Messi v Ronaldo | Contains double your daily salt allowance
- Thread starter Rado_N
- Start date
- Status
As I thought, links from goal.com and ESPN mean nothing.
Don’t be so thick @kc7 already has all the proof which has been common knowledge for some time.
but go ahead and take the Trump route of “fake news”
I've noticed your posts getting more and more aggressive. It's understandable -- your idol and mister football went on to join a farmers league and bankrupted his boyhood club due to pure greed. I understand your anger, just take deep breaths.
Not aggressive at all, you’re the one getting defensive and deflecting because you have no counter. You get shown proof and have zero comeback because countless times you’ve been proven wrong over and over and over.
And Messi didn’t bankrupt the club, Barto did with awful contracts to Griezmann, dembele and coutinho and Roberto.
I’m sorry your idol took a team that won 9 serie a in a row to a fourth place finish and bounced even willing to join a huge rival until a retired manager had to slap some sense into him. Just relax, it’ll be fine.
Guys guys guys guys. I dont think ye lot really understand how lucky we are to still have both Messi and Ronaldo playing. Just enjoy them whilst we have them. Its splitting hairs in regard to one of them being proclaimed as the GOAT.
They'll always be equal in my eyes.
They'll always be equal in my eyes.
So Cristiano was going to betray United until the last minute and Messi found out that he was leaving Barcelona in August and at lightning speed all contracts were closed with PSG?
So Cristiano was going to betray United until the last minute and Messi found out that he was leaving Barcelona in August and at lightning speed all contracts were closed with PSG?
When money can be agreed upon in a hurry of course contracts can be done quickly.
Look at how quickly Ronaldo’s contract was done with United. Ronaldo was 100% going to betray United until Fergie stepped in. Pep even said a deal was done and everything. Messi would never ever entertain going to Madrid. Barca fans can be more sore about psg but the reality it’s not as big of a rivalry as people may think. Barto just destroyed the team himself.
Yeah excuse me for not taking "goal" seriously.
I see you're trying to cope with Messi playing in farmers league while Ronaldo is playing in a serious league. I mean who could this happen.
The fact he run the Barca club into financial ruin is what takes the cake really
Constantly deflecting yet again
Just give up man, I get that you’re one of those tin foil hat people who doesn’t believe anything and that you know it all but you’re way off the mark. Do some research know and again and there is absolutely no shame in admitting you’ve been wrong. It’s just a discussion.
Sorry to hear your idol was had zero issue with going to rival. Fergie saved his entire united legacy.
First you gotta pick a story. Did Ronaldo reject city or did city reject Ronaldo ?
Constantly deflecting yet again
Just give up man, I get that you’re one of those tin foil hat people who doesn’t believe anything and that you know it all but you’re way off the mark. Do some research know and again and there is absolutely no shame in admitting you’ve been wrong. It’s just a discussion.
Sorry to hear your idol was had zero issue with going to rival. Fergie saved his entire united legacy.
Too bad no one did that for Messi. Now he has tarnished himself in Ligue 1 taking on the might Lille!
Wrong again. Messi was sought after by Chelsea as well, and Pep had been constantly asking about him as recently as April but Messi told him he was staying with Barca.
and Ronaldo just went to serie A to a team that won 9 serie A and gave them their worst finish in over a decade. Zero room to talk farmers league when psg didn’t even win the title last season and this was before Messi.
I never said City rejected Ronaldo, just that they were wavering on him because they were indecisive. Giving a 37 year old the biggest contract in epl history is beyond insane, but you can never put a price on nostalgia. Messi is still at a ballon d’or level at least. And his international trophy is a more meaningful one than anything Ronaldo has won in 3 years now.
You need to do some research instead of spouting nonsense. You even said I said City rejected Ronaldo which I never did. Work on your reading comprehension my friend. It will go a long way in this debate I can assure you.
I really don't think he was going to go to City, but I also tell you that deep down I don't care. I did not actively follow him after he left Madrid.
Although I do not think so, I would not bet a kidney for his loyalty to United, for money, for being on the front page, etc, but in the same way the idea that that meeting with Laporta was the one that decided everything, and not months in advance It seems like a fairy tale.
Cristiano played there more than a decade ago, and Messi, from the Masía, has gone to the club that is humiliating you. He had been tinkering with his renewal for a year and as I told you in some other post, the club had to think of all kinds of systems to pay him (like that story of paying him in 5 years) while his colleagues were pressured to cut wages to pay him.
Why did he go to PSG and not City? they rejected him? or could they not pay him?
There may be no rivalry, but culés on social media seem quite rabid with PSG
@Daysleeper
"Messi had a meeting at the Qatari consulate in Barcelona." (December 2020)
And the source is good. Quim is a Barça fan, a very honest guy who does not speak nonsense. Possibly the sanest guy on the whole show
Of course Jorge Messi denied it (what else could he do?).
"Messi had a meeting at the Qatari consulate in Barcelona." (December 2020)
And the source is good. Quim is a Barça fan, a very honest guy who does not speak nonsense. Possibly the sanest guy on the whole show
Of course Jorge Messi denied it (what else could he do?).
Well aside from the fact that this has nothing to do with my original post, and this is also not the first time you would take any opportunities to criticize my criteria preference, which I couldn’t totally refute, as it’s not a matter of right or wrong, but rather subjective preference.
But this is Ronaldo vs Messi thread afterall, I don’t see why we are only allowed to discuss and compare individual class of players, but not everything else. Goals, records, trophies and achievements etc has always been part of major topic of discussion in football, and being used as comparison on any GOAT discussion in the past. As those are the most commonly used objective metrics.
Admittedly it may not be the most deciding factor for some, but it’s still a significance factor being valued/talked by most people out there. It’s like in tennis people would talk about no. of grand slams all the time when discussing best tennis player or GOAT, in basketball they talk about MVP, NBA champions and points/rebounds/assists stats, in football we also talk about WC, CL, ballon D’or, goals/assists stats etc. it’s nothing to do with adjusting opinions/arguments, it’s just the way it always is, and something which couldn’t be ignored in any major sports.
Even when people compared Pele and Maradona, apart from individual class of players, things like winning 3 WC and scoring 1000+ goals has always been put forward as one of Pele’s strongest arguments (even Pele himself always use these to defend his own legacy), whereas taking the “underdogs” Argentina/Napoli to “single-handedly” winning WC/Serie A titles has always been widely admired as part of Maradona greatest legacy too. These criteria are not something I created out of the blue, but they have always been there as part of players comparison. Whether you regard these being boring and meaningless to you, is just matter of your personal preference, really.
Last edited:
Of course, they mean nothing..only for you))
Below is from Eurosport..
--https://www.eurosport.com/football/transfers/2020-2021/cristiano-ronaldo-to-manchester-city-how-jorge-mendes-masterminded-sensational-switch-inside-footbal_sto8507145/story.shtml
"Mendes took the situation into his own hands and moved forward in determination to pull off one of the big transfers of 2021. For the past four months he has been looking for a new home for his most famous client - and no stone was left unturned.
The main clubs in sight were Real Madrid, PSG, Manchester United, Man City and Chelsea. Through varying degrees of approaches and meetings, Mendes did not have much joy in his discussions. Yet when an opportunity arose in the market he was ready to strike - that moment arrived with Harry Kane and his failed switch to Etihad Stadium."
" As this season began and a transfer seemed increasingly unlikely, Ronaldo had maintained his stance that if a good offer came up - particularly in England - he would want to go. Mendes vowed to keep on trying."
Below is from Guardian..
-- https://www.theguardian.com/footbal...os-return-to-manchester-united-after-12-years
"Mendes informally approached most of Europe’s big hitters including Madrid, Paris Saint-Germain, United, City and Chelsea but had received no firm encouragement about a potential move."
It seems Ronaldo should send a long Thank You message to Kane))
You also have to give huge credit to Mendes, they guy does not stop trying even after so many rejections))
Last edited:
He also told pep in April he was staying. And Laporta was elected in March of 2021. Messi definitely thought about leaving during the Barto era. If he had a deal with psg for that long he would’ve left much sooner.
I have stopped following Messi on social media after the psg and I do agree lots of Barca fans hate psg but I’d argue the rivalry between city and United is bigger since they’re from the same city.
I think once city got Grealish it ended the Messi pursuit. Had the la liga hard cap happened a week before it did (in regards to Messi not finding out till he came in to sign a new contract that he wasn’t able to be re-signed) I think city would’ve been an even better choice and it looked like it was going to happen after he sent the burofax last year.
I also think he absolutely could have had contact with psg earlier but I imagine it was before Laporta took over. However, I’m not going to pretend that is exactly how it all went down. You certainly could be on to something. You mention psg humiliating Barca but the reality is that everything bad a did was self inflicted. And it’s not like psg have done anything of note in the last five years. Barto destroyed the club not psg. Any half competent president wouldn’t have blown the 222 million as badly as Barto did.
so yeah, going to city coming from united would’ve been far worse than Barca to psg. Much much less history with Barca and psg
I think it was a PR act to get United to sign him. He used City to sign for us the same way he used us to sign new contract with Madrid.
1. I don’t know much of Muller as I wasn’t born during his time, but Ronaldo did score more goals in knockout rounds and finals than anyone I have been awared of though. And even Muller has amazing goal ratio, there are also contexts you can’t just totally ignored when comparing both players. Context such as the fact that Ronaldo has played around 200 games as midfield winger during his formative years at United vs Muller being striker throughout his career. Whereas Germany in 1970s was a far stronger side than Portugal during 2010s etc which would definitely affect their WC stats. Don’t get me wrong, Muller was a great player too, and is probably among my top 10-15 GOAT. But Ronaldo had done and shown much more throughout his career, it’s not even a question. For example in terms of Ballon D’ors, Ronaldo has won it 5 times and runners up 7 times. Muller has only won it once and manage runners up 2 times. Its 12 vs 3 in terms of how the world view them as best player in the world in their time. It’s huge difference.
2. I never have any problem admitting Messi is better player when compared their performance on the pitch over the years (especially in recent years). If this is to you the most defining factor in deciding Messi > Ronaldo, I am fine with it too. But let’s not belittle Ronaldo’s greatness in football. He has his own level of impact on influencing games, winning trophies and achieving things where very very few could compare throughout the history of the game, and where a lot of people admire too. What I want to point out is, there are many who enjoyed Messi dribbling, ball control, creativity, playmaking, magical moment, overall performance etc more, but there are also many who also enjoyed Ronaldo’s skills/tricks (his earlier years) and his movement, ariel, athleticism, determination and clutchness (his later years). In the end, what they have done/achieved throughout their career, both collectively or individually, is very similar. It’s just different means to similar ends, if we look beyond personal preference.
Last edited:
That’s honestly possible, but (and I’ll try to dig it up) pep did say a deal was done between city and Ronaldo.
I asked for proof. Show me proof.
Totenham's interest in Messi was also not reported in the media. Is your conclusion that Totenham would not have bought Messi?
Again, this isn't your Bartha fantasy world -- you have any credible sources that show only Man United was interested in Ronaldo an no one else?
The burden of proof lies with you, to prove that they were interested and willing to meet his/juventus terms.
Asking others to provide proofs for a negative is a logical fallacy, called “Appeal to Ignorance”.
Example : Can you provide proof to show me that unicorns do not exist? If you cannot do so, then they exist.
Also, there is a difference between interest and actually going out and making the time, money and effort to get him.
Example : I am interested in getting rid of all rats in my country, but am I interested enough to spend all my time, money and effort doing so?
He has the burden of proof, not you. He is simply using a logical fallacy.
Honestly, I’d just like to add this why Messi going to PSG is such a bummer for me personally. While I’ll always choose my club over any specific player, him going to the French league means I won’t give a crap about 90% of his matches outside of the CL ones.
Had Messi gone to city (and frankly winning an epl title with a team that dominated epl in recent years anyway doesn’t do much for me, but I know it would for a lot of other people) I’d at least been watching him a lot more since I love playing fantasy premiere league.
I bring this up because obviously people who are massive fans of either Messi or Ronaldo (or both) have tons of great memories over the years and at least with Ronaldo going to United it’ll be easier to watch him in the hopes he continues to create more memories, because while yes, he’s 37, he’s still a fantastic player.
I’ll always have a soft spot for Messi after watching him for so many years but with psg it does feel like a semi retirement for me which is a shame. I’m sure I’ll catch his highlights on Reddit or something. I wish him the best, and I still say if he does get psg their first cl title it would be an incredible achievement.
But maybe that’s on me as well, as the only leagues I take seriously are la liga and epl. I’m not even saying all other leagues are bad (hell, maybe the French league is in fact underrated), but I just don’t have any desire to keep up with them week in and week out outside of the really big matches (Milan derby, Bayern vs Dortmund, Napoli vs Roma etc..)
Very well said, that’s more or less my sentiments too. While I don’t think it matters much if Messi spend his retiring years at PSG, as he has already done enough with Barca over the years to cement his place as GOAT, but watching him playing most of the his future games in French league during his final years are quite a waste indeed, as he is still one of the best out there, if not the best. But lets see how he is doing in CL then, I won’t be betting against him winning another CL before his retirement.
This debate is getting boring now.
Let is settle it with who has bigger cock, Ronaldo wins. Peace.
Let is settle it with who has bigger cock, Ronaldo wins. Peace.
I asked for proof. Show me proof.
Totenham's interest in Messi was also not reported in the media. Is your conclusion that Totenham would not have bought Messi?
Again, this isn't your Bartha fantasy world -- you have any credible sources that show only Man United was interested in Ronaldo an no one else?
Levy would be clever enough to know that Messi would never have been interested in joining Spurs. For the greatest players there is only a select clubs they want to join unless they want to go the MLS.
It is a dumb metric, no matter how you put it. This sport is not only played by 11 players per team, the performance level has also much to do with synergies and systems. There is only so much a single individual can do and this goes both ways. Messi and Cristiano wouldn't have these crazy numbers if they didn't play for teams that could buy all the quality in the world. And similarly, they're not to blame for their teams not winning anything big as long as their very own performances were on point. Cristiano didn't win a single CL with Madrid during his individual peak. That alone invalidates your whole argument.
The fact that Messi is winning a poll vs Cristiano made in a Man Utd forum says everything.
That poll in other forums would be way more favorable towards Messi, that's a fact.
That poll in other forums would be way more favorable towards Messi, that's a fact.
Sorry but the club trophies does matter when they were the key performers. I do agree though that's it a dumb metric to list club trophies as a individual achievements, but if the players had iconic performances to spur their clubs to victory it does matter. I agree that you can only just a player on their individual performance which is why hate the trope of Messi/Ronaldo knocked out of the CL or whatever whilst neglecting the performance of the entire team.
Here's one from Marca with more than 400,000 votes:
https://www.marca.com/futbol/2020/04/02/5e85b0c5268e3e52608b457a.html
And for the 2952536th time, this poll was rigged, and it's well documented
I voted Ronaldo but really Im not sure to be honest.
Ive seen Ronaldo play at club and international level at least 100 x more than Messi.
At international level Ronaldo has been the more impressive (in a weaker team)
At club level other than certain champions league games and the odd La Liga match, my Messi knowledge has generally been the highlights which have looked incredible but it is hard to compare if you havent watched them both week in and week out.
My impression is that perhaps Ronaldo has made a bigger difference when it mattered for club/country - very much steps up to the occasion, but Messi has been the better all round player (dribbling ability etc) week in week out.
We 100% should be grateful they are both still playing!
Ive seen Ronaldo play at club and international level at least 100 x more than Messi.
At international level Ronaldo has been the more impressive (in a weaker team)
At club level other than certain champions league games and the odd La Liga match, my Messi knowledge has generally been the highlights which have looked incredible but it is hard to compare if you havent watched them both week in and week out.
My impression is that perhaps Ronaldo has made a bigger difference when it mattered for club/country - very much steps up to the occasion, but Messi has been the better all round player (dribbling ability etc) week in week out.
We 100% should be grateful they are both still playing!
Ronaldo won a poll on who was the GOAT on Twitter with over 500,000 votes. The options even also included Pele and Maradona.
Definitely a few on here who made numerous fake twitter accounts to keep voting for Ronaldo.
Tbf Messi would’ve received a lot of votes from the same people as well.
Well, exactly. It is not Ronaldo‘s fault that he is Portugese and therefore will never win the World Cup.
If you want to compare two players you have to watch them play dozens of games.
So bringing in international or club trophies really doesn’t paint a useful picture.
Ronaldo should win any internet poll because his agent is Mendes, and he has a massive PR team for his principal asset.
That's my point. Many clubs were not "into" Ronaldo either because they know there's no chance they will get him.
Yes Ballon D'or player Messi is playing in ligue 1 taking on mighty clermont foot this week while goal poacher fox in the box old man Ronaldo somehow ended at the biggest club in the world.
I don't know why you're so annoyed, Messi consumed all of Barca for his personal wealth account and left the burning ship and now he's enjoying some Qatari dough. Be happy! Maybe they will make the copa America a yearly competition so he can win it even more!
Funny thing is, you claim the moral high ground for you and then post stuff like this. I mean, you're not really a particularly objective person, are you?
No it doesn't?
My initial claim was we do not know if City rejected Ronaldo or he was 100% city bound. There is no proof for this. That's it. For me to prove this is true, I would have to source every new outlet there is and debunk each and every one.
For someone to prove me wrong they'd have to show just one reputable source claiming with 100% certainty with what happened. I know it's fun to learn something new and use it but I'm afraid it doesn't apply here.
- Status