I'd take him, yes he is a short term manager but who isn't these days?
Gone are the days where a manager will stay at a top level club for much more than 4-5 years.
Yes he comes with baggage and controversy but he is almost guaranteed short term success and that controversy is viewed differently for the most part when the person causing it is on your side.
And let's be honest here it can't get much worse than the dross we are being served up every week right now, at least with him if the football isn't entertaining he will be.