United are out of Europe. We battled, we scrapped, we kicked and screamed, but like a mangy old dog trashing about on the veterinary table, we were eventually put down by a more intelligent being. It’s probably for the best.
Though it may be simplistic to claim that United lost the tie because of David Moyes’s now-trademark subordination to Wayne Rooney’s demands, there is a kernel of truth in it. The first nail in the coffin was the decision to start with the patently unfit forward. Rooney’s toe injury, and the painkilling injection given to smother it, had been a pre-match sideshow. All of Europe, including Pep Guardiola – who offered to buy journalists a “big glass of beer” if proven wrong – knew that Rooney would play. There is now a whiff of desperation around Moyes’s United which tallies with his determination to start his most feared player regardless of his condition, or indeed of any real advantage that it might bring to the team. It is hardly surprising: for much of this season Moyes has inexplicably fielded Rooney as a No. 10, despite him lacking the physical, technical or tactical qualities to succeed there.
Last night, playing at No. 9 in the absence of Robin van Persie and Juan Mata, Rooney was required to hold the ball up, bring runners into play, and offer a threat in behind Bayern’s high defence. Rooney was tasked with an awful lot of running, and his technique and temperament had to be perfect against a team of such pressing ability. In all these considerations he was a failure. But that is not the worst of it. If anyone was going to score for United, as the main forward it would likely be him. Indeed, United’s two best chances both fell to Rooney. The first was blocked after indecision on the ball; the second, an absolute sitter to give United a decisive second away goal, was fluffed pathetically. A fit Rooney would not have missed; nor would a fit Ade Akinbiyi. The genesis of that wasted chance can be found in Moyes’s unjustifiable faith in an unfit player.
Rooney is often a sluggish and overweight figure even when free from injury. But last night he was simply not fit. He should not have played. And when his condition became apparent – by half-time, perhaps even earlier – he should have been removed. All this despite Moyes’s pre-match pledge that United could not afford to “carry any passengers.” A casual observer of United’s season would not have been surprised to see Rooney trotting out for the second half. This is because Moyes is incapable of decisive action if it invites the slightest hint of criticism. He lacks the nerve to confront famous names the likes of which he had no experience of dealing with until last summer. He is a manager with a lesser ego than his star players. It is Steve McClaren at England all over again.
cont....
http://unitedeye.net/bayern-review-moyes-and-rooney-cost-united-when-it-matters/