Moyes So Far!

Status
Not open for further replies.
I just came home from work and ESPN is reporting Moyes is in deep shit in the eyes of the Glazers.
 
I just came home from work and ESPN is reporting Moyes is in deep shit in the eyes of the Glazers.
There isn't much in the story beside their "sources". Can't see anything leaked in regards to his future until the end of the season. If we are flat midweek and get pumped against City, maybe then it will come earlier but I wouldn't read too much into what ESPN has to say.
 
I stood by Moyes until Liverpool, I didn't turn on him because it was Liverpool.

I turned on him because you have to win big games, or the gaps between the top teams grows larger, we need a manager like Klopp a long term manager, not one like Moyes.
 
There's no smoke without fire. What did we all expect anyway? A quick look at the 2014 results so far will tell you all you need to know. It would be very surprising if no board members are considering sacking him. Having said that, the article says that he still maintains the support of SAF and SBC. I think if we qualify against Olympiakos, win at West Ham, and put in a good performance against City, he will get back the support of the board. I don't see any of the three results materializing but I'm a pessimistic bastard so you never know.
 
There's no smoke without fire. What did we all expect anyway? A quick look at the 2014 results so far will tell you all you need to know. It would be very surprising if no board members are considering sacking him. Having said that, the article says that he still maintains the support of SAF and SBC. I think if we qualify against Olympiakos, win at West Ham, and put in a good performance against City, he will get back the support of the board. I don't see any of the three results materializing but I'm a pessimistic bastard so you never know.
It did say that the sources claim fergie isn't as sure of his support as before, basically it's wavering, understandably. Fergie would have enjoyed the Liverpool game that's for sure, and there's 1 man at fault for that.
 
There's no smoke without fire. What did we all expect anyway? A quick look at the 2014 results so far will tell you all you need to know. It would be very surprising if no board members are considering sacking him. Having said that, the article says that he still maintains the support of SAF and SBC. I think if we qualify against Olympiakos, win at West Ham, and put in a good performance against City, he will get back the support of the board. I don't see any of the three results materializing but I'm a pessimistic bastard so you never know.

Moyes should be getting better results as the squad learns his management style, it's actually getting worse with time, so yes no smoke without fire, and they should cut their losses now.

Be on the phone to one Jurgen Klopp, give him a hefty transfer budget and give him a nice beard comb as part of the deal.
 
David Moyes does not possess the type of personality or social intelligence that is required to enthuse and motivate men who consider themselves to be top professionals and who strive to achieve the highest accolades in their profession. I know people in the sport, and while David Moyes is considered to be hardworking by his peers he also has a reputation for communicating bluntly and with a gruff mannerism that typically causes others to react negatively - perhaps even disobediently or defiantly - to his orders. I could have used an alternative word to 'orders' but didn't on purpose.

Possessing the mental faculties required to communicate with young men who are wealthy and powerful but who also feel the stresses and demands that come with their careers in a globally recognized endeavour is a required characteristic for any man who aims to support and nurture their talents, and if that man does not have the self-awareness that's necessary to anticipate how his words and actions influence the performances of those who look in his direction for inspiration then that man should not be in such a critical position in the first place.

In the absence of intelligence or self-awareness, a man with charisma should be sought.
 
Miguel Delaney is the one who wrote that ESPN article so there's definitely some element of truth there. He has sources inside the club.
 
I stood by Moyes until Liverpool, I didn't turn on him because it was Liverpool.

I turned on him because you have to win big games, or the gaps between the top teams grows larger, we need a manager like Klopp a long term manager, not one like Moyes.
You turned on him because Feeky called you out for your shit and you thought "damn, he's sexy, and he's right. I guess that's why they call him Right 'n' Sexy". Am I right? (and sexy?)
 
Some Liverpool fans, friends of mine are now calling him agent Moyes. I don't blame them.
 
It did say that the sources claim fergie isn't as sure of his support as before, basically it's wavering, understandably. Fergie would have enjoyed the Liverpool game that's for sure, and there's 1 man at fault for that.

Are we sure that SAF blames Moyes though? Nothing he has said so far suggests that. (Although, I honestly don't see what/who else he can blame!)

Moyes should be getting better results as the squad learns his management style, it's actually getting worse with time, so yes no smoke without fire, and they should cut their losses now.

Be on the phone to one Jurgen Klopp, give him a hefty transfer budget and give him a nice beard comb as part of the deal.

:D Klopp would be a dream come true. De Gea can give him some beard tips if need be.
 

you're actually expecting some positive Moyes stories at the moment?

For example

Moyes should be proud to have already reached Everton's target with his new club
3-0 against 2nd place Liverpool. It could be worse
Paddy Crerand and Man United's coach brother Gary Neville have full faith in David Moyes
 
Are we sure that SAF blames Moyes though? Nothing he has said so far suggests that. (Although, I honestly don't see what/who else he can blame!)



:D Klopp would be a dream come true. De Gea can give him some beard tips if need be.

They could start their own line of Beard Combs and Beard Shampoo, L'oreal Klopp, because you're worth it.
 
If anything is going to happen before the end of the season, it'll be a day or two after the City game at the latest.
 


"I hope it's not because Manchester United won the league quite comfortably last season that the fixtures have been made much more difficult."

I forgot all about this gem. Seems so long ago. What a ride we've had so far.
 
To play Devil's advocate - why?

We're effectively out of the CL anyway; even if we get through what realistic chance to we have vs our next round opponents? And the league or top 4 is gone anyway.

The results of our next three games are irrelevant. Win three, lose them all or draw each one - makes no difference to anything whatsoever.

It's not about the league finish now, it's more about pride and shame. Losing convincingly against closest rivals is a mistake that more often than not leads to firing the manager if he already is on the spot.
 
Most papers running same line. Hes in trouble now.

As i said, i expect he'll be removed on Thursday

Madness if club remove on Thursday. They should have removed him on Sunday, so we have half a chance on Wednesday.

We all know why he was saving Young and Valencia for.
 
To play Devil's advocate - why?

We're effectively out of the CL anyway; even if we get through what realistic chance to we have vs our next round opponents? And the league or top 4 is gone anyway.

The results of our next three games are irrelevant. Win three, lose them all or draw each one - makes no difference to anything whatsoever.

Whether we like it or not we must go in the Europa league. It will allow us some European exposure, its will help us pay the bills and we would look more credible than being out of Europe.
 
I personally think "I don't know what happened" is an acceptable excuse for a defeat. Just roll that one out every time David.
 
Get through the CL and I think he's safe. If our season is over this time next week, particularly if City do us over, and I'm starting to think that'll be that for Moyes.
 
Get through the CL and I think he's safe. If our season is over this time next week, particularly if City do us over, and I'm starting to think that'll be that for Moyes.
Then let's lose, I don't think we have any chance in the QF anyway, with him in charge...
 
Get through the CL and I think he's safe. If our season is over this time next week, particularly if City do us over, and I'm starting to think that'll be that for Moyes.

It depends. What if there's a great manager who is currently available but won't be available for long? (ex Van Gaal). I believe our current position is enough to make United think.
 
Get through the CL and I think he's safe. If our season is over this time next week, particularly if City do us over, and I'm starting to think that'll be that for Moyes.

I hope so. Backed Moyes and gave him a chance and was content for a long time but our 2014 results and performances in particular have been devastating to take.

At some point the club has to step away from dreaming of the romantic story of Moyes coming good. At some point you need to remove the will for that to happen from your head and actually apply some real logic and analysis. That time has come and it's clear Moyes is out of his depth.
 
http://www.thetimes.co.uk/tto/sport/columnists/mattdickinson/article4036764.ece

Glazers’ window of opportunity spells danger for David Moyes

At the end of the day, every year we feel we owe it to this football team and this community to do a good honest assessment of our franchise. If at any point, we feel that change is in our best interest, we feel we have to make that change. You can’t let decisions you made a year ago affect a decision today.”

Joel Glazer said that after firing Jon Gruden as head coach of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Gruden had previously masterminded the only Super Bowl triumph in the Bucs’ existence, the youngest coach ever to win American football’s glittering prize.

The Glazers had awarded him a three-year contract extension but sacked him only 12 months later after a winning 9-7 season when the team just missed the play-offs. They have hired and fired two more head coaches in the four years since.

The point is to remind us that just because Manchester United stood for so long by Sir Alex Ferguson, and constantly cite stability, and gave David Moyes a six-year contract, nothing should blind us to the willingness of the Glazers to pull the trigger on a coach when they have lost the faith. Different continents, different sports but that mantra from Joel Glazer remains the same on both sides of the Pond. They seemed sure about Moyes 12 months ago but entrust him now with a £150 million rebuild? The Scotsman does not have a Superbowl to put on the table.

Of course the Glazers are twitching, having sat with all the club’s biggest sponsors at Old Trafford on Sunday and watched a failing team taken apart, bereft of confidence.

Twelve months ago, they were persuaded that Moyes represented the United way for the rest of the decade. To them, and pretty much everyone else, it seemed that the worst that could happen was a slump to fourth. How naive such assumptions look now.

That worried look on the face of Ed Woodward, the vice-chairman, when the cameras cut to him on Sunday afternoon did not just reflect his alarm at the spanking being administered by Liverpool. It surely told of a deeper worry that if this is not working, if United lose to Olympiacos tomorrow, if the fans turn nasty, if the Glazers cut Moyes adrift, what the hell does he do next?

He can hope that Moyes can turn things around, but it would be negligent if Woodward was not weighing up his next move and the list of potential successors. Sadly for him, that process is not a rest from the daily headaches. Last time United went through these discussions, they were so relaxed they could turn up their nose at José Mourinho out of pure idealism. They did not want him, and they could not lure Pep Guardiola. Carlo Ancelotti, the only other coach still in club football with two Champions League wins, might have been available but he also had the option of Real Madrid. Now all three are happily, and successfully, employed elsewhere. United were so sure of Moyes that they did not bother with a job interview. Mourinho once presented a PowerPoint display of his strategy to Roman Abramovich. Brendan Rodgers gave the Liverpool owners a 180-page dossier on his methods, his vision.

Ferguson rang Moyes on May 2, summoned him from a shopping trip with his wife (he was replacing a watch strap, if you must know) and told an astonished Glaswegian that he was the new United manager.

“He took me in, took me up the stairs, made me a cup of tea and came out with it,” Moyes said. “It’s a moment I’ll never forget.”

We might imagine that, whenever it starts, the search for the next United manager will involve rather more formality.

It will be a longer, tougher search, of necessity given that the big three seem out of reach. And while Ryan Giggs is the obvious interim if Moyes was to depart sooner rather than later, United do not need a rookie. There are few genuine contenders from within the Premier League. Rodgers? Liverpool should be tying him into the sort of deal that once ensured that Chelsea had to pay €15 million (now about £12.5 million) for André Villas-Boas.

Roberto Martínez? It is not hard imagining him heading up a Champions League club one day, but would United return to Everton so soon after Moyes?

Looking abroad, Jürgen Klopp’s work with Borussia Dortmund has shown a clear, aggressive identity plus strong powers of motivation. Yet if Mourinho was too much trouble, what do United make of a coach who was sent off for the eighth time at the weekend?

Diego Simeone’s star is soaring at Atlético Madrid but after seven changes of job in nine years, could United be sure he can oversee such a huge rebuild?

Joachim Löw has signed a contract extension with Germany until 2016. Louis van Gaal falls out with everybody. Antonio Conte? Frank de Boer? Luciano Spalletti? The up and coming Vincenzo Montella at Fiorentina? The more names they consider, the more confused they might get.

And we are getting ahead of ourselves even thinking about candidates when United should first be working out a structure. Are we talking a coach or a manager? Would United embrace a director of football?

With so much to resolve, the truth is that any move would feel precarious. The certainties have all gone at Old Trafford, where the champions are heading to their worst finishing position for 24 years. Anything the Glazers do comes with risk and they cannot even be sure who to rely on. Could they trust Ferguson’s input again?

If the experiences of the Bucs show that the Glazers are not scared of sacking coaches, events in Florida also highlight a poor track record in finding replacements. Only last December after the Glazers had ousted the coach and general manager of the Bucs , an article in the Tampa Bay Times began with the plaintive question: “Can we fire the owners, too?”

Tom Jones, a columnist, wrote: “If you want to get to the heart of why the Bucs have turned into a swamp of little hope, start with the Glazers. This is now two straight coaching hires they’ve completely bungled.” So the good news for those United fans who have given up on Moyes is that the Glazers will not be afraid to sack him if it gets much worse. The bad news is that they will probably botch the transition.

Reassuring, it ain’t.

The fact that we didn't sound out other candidates, or even interview Moyes to see if he was suitable, absolutely blows my mind. We must be the only multi-billion dollar business who has ever done something like that when changing the equivalent of the CEO.
 
It depends. What if there's a great manager who is currently available but won't be available for long? (ex Van Gaal). I believe our current position is enough to make United think.

There was (LITERALLY) all of the best managers currently in the world available, of which all I expect would have joined us bar one or two. And we chose Moyes. Moyes needs to get sacked but I am concerned who's available to us right now. Buying Moyes out of his contract and paying compensation to another club for a top manager will also be expensive.
 
Get through the CL and I think he's safe. If our season is over this time next week, particularly if City do us over, and I'm starting to think that'll be that for Moyes.

I don't think he will last long even if we win on Wednesday. If we scrape through Olympiakos with a West Brom sort of performance and result, then it will only take our inevitable dismantling at the hands of City and eventual CL failure I think. The season and DM are a write off. From that disaster of a transfer window till now is been a huge downwards spiral.

He can buy himself time with the odd decent performance against the lesser teams, but I don't think we will go on any sort of run that will suggest he will last the summer.
 
There was (LITERALLY) all of the best managers currently in the world available, of which all I expect would have joined us bar one or two. And we chose Moyes. Moyes needs to get sacked but I am concerned who's available to us right now. Buying Moyes out of his contract and paying compensation to another club for a top manager will also be expensive.

I seriously doubt that we ever wanted Mourinho. Also every club is entitled to make mistakes.

My point is pretty simple. What if the club has noticed that they have messed up with Moyes in at least 2 ways (1- bringing an inexperienced manager, 2- bringing him so late in summer) and want to make sure it doesn't make the same mistake twice? Getting Van Gaal now may unsettle the side even more but would allow him to assess the squad before summer starts. Also would you trust Moyes with 150m?
 
Last edited:
Moyes needs to get sacked but I am concerned who's available to us right now. Buying Moyes out of his contract and paying compensation to another club for a top manager will also be expensive.
I agree, but will it be any more expensive than many more years out of the Champions League? A win/win would be if Moyes left to save face, or the Club have been wise enough to have a clause in his contract.
 
They're playing like this because of the incompetence of the manager, he selects the team, tactics and motivates the team. Do you think Mata chooses to play as a conventional winger?

Nope, I firmly agree that this is due to the manager. Because we're not playing well people see this as our new ceiling, when it's clearly not.
 
http://www.thetimes.co.uk/tto/sport/columnists/mattdickinson/article4036764.ece

Glazers’ window of opportunity spells danger for David Moyes



The fact that we didn't sound out other candidates, or even interview Moyes to see if he was suitable, absolutely blows my mind. We must be the only multi-billion dollar business who has ever done something like that when changing the equivalent of the CEO.

It's mind-boggling and goes against every hiring practice that makes sense. I can't believe the Glazers were so haphazard and let it happen the way it did.

The article is interesting but as someone who doesn't knows much about American football aside than the shape of the ball, I wonder how much the Glazer history can be applied to football. Is the "coach's" role in American football similar to the manager's in football? When they messed up the firing and hiring process as the article says, how did they do that? Did they hire someone inexperienced? Did they hire someone experienced but didn't back him in the market (they have a trade system so not sure how that works)? Did they exert pressure on the new coach a la Abrahimovich? It is hard to know what to expect based on their pattern unless one knows more about it. It is certainly something interesting to do some reading on.
 
NastyJampackedEasternnewt.gif


ComposedFriendlyAttwatersprairiechicken.gif


Alan Partridge.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.