG have got nothing to play for and there’s no reason for the two clubs to keep it hush. All signs point to ETH if we have already made a decision - Ajax are still in a close title race and it makes no sense for them to announce their manager is leaving yet.
Makes sense waiting. If we announce it now we'll be paying compensation to PSG. If we wait till the end of the season there's every chance PSG will sack Poch leaving him a free agent.
 
The only issue with DDG at the moment is that our board will give him a new contract. There's no reason to fret with having him next season, as we have some other major issues to sort. He has a year to train his distribution and presence to show he can come forward with us.
 
Makes sense waiting. If we announce it now we'll be paying compensation to PSG. If we wait till the end of the season there's every chance PSG will sack Poch leaving him a free agent.
If recent reports are to be believed we want to announce our new manager very soon - either the end of this month or some point in April. If thats the case then it won't be Poch going by his recent comments and desperation to stay on as PSG coach.
 
The only issue with DDG at the moment is that our board will give him a new contract. There's no reason to fret with having him next season, as we have some other major issues to sort. He has a year to train his distribution and presence to show he can come forward with us.
The board doesn't need to give Dave a new contract, he has one till 2024. Hendo and co will leave though.
 
If its going to be announced soon then it will be Ten Hag imo.
Klopp announced he was leaving Dortmund at the end of the season before he joined Liverpool. Its not going to unsettle Ajax because they know he's leaving anyway.
 
Even if people want a keeper who is more used to playing a sweeping style and is better with his feet, I find the way some people treat De Gea who has been by far our best player post-SAF really disgusting. Show some respect.
And how did I treat him? I respect him for what he did.
But the club needs to bin him asap. United will never be a top club again with him being a number 1.
 
He has been one of our best players for years, but that is because he has had to make great save after great save. What if he is not having to do that, because our midfield functions as it should as does the defence in both an attacking and defensive sense. DDG would then need to be part of the attacking process. That is where people have doubts.

He hasn't been though. He's having a good shot-stopping season, that's it. During Ole's entire tenure he was an issue. He actively cost us top 4 with his mistakes during Ole's interim season, continued to make too many mistakes during Ole's first full season as manager and wasn't exactly without issues, when we came second. The last good season he had, was when we came second with Mourinho in charge. And even then, his issues with not coming off his line and as a passer became apparent.
 
He hasn't been though. He's having a good shot-stopping season, that's it. During Ole's entire tenure he was an issue. He actively cost us top 4 with his mistakes during Ole's interim season, continued to make too many mistakes during Ole's first full season as manager and wasn't exactly without issues, when we came second. The last good season he had, was when we came second with Mourinho in charge. And even then, his issues with not coming off his line and as a passer became apparent.
Then it will depend on the new manager. If it is Poch he might be safe, if it is ETH he might not want him, Henderson might be in the same boat if we train them to not be particularly good with their feet.
 
If anyone's interested, Ajax will be playing Feyenoord in 20 mins. Should be a good game if you can find a river. Important game for Ajax to maintain distance from PSV.
 
If anyone's interested, Ajax will be playing Feyenoord in 20 mins. Should be a good game if you can find a river. Important game for Ajax to maintain distance from PSV.
Thanks for the heads up, will definitely tune in. Need to bleach my eyes from this PSG-Monaco borefest.
 
There’s some weird Twitter movement against DDG that I’ve noticed of late. No idea why he seems to be the whipping boy and the root of all evil.

Just strange fans that think because he can’t kick as well as Ederson, he should be replaced and we will instantly make 20 points up.

It's not that deep. He doesn't come off his line well enough to sweep keep in a high press team. He's really good at what he does of course but if that's where we're going then he is not what we would want.

I seem to recall the Spanish national side played high with DdG in goal at the Russia World Cup. They got massacred and DgD was humiliated and took a year to recover his form.
 
Then it will depend on the new manager. If it is Poch he might be safe, if it is ETH he might not want him, Henderson might be in the same boat if we train them to not be particularly good with their feet.

Even if we hire Pochettino, I'd be surprised, if he continues to be our first choice there for much longer.
 
If recent reports are to be believed we want to announce our new manager very soon - either the end of this month or some point in April. If thats the case then it won't be Poch going by his recent comments and desperation to stay on as PSG coach.
I'm not sure if the decision is in Pochs hands tbh. We all know how ruthless PSG are about winning the CL. I'm sure the players have their say as well and if they're not onside with the manager then Pochs days are probably numbered. If Zidane wants the job then Poch is gone for sure. So many variables on PSGs manager for next season.

Unless it's someone like Potter then I just can't see us naming a new manager until the end of the season. We all know our club likes to look as if they're proactive but thats very rarely the case.
 
The board have to put into place everything he wants, if they're serious about us being a proper football club again.

That's my worry, but hopefully with Rangnick also there they will let ten Hag focus on coaching while giving him the necessary support.
 


Stating the obvious a bit but a good sign we want the new guy to get a head start
 
I'm not sure if the decision is in Pochs hands tbh. We all know how ruthless PSG are about winning the CL. I'm sure the players have their say as well and if they're not onside with the manager then Pochs days are probably numbered. If Zidane wants the job then Poch is gone for sure. So many variables on PSGs manager for next season.

Unless it's someone like Potter then I just can't see us naming a new manager until the end of the season. We all know our club likes to look as if they're proactive but thats very rarely the case.
I don't doubt he might be let go at the end of the season, but I don't see the point of sacking him yet. PSG are still going to win Ligue 1, and I don't see Zidane agreeing to join mid season, free league title aside.
 
LVG tried to tell us De Gea can be a problem while doing great at shot stopping. His style can invite a lot of pressure.

We often see great passes in behind swept up by keepers out of their area but with us it rarely happens. Many of our own through balls have been thwarted by the oppositions keepers.
 
It's not that deep. He doesn't come off his line well enough to sweep keep in a high press team. He's really good at what he does of course but if that's where we're going then he is not what we would want.
He shouldn’t be the first one to go in a clear out, which is what the Twitter brigade would like everyone to believe. A replacement GK should be down the list in a rebuild.

Our defensive frailties stem from our poor defensive players first and foremost. We won a title with Dave in goals. Get players who can do their jobs adequately in front of him and we can be successful again.

He may need replaced one day under a manager like Ten hag, but that should come when he is the clear weak link of this side, something which is not the case at the moment.
 
De Gea IS a problem though. I think we're digging our heads in the sand about him because of sentimental reasons, namely he's one of the last links to Sir Alex's winning squad, his lengthy tenure at the club, and his occasional insane saves. But the fact remains that he's not a compatible keeper for the modern game judging by his positioning and distribution, something that exacerbates our existing issues in defence. It's pretty telling that he can't even make the Spain squad these days.

I love him but its clear that as a club if we want to move on to a more progressive style of football, he needs to be upgraded on.

Yeah DDG distribution and inability with the ball at his feet is an issue, however it's well below any of DM,ST,RW,RB,CM,CB,
 
A manager like Ten Hag might look to get De Gea replaced sooner rather than later, similar to when Pep went to City.
 
Well if he gets the job then have gotta fully back big decisions like that
Absolutely, really big summer ahead for whoever gets the job. I think by the end of it many of us won’t be happy and will still be thinking there are plenty that need replacing, hard to change it too much over one summer.
 
Yeah DDG distribution and inability with the ball at his feet is an issue, however it's well below any of DM,ST,RW,RB,CM,CB,
Depends on who the manager is. Ten Hag likes to build up play from the back and of course that starts with the keeper as the anchor, so if its him then I'd imagine he'd want to prioritise the GK position as an upgrade. The other positions are definitely concerns (arguably bigger ones), but going by the assumption he will be given time to build the team he wants, I'd imagine getting them accustomed to playing from the back would be something he wants to ingrain early on, meaning De Gea would likely be one of his first casualties.
 
Absolutely, really big summer ahead for whoever gets the job. I think by the end of it many of us won’t be happy and will still be thinking there are plenty that need replacing, hard to change it too much over one summer.

If it's absolute maximum of 4 signings then for me it has to be

DM
ST (ability to play wide on right too)
RB
creative CM (when Pogba leaves)

Yes there is an issue for a left footed RW and clearly Varane needs a better partner, however a DM will help provide solidity
 
Currently watching PSG lose 3-0 and look absolutely hopeless yet again.

I really hope based on recent reports our board are lively to this, ETH should be the one.
 
Currently watching PSG lose 3-0 and look absolutely hopeless yet again.

I really hope based on recent reports our board are lively to this, ETH should the one.

Yeah hopefully this has killed off his hopes
 
Monaco - PSG 3-0, I really, REALLY hope that they won't sack Pochettino today and we announce him tomorrow/next week :nervous:
 
Abit of trivia.
Speaking during an interview for Ajax's YouTube channel in 2020, Ten Hag revealed how he met Ferguson on a previous visit to Carrington. While meeting the legendary manager, he got the chance to speak to him and see how he operated at United.

“Steve and I visited Sir Alex Ferguson when we played Manchester City, the morning before the match we had coffee with him - it was a memorable conversation about football,” Ten Hag said.

“When we visited, Sir Alex Ferguson was sitting in his office, he was the manager and he had an overview of the pitches at Carrington and he could follow the training sessions from his office, it was an experience.”
 
He shouldn’t be the first one to go in a clear out, which is what the Twitter brigade would like everyone to believe. A replacement GK should be down the list in a rebuild.

Our defensive frailties stem from our poor defensive players first and foremost. We won a title with Dave in goals.
Get players who can do their jobs adequately in front of him and we can be successful again.

He may need replaced one day under a manager like Ten hag, but that should come when he is the clear weak link of this side, something which is not the case at the moment.

I think most aren't saying that. It's just worth pointing out. If we are thinking of the analyst bubble on twitter, they have just as much of an issue with AWB, McTominay and Ronaldo as they do with de Gea.

He's contributing to our defensive frailties though. And the last time we won the league with him was almost 10 years ago. Things change.
 
PSG under Poch are finished

They'll still win the league but my goodness do that team look awful in games in spite of the all star roster.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.