Messi v Ronaldo | Contains double your daily salt allowance

Messi or Ronaldo

  • Messi

  • Ronaldo


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Origi and the other guy both scored two goals and Messi didnt score any but hes the greatest player of all time trust me lo l
 
I know this thread is mental at the best of times but how can he be blamed for that tonight? Their defence was a joke and much like the Roma game it was clear that Valverde's intent was to sit in and just see the game out. There's nothing you can do when your team is set up like that and the opposition are focusing solely on you. I don't care if you're Messi, Ronaldo, Maradona or Pele.
Valverde decisions were poor (subs far too reactive) but the team were too... all of them.
 
Closing the poll again is a brillaint wind up to be fair :lol:

Messi is just one Suarez or Alba not missing a sitter away from being good.

I thought it was an obvious wind up I’m surprised so many people actually cried about it :lol:
 
Messi is the only forward in the world who is a passenger in defence. It's a lot easier to attack and contribute goals and assists when you run only when the team attacks.
 
After all those years people have watched both of them, there are still some who claim Ronaldo is a better all-around player.

When was the last season Ronaldo managed to consistently pick the ball in midfield or in the wings and dribble past players ? Probably 2009-10. Messi has been doing it for 15 years while scoring basically the same amount of goals with way less games played...
 
It was his best knockout performances since 2015. Shouldn't blame him for what happened this year, but this is not a one year failure. It's 4 years now with an investment that's never been seen before. Barcelona's wage bill is nearly double of any other team on the planet. Winning this year's Champions League would have been the biggest achievement of his career by a mile...

When Barcelona conceded the 2-1 vs Lyon I saw a different Messi, a proper captain lifting everyone's spirits up. Tonight's second half was the same Messi that appeared in Rome last year, head down, hands on hips, no initiative... and it's nothing new. It simply can't happen. They can lose the match, but they can't lose it like they lost tonight. That was pathetic.

After a 3-0 home win with Ajax/Spurs waiting in the final and Madrid winning the past 3 European Cups in a row, this simply can never happen. He's the superstar, arguably the best player ever, he's the guy who gave the speech at the start of the season in front a full Camp Nou promising the fans they'd do everything in their power to win the Champions League. He did not keep that promise tonight.

I still think the fact Barcelona funnel their attacks to go through Messi stops them from reaching their full potential as a team. It puts an amount of pressure on Messi to perform that is simply not necessary with the other players they have. Even with the structural problems, they should have won the Champions League regardless. You can talk about tactics, goals, a player's ability, mistakes, etc.. but in this competition a team's mentality is just as important as everything else and Barcelona simply don't have it. When there's such a big difference between a team's home and away form it's obvious that there are mentality problems. They didn't need Xavi, Iniesta or Neymar, they missed Puyol more than all of those in the past 2 years.

You keep saying this, but what potential?

Coutinho is a bust. Suarez a shell of himself. Their midfield is miles worse than it was under Pep.

Now I agree with you regarding mentality. Their collective mentality is shit. I don't know if that stems from Valverde or from Messi, but their mentality is awful. When you're up 3-0 in a CL semi-final, you should never blow that lead.
 
Well, one of the mod felt the need to go all RAWKish and decided to come close the poll instead of cheering Messi on in that final minute.

Who cares? It's quite a funny WUM TBH. If you hadn't dedicated your life to defending Ronaldo on the internet, this wouldn't matter.
 
The funny thing is this is not the first time this has happen.. he has done this many of times but it gets brushed off because Messi.

Imagine Ronaldo let two 3 goal leads go while Messi won 3 CL in a row imagine the state of this forum
Exactly, Messi is great when his team is in control (Xaviesta era), but if you need him to turn a tie or rescue a game? He hides.
 
Closing the poll again is a brillaint wind up to be fair :lol:

Messi is just one Suarez or Alba not missing a sitter away from being good.

One Saurez. One Alba. One Higuin. Poor Messi, everyone missing for him. What about when these players score for him? He had his chance to win it for Barca. He didn't. He bottled again.

Great (and maybe even arguably GOAT player) but let's not act like he doesn't have a weakness.
 
I'm not saying I disagree but can you provide some evidence to back it up?
Sure.

*Last week Messi scores 2 goals poll opened

*This week Messi chokes poll closed

* the excuse made in terms of anything Ronaldo has accomplished is worth nothing the moment Messi does something great.

* lastly if Messi won a 3 peat of CL and had a copa America to his name while Ronaldo choked two 3 goal leads and lost 4 finals in a row this thread would be closed by now. And you and everyone here knows that.
 
Sure.

*Last week Messi scores 2 goals poll opened

*This week Messi chokes poll closed

* the excuse made in terms of anything Ronaldo has accomplished is worth nothing the moment Messi does something great.

* lastly if Messi won a 3 peat of CL and had a copa America to his name while Ronaldo choked two 3 goal leads and lost 4 finals in a row this thread would be closed by now. And you and everyone here knows that.

That's only 4 and 1 is a hypothetical, can you provide more evidence?
 
Like I said. Intangibles, mental fortitude, “clutch” as much as you all hate that word, X factor, big game player ...what ever you want to call it It is just as valuable and important as talent and Ronaldo has it and Always has. Messi never had it he is mentally weak and not made for the big occasion. If you prefer pretty passes as dribbling good for you I prefer winning and I prefer a player will single handedly win me a tie. 1 goal down 2 goals down or 3 goals up makes no difference.

You call it clutch, i call it Ramos, Bale, Benzema and Karius saving CR7's ass time and time again. Oh and also Real Madrid not conceding a shitton of goals while still expecting CR7 to solve it all.

CR7 "clutchness" its pretty much his teammates showing up time and time again on semis and finals, that doesnt make him a better player than Messi. If today Pique scores a 90'+ header to put Barcelona trough, doesnt make Messi better or worse.

They are the players the are and nothing can change that. Their teammates, team results, awards etc wont ever change that. Messi is a better football player, and this season alone has been 5 times the player CR7 has been, and nothing will change that. CR7 has had his clutch moments yes just as he had too moments of completely dissapearing from the game and his team winning the game for him.
 
One Saurez. One Alba. One Higuin. Poor Messi, everyone missing for him. What about when these players score for him? He had his chance to win it for Barca. He didn't. He bottled again.

Great (and maybe even arguably GOAT player) but let's not act like he doesn't have a weakness.

Poor Messi.

Playing with no quality players his entire career. Such a shame. :lol:



...he’s lucky to have scored that free kick and the first goal being a walk in. He was pocketed the 1st half of the 1st leg and the entire game today.

Nothing new.
 
After all those years people have watched both of them, there are still some who claim Ronaldo is a better all-around player.

When was the last season Ronaldo managed to consistently pick the ball in midfield or in the wings and dribble past players ? Probably 2009-10. Messi has been doing it for 15 years while scoring basically the same amount of goals with way less games played...
Your point? Also to the stats part Ronaldo was an out and out winger for his first 3 to 4 season in his career. Messi has always been a player to get into the box.
 
One Saurez. One Alba. One Higuin. Poor Messi, everyone missing for him. What about when these players score for him? He had his chance to win it for Barca. He didn't. He bottled again.

Great (and maybe even arguably GOAT player) but let's not act like he doesn't have a weakness.
Course he does, the fecking walking around when they dont have the ball for one. How do his teammates put up with that shite. You're good we get it, doesnt mean you could put in a bit of effort too.

These two has-beens aside. If pool win the CL, I think everyone's favorite defender is in with a shout for the balon.....
 
I just find it hilarious last week Messi scores 2 goals and everyone here is having an orgy ....”poll reopened to truly decide who the best is”

*one week later Messi CHOKES AGAIN for more times then I can count on my hands

“Poll closed to avoid knee jerk reaction”

A mod pulls a prank on the most meaningless poll ever conceived and people start acting like all their human rights have been stripped away from them. Can't you see that they did it just to get a reaction from you guys?
 
Exactly, Messi is great when his team is in control (Xaviesta era), but if you need him to turn a tie or rescue a game? He hides.

That's a ridiculous and simplistic way to look at it.

Essentially all you're saying is that a player is less effective with inferior teammates.
 
That's only 4 and 1 is a hypothetical, can you provide more evidence?
I’m not going back and forth with you. Its obvious to see in this forum it’s always been like that and the obvious evidence was today. Is there proof proof no ( I’m assuming that’s the answer you want) but it’s pretty easy to see.
 
A mod pulls a prank on the most meaningless poll ever conceived and people start acting like all their human rights have been stripped away from them. Can't you see that they did it just to get a reaction from you guys?
I’m sure it was that.
 
Who cares? It's quite a funny WUM TBH. If you hadn't dedicated your life to defending Ronaldo on the internet, this wouldn't matter.
It doesn't matter, but it's just bad taste.
 
Great idea for mods to close the poll. Love the meltdown by some on here. Your most hated rivals have just got to the champions league final and all you want to do is to push the narrative that a player who couldn’t wait to get out of Utd is the goat:)
 
I thought it was an obvious wind up I’m surprised so many people actually cried about it :lol:

Tbf this thread is pretty bitter at the best of times so not a particularly good wind up, just looks like staff bias more than anything else

Probably a bit grating for the pro Ronaldo lot because they're usually outnumbered by the Messi ones
 
I just find it hilarious last week Messi scores 2 goals and everyone here is having an orgy ....”poll reopened to truly decide who the best is”

*one week later Messi CHOKES AGAIN for more times then I can count on my hands

“Poll closed to avoid knee jerk reaction”

It's a daft poll on the internet man, it isn't that serious.

But, seeing as how you're so interested in the poll, it was rigged from the start. Messi was away ahead to begin with then because of all the arguing the mods just put them tied and closed it so people would shut up. Unless you genuinely believe that it was just a coincidence that they had the exact same amount of votes...
 
Great idea for mods to close the poll. Love the meltdown by some on here. Your most hated rivals have just got to the champions league final and all you want to do is to push the narrative that a player who couldn’t wait to get out of Utd is the goat:)

.. After winning 3 leagues and a CL, and reaching the final of another, at the age of 23.
 
There was that time Damien posted a screenshot with the mod forum in view and there was a thread suspiciously called "Messi does what Ronaldon't" or something like that in the list. He quickly deleted it of course, but it makes you think.
 
I didn't even vote but i thought it was a hell of a stupid idea to reopen it.

50-50 was perfect.
 
You call it clutch, i call it Ramos, Bale, Benzema and Karius saving CR7's ass time and time again. Oh and also Real Madrid not conceding a shitton of goals while still expecting CR7 to solve it all.

CR7 "clutchness" its pretty much his teammates showing up time and time again on semis and finals, that doesnt make him a better player than Messi. If today Pique scores a 90'+ header to put Barcelona trough, doesnt make Messi better or worse.

They are the players the are and nothing can change that. Their teammates, team results, awards etc wont ever change that. Messi is a better football player, and this season alone has been 5 times the player CR7 has been, and nothing will change that. CR7 has had his clutch moments yes just as he had too moments of completely dissapearing from the game and his team winning the game for him.
Oh cry me a river. As if Messi did not have the greatest team of all time for half of his career. Ask any true sports analyst and they will tell you how mental toughness is just as important as talent. The best player debate was put to bed in 2016.
 
I’m not going back and forth with you. Its obvious to see in this forum it’s always been like that and the obvious evidence was today. Is there proof proof no ( I’m assuming that’s the answer you want) but it’s pretty easy to see.

I've decided not to read this post because I dont want my feelings challenged. Apologies for wasting your time. Good luck in future polls.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.