Messi v Ronaldo | Contains double your daily salt allowance

Messi or Ronaldo

  • Messi

  • Ronaldo


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks for the update man. At the risk of sounding a bit silly....whys Qatar there?
They seem to invite 2 countries quite often, probably because 10 teams is kind of difficult to fit into any reasonable format.
 
Yes they do and he does bugger all, for them, had a great world cup, ohh did he, one before that, oh no he didn't, Best player in laliga that's it. Shame really .

Laughable post. A player with over 30 major trophies in his career, 110 goals in the CL, has the best goals per game scoring record in that competition since Gerd Muller, has 4 CL trophies (including some of the most iconic performances in CL history).
And you reduce him to: Best player in laliga that's it?

Ladies and gentlemen, a new low for Cristiano fans. :(:(:(:(
 
Laughable post. A player with over 30 major trophies in his career, 110 goals in the CL, has the best goals per game scoring record in that competition since Gerd Muller, has 4 CL trophies (including some of the most iconic performances in CL history).
And you reduce him to: Best player in laliga that's it?

Ladies and gentlemen, a new low for Cristiano fans. :(:(:(:(
:lol: That is a much much more reasonable post than most of the ones made by your side.
 
One thing is for sure, Ronaldo dropped a clanger joining Juventus. It's made him lose the debate this season, probably the next seasons too. Can't see him doing much at the next Euros or World Cup, either.

Going to Italy is as much career suicide as going to France right now.
 
I swear it will be my only and last off topic here but, i always got this feeling that some specific posters look really immature. Now i can see why: Trump fan with those typical alt right phrases...I assume "sjw" is a worse thing than the leader of the most powerful nation teaching his people to hate the vast majority of mankind or say that "they bring diseases".
 
One thing is for sure, Ronaldo dropped a clanger joining Juventus. It's made him lose the debate this season, probably the next seasons too. Can't see him doing much at the next Euros or World Cup, either.

Going to Italy is as much career suicide as going to France right now.

He went there exclusively for the money, he can have no complaints really.
 
Aargh thanks bud. Thought Qatar was up to their oil money tricks again :lol:

other guest nation is Japan and there's no teams from Central and North America this time (Mexico and USA). original idea was tournament with 16 teams, but instead the new format will start from 2020. this is the last one that will feature 12 teams and every next Copa will be played in same years as European championships (2020, 2024).
 
One thing is for sure, Ronaldo dropped a clanger joining Juventus. It's made him lose the debate this season, probably the next seasons too. Can't see him doing much at the next Euros or World Cup, either.

Going to Italy is as much career suicide as going to France right now.

But according to Cristiano fans, this is even further proof that he is better, because he has done it in 3 leagues. One overeager fan even went as far as to say that Cristiano has dominated Serie A this season. Yes, thats how desperate they are now. :eek::eek::eek:
 
But according to Cristiano fans, this is even further proof that he is better, because he has done it in 3 leagues. One overeager fan even went as far as to say that Cristiano has dominated Serie A this season. Yes, thats how desperate they are now. :eek::eek::eek:
Tbf I think Messi is the Better player but winning the premier League la Liga and seria a would be an amazing achievement ... First player ever?
 
Laughable post. A player with over 30 major trophies in his career, 110 goals in the CL, has the best goals per game scoring record in that competition since Gerd Muller, has 4 CL trophies (including some of the most iconic performances in CL history).
And you reduce him to: Best player in laliga that's it?

Ladies and gentlemen, a new low for Cristiano fans. :(:(:(:(
By far that was the lowest point in this thread.
 
One thing is for sure, Ronaldo dropped a clanger joining Juventus. It's made him lose the debate this season, probably the next seasons too. Can't see him doing much at the next Euros or World Cup, either.

Going to Italy is as much career suicide as going to France right now.
In hindsight, maybe. But he joined Juve, who has been a top 4 European team of the past 5 years - their UCL record as proof. What is it, 2-3 finals in 5 years or something?

So had his signing pushed them over the line this season (no doubt they signed him for that reason mostly), during a period where Madrid needed a rebuild and Bayern. Albeit, there’s a rise of some English clubs challenging, there’s no super power in European football atm and the competition was as open for someone new to win it, as it’s been for a while.

So had they beat Ajax, as was expected, and Ronaldo pushed them to the final and even a win - the move would have been considered genius and probably he’d have received another Balon d’Or. In a calculated move, he basically put all his eggs in 1 basket. But this year might have been their best chance as Madrid/Bayern will both strengthen. The English clubs are proving to be stronger and stronger. etc.

other guest nation is Japan and there's no teams from Central and North America this time (Mexico and USA). original idea was tournament with 16 teams, but instead the new format will start from 2020. this is the last one that will feature 12 teams and every next Copa will be played in same years as European championships (2020, 2024).
Thanks Bole.
 
Don't use the "combines" stuff as you don't give your "Ronaldo fan" any "combination" argument. Each Ronaldo attribute you come up with each different player and different example so let's play the Messi game the same style.



But being better at dribbling doesn't mean he's better. Quaresma is a better dribbler than Beckham or even Ronaldo is he a better player?



But being better at final third passer doesn't mean he's better player. Do you think Saha or Ole (or any good passing striker) was better player than Rudd because they pass better in "final third"?



But being better at creative doesn't mean he's a better player. Do you think Okocha was better than Lampard or Gerrard because he's more creative?



Again, scoring more doesnt make one better, or are you now saying that Lampard was better than Zidane AND Iniesta because he scored more?



"How many players in history combine so many traits at a GOAT level" - What about Baresi who is arguably GOAT at defending (marking, tackling), leadership, positioning, consistency, reading of the game, longevity. Same can be said about Maldini. Or do you think only attacking trait (that you choose) matter? Well, Messi is also GOAT at reading, consistency, and longevity too, but I am playing your game of "about other players".

Besides, you don't give your "Ronaldo fan" any "GOAT level" or "combine" argument. All the stuff you listed in your original post (scoring, amount of title won, heading, off the ball movement, clutch, proved himself in different leagues) Ronaldo is also at GOAT level, but you don't talk about it there, do you? If "GOAT level" and "combine" is such an important point of your argument why don't you let your "Ronaldo fan" use that? or do you afraid of losing your own argument with yourself?

By the way, Ronaldo is GOAT in term of heading, physically, consistency, determination, movement, "clutch", basically everything you need from a striker. Before you talk about Gerd Muller - for me Gerd Muller is also a GOAT level player.
Also, I am not intending to say Ronaldo is better since for me Messi is the GOAT by far. What I said is your way of argument "what about abcdef" is ridiculous and illogical.

This is my last post of the day so if you want to continue, message me on my inbox or wait for my reply tomorrow.

Toastao80 silenced again.

Now wait till he brings the Onze D'or argument
 


For those who can’t view the tweet:

Suarez without Messi: 36 goals
Suarez with Messi: 59 goals
Neymar without Messi: 20 goals
Neymar with Messi: 40 goals

Benzema with Ronaldo: 5 goals
Benzema without Ronaldo: 18 goals(and counting)
Dybala with Ronaldo: 5 goals
Dybala without Ronaldo: 22 goals
 
One thing is for sure, Ronaldo dropped a clanger joining Juventus. It's made him lose the debate this season, probably the next seasons too. Can't see him doing much at the next Euros or World Cup, either.

Going to Italy is as much career suicide as going to France right now.

He made a history for being the only player ever won in England, Spain and Italy. Something Messi could only dream about.

PS. Serie A is the third best league in Europe now.
 
Toastao80 silenced again.

Now wait till he brings the Onze D'or argument

Silenced again? Cmon, itll take a better argument than that to hold me down. I saw him proclaim Gerd Muller a GOAT level player and didnt think it warranted a response. How many people have you ever heard put Muller up their with Diego and Pele as GOAT candidates? He is simply not held in that high a regard. Cristiano fans would have you believe he is, because he and Cristiano excel at the same things (heading, clutch, goals, off the ball movement etc).
Cristiano fans, please enlighten us (this should be interesting), who do you consider as the 5 greatest players of all time?
 


For those who can’t view the tweet:

Suarez without Messi: 36 goals
Suarez with Messi: 59 goals
Neymar without Messi: 20 goals
Neymar with Messi: 40 goals

Benzema with Ronaldo: 5 goals
Benzema without Ronaldo: 18 goals(and counting)
Dybala with Ronaldo: 5 goals
Dybala without Ronaldo: 22 goals

What does that prove?

Zlatan with Messi 20 goals
Zlatan with Cavani 50 goals
 
Ronaldo, Messi, Pele, Maradona, Di Stefano

Why Di Stefano ahead of Muller? Didnt Muller win international tournaments (2 infact, and scoring in both finals) whereas Alfred did not? Didnt Muller score more goals?
 
Why Di Stefano ahead of Muller? Didnt Muller win international tournaments (2 infact, and scoring in both finals) whereas Alfred did not? Didnt Muller score more goals?
As I have said numerous times which you have refused to acknowledge, is the fact that those players are KEY players for their team.

Any United midfielder during the Sir Alex era has more PL medals than Gerrard, but does anyone think all of them are better?
 
As I have said numerous times which you have refused to acknowledge, is the fact that those players are KEY players for their team.

Any United midfielder during the Sir Alex era has more PL medals than Gerrard, but does anyone think all of them are better?

Youre not making sense. What has that got to do with why you think Di Stefano was greater than Muller?
Gerd Muller wasnt just any old player, he was one of the best players in the world for nearly a decade. And if youre implying that Gerd wasn't a key player for his teams, you know that he scored 10 goals for Germany in World Cup 70, scored the winning goal in the 74 final (also scored the goal that took them to the final), scored 570 goals for Bayern, won 3 European cups (scored in 2 finals)?

I thought that winning an international tournament gave Cristiano an advantage over Leo? Shouldn't that argument apply to Muller over Di Stefano? In fact Muller contributed a lot more to Germany's titles than Cristiano to Portugals (and its not even close).
Added to that, the other favourite of Cristiano fans, goals. Muller blows Di Stefano out of the water here Shouldn't that be used in his favour?
 
Youre not making sense. What has that got to do with why you think Di Stefano was greater than Muller?
Gerd Muller wasnt just any old player, he was one of the best players in the world for nearly a decade. And if youre implying that Gerd wasn't a key player for his teams, you know that he scored 10 goals for Germany in World Cup 70, scored the winning goal in the 74 final (also scored the goal that took them to the final), scored 570 goals for Bayern, won 3 European cups (scored in 2 finals)?

I thought that winning an international tournament gave Cristiano an advantage over Leo? Shouldn't that argument apply to Muller over Di Stefano? In fact Muller contributed a lot more to Germany's titles than Cristiano to Portugals (and its not even close).
Added to that, the other favourite of Cristiano fans, goals. Muller blows Di Stefano out of the water here Shouldn't that be used in his favour?
He was definitely one of the best players in the world, where have I denied that? :confused:

The bolded part, it's a contributing factor, being the star player winning 5 EC/CLs also counts for a lot.
 
I thought redcafe_reader's post was satire. Was it not? "Being better at all these things doesn't mean you are better".
 
As I have said numerous times which you have refused to acknowledge, is the fact that those players are KEY players for their team.

Any United midfielder during the Sir Alex era has more PL medals than Gerrard, but does anyone think all of them are better?
Yes they all are better. Keane and scholes miles better
 
He made a history for being the only player ever won in England, Spain and Italy. Something Messi could only dream about.

PS. Serie A is the third best league in Europe now.

Haha no one cares. Put Messi on the best team in England and put him on Juventus (who have won 8 straight league titles) and he’d be the same.

It’s not like Ronaldo took Udinese to a serie A title
 
Silenced again? Cmon, itll take a better argument than that to hold me down. I saw him proclaim Gerd Muller a GOAT level player and didnt think it warranted a response. How many people have you ever heard put Muller up their with Diego and Pele as GOAT candidates? He is simply not held in that high a regard. Cristiano fans would have you believe he is, because he and Cristiano excel at the same things (heading, clutch, goals, off the ball movement etc).
Cristiano fans, please enlighten us (this should be interesting), who do you consider as the 5 greatest players of all time?

I can claim Bebe is the best player of all time, still do not change that I am using the exact argument you used in your imagination argument with your "Ronaldo fan", and as I guess, there is no reply from you. Whether it's because you are "silenced" or not is up to you, otherwise, feel free to address my post just as I addressed yours. Or you can just say: "oh he said Bebe is GOAT, Ronaldo fan silenced again".

And don't derail the topic, Gerd Muller is 1 of the best striker of all time, therefore for me he's GOAT level player (Read "level"), but that's for another topic and I am up to it if you want to. Also as I said it myself, I am not Ronaldo fan, I am not again your opinion that Messi > Ronaldo, I am again your way of argument.

I thought redcafe_reader's post was satire. Was it not? "Being better at all these things doesn't mean you are better".

It was to answer to his post, where he argues with "Ronaldo fan" and self claiming victory

Dismantling their arguments is so easy. Case in point.
Cristiano fans: Cristiano is better because he has has won more (debatable but lets go with it).
Messi fans: but that argument is not definitive, otherwise didnt Muller win more than Diego? Was Muller therefore better? Sergio Ramos has won more than Baresi. Who is greater?
Cristiano fans: no answer. But hold on, he's better because he scores better, esp in the CL.
Messi fans: Again, scoring more doesnt make one better, or are you now saying that Lampard was better than Zidane AND Iniesta because he scored more?
Cristiano fans: silence again. But Cristiano is better because he has more Balon Dor votes. Messi fans: again, cant always go by that, otherwise are you saying that Lampard AND Gerrard were MUCH better than Scholes because they destroyed him in Balon Dor voting (in fact, he never got a single vote in his career).
Cristiano fans finally respond: Well sometimes Balon Dor is wrong, look how Sneider got cheated by Messi in 2010. Messi should have 4.
Messi fans: but hold up. One minute you are swearing by The Balon Dor and using it to big up Cristiano, then the next, youre doubting its accuracy. Which is it?
Cristiano fans: Again, no response.
Messi fans: what quality as a footballer makes Cristiano better?
Cristiano fans: Well, how about heading and off the ball movement.
Messi fans: Muller had better heading and off the ball movement than Diego, did that make him better?
Cristiano fans: again silence. Hes another one, Cristiano is more clutch.
Messi fans: Muller was more clutch than Diego. Was he better?
Cristiano fans: silence. But Cristiano has proved it in different leagues, so hes better.
Messi fans: again not definitive. Or are you now saying that Marcel Desailly is greater than Beckenbauer, Moore, Maldini AND Baresi because he proved it in different leagues? Zola better than Roberto Baggio? Evra better than Maldini?
Cristiano fans: silence again.
Breaking down their arguments is like childsplay.

I can do it the same to prove Bebe is better than Maradona

Maradona fans: Diego is better because he has has won more .
Bebe fans: but that argument is not definitive, otherwise didnt Muller win more than Diego? Was Muller therefore better? Sergio Ramos has won more than Baresi. Who is greater?
Maradona fans: no answer. But hold on, he's better because he scores better, esp in the CL.
Bebe fans: Again, scoring more doesnt make one better, or are you now saying that Lampard was better than Zidane AND Iniesta because he scored more?
Maradona fans: silence again. But Diego is better because he has more Balon Dor votes.
Bebe fans: again, cant always go by that, otherwise are you saying that Lampard AND Gerrard were MUCH better than Scholes because they destroyed him in Balon Dor voting (in fact, he never got a single vote in his career).

...

Just replace "Ronaldo" with "Maradona" and "Messi" with "Bebe" and do the rest, imagination is @Tostao_80's strong points after all.
 
Haha no one cares. Put Messi on the best team in England and put him on Juventus (who have won 8 straight league titles) and he’d be the same.

It’s not like Ronaldo took Udinese to a serie A title
Put Messi in one of the best international teams in the world and they win feck all.
 
Put Messi in one of the best international teams in the world and they win feck all.

Put Ronaldo on Argentina and they’d also struggle to win the World Cup

Hell, Ronaldo’s supporting cast won a euro final without him, messi’s couldn’t even qualify for
The World Cup without him.
 
Messi would’ve won with Germany or Spain

Put Ronaldo on Argentina and they’d also struggle to qualify for the World Cup

Hell, Ronaldo’s supporting cast won a euro final without him, messi’s couldn’t even qualify for
The World Cup without him.
Fact: Argentina has never failed to qualify for a WC, Portual have only ever qualified for 3 before Ronaldo.
 
Fact: Argentina has never failed to qualify for a WC, Portual have only ever qualified for 3 before Ronaldo.

Fact: Argentina were in danger of not qualifying when Messi was gone for 3 games. Messi has to bail them out in the final qualifying game.

Fact: Ronaldo barely played in the euro final and his team still won

Fact: Portugal have a significantly better record without Ronaldo than Argentina does without Messi
 
In hindsight, maybe. But he joined Juve, who has been a top 4 European team of the past 5 years - their UCL record as proof. What is it, 2-3 finals in 5 years or something?

So had his signing pushed them over the line this season (no doubt they signed him for that reason mostly), during a period where Madrid needed a rebuild and Bayern. Albeit, there’s a rise of some English clubs challenging, there’s no super power in European football atm and the competition was as open for someone new to win it, as it’s been for a while.

So had they beat Ajax, as was expected, and Ronaldo pushed them to the final and even a win - the move would have been considered genius and probably he’d have received another Balon d’Or. In a calculated move, he basically put all his eggs in 1 basket. But this year might have been their best chance as Madrid/Bayern will both strengthen. The English clubs are proving to be stronger and stronger. etc.

I think Juventus signed him primarily for commercial reasons, though it helps that Ronaldo is a beast in the Champions League. Likewise, Ronaldo considered Juventus to be among the favourites for the trophy so he joined them in an effort to further his legacy in addition to making more money.

This is all well and good, can't say either Juve or Ronaldo did something stupid here. If Juventus don't win the CL in his time there, the move is still a success. The club will definitely enjoy more popularity now with the CR7 brand, which means more money and altogether a higher standing in football, and the player will make the money he wants along with winning a different league. If they end up winning the CL, all the better.
 
I think Juventus signed him primarily for commercial reasons, though it helps that Ronaldo is a beast in the Champions League. Likewise, Ronaldo considered Juventus to be among the favourites for the trophy so he joined them in an effort to further his legacy in addition to making more money.

This is all well and good, can't say either Juve or Ronaldo did something stupid here. If Juventus don't win the CL in his time there, the move is still a success. The club will definitely enjoy more popularity now with the CR7 brand, which means more money and altogether a higher standing in football, and the player will make the money he wants along with winning a different league. If they end up winning the CL, all the better.
Yep. Can’t disagree with much there. Though knowing Ronaldo and his individual drive to be the best, not winning another UCL there would disappoint him. He wants another Balon D’Or. or least, he doesn’t want Messi to surpass him.
 
Are we still trying to compare Argentina vs Portugal?

"His supporting cast won a euro"

Did any of you watch the final? any other day and we lost 4-0 in that final. Luckiest shot ever.

Also stop the nonsense
Portugal: Hugo Almedia,Postiga,Danny,Raul Meireles, Miguel Veloso, Danny, Eder, Silvestre Varela, Andre Martins, Josue. This was for most go his international career...

Do I even need to mention the players Messi has at Argentina.

FACT: Messi out of Barcelona is a shadow of the player he normally is period. He is a system player always has been and that a fine but let's not pretend he is something he is not and that Ronaldo was blessed with an amazing national team. Ronaldo would have put in work with the players Messi has played with.
 
Are we still trying to compare Argentina vs Portugal?

"His supporting cast won a euro"

Did any of you watch the final? any other day and we lost 4-0 in that final. Luckiest shot ever.

Also stop the nonsense
Portugal: Hugo Almedia,Postiga,Danny,Raul Meireles, Miguel Veloso, Danny, Eder, Silvestre Varela, Andre Martins, Josue. This was for most go his international career...

Do I even need to mention the players Messi has at Argentina.

FACT: Messi out of Barcelona is a shadow of the player he normally is period. He is a system player always has been and that a fine but let's not pretend he is something he is not and that Ronaldo was blessed with an amazing national team. Ronaldo would have put in work with the players Messi has played with.

Ronaldo would hardly get any service on that Argentina team
 
Are we still trying to compare Argentina vs Portugal?

"His supporting cast won a euro"

Did any of you watch the final? any other day and we lost 4-0 in that final. Luckiest shot ever.

Also stop the nonsense
Portugal: Hugo Almedia,Postiga,Danny,Raul Meireles, Miguel Veloso, Danny, Eder, Silvestre Varela, Andre Martins, Josue. This was for most go his international career...

Do I even need to mention the players Messi has at Argentina.

FACT: Messi out of Barcelona is a shadow of the player he normally is period. He is a system player always has been and that a fine but let's not pretend he is something he is not and that Ronaldo was blessed with an amazing national team. Ronaldo would have put in work with the players Messi has played with.

Mate you yourself aren't even concinced of what you just posted.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.