Silenced again? Cmon, itll take a better argument than that to hold me down. I saw him proclaim Gerd Muller a GOAT level player and didnt think it warranted a response. How many people have you ever heard put Muller up their with Diego and Pele as GOAT candidates? He is simply not held in that high a regard. Cristiano fans would have you believe he is, because he and Cristiano excel at the same things (heading, clutch, goals, off the ball movement etc).
Cristiano fans, please enlighten us (this should be interesting), who do you consider as the 5 greatest players of all time?
I can claim Bebe is the best player of all time, still do not change that I am using the exact argument you used in your imagination argument with your "Ronaldo fan", and as I guess, there is no reply from you. Whether it's because you are "silenced" or not is up to you, otherwise, feel free to address my post just as I addressed yours. Or you can just say: "oh he said Bebe is GOAT, Ronaldo fan silenced again".
And don't derail the topic, Gerd Muller is 1 of the best striker of all time, therefore
for me he's GOAT level player (Read "level"), but that's for another topic and I am up to it if you want to. Also as I said it myself, I am not Ronaldo fan, I am not again your opinion that Messi > Ronaldo, I am again your way of argument.
I thought redcafe_reader's post was satire. Was it not? "Being better at all these things doesn't mean you are better".
It was to answer to his post, where he argues with "Ronaldo fan" and self claiming victory
Dismantling their arguments is so easy. Case in point.
Cristiano fans: Cristiano is better because he has has won more (debatable but lets go with it).
Messi fans: but that argument is not definitive, otherwise didnt Muller win more than Diego? Was Muller therefore better? Sergio Ramos has won more than Baresi. Who is greater?
Cristiano fans: no answer. But hold on, he's better because he scores better, esp in the CL.
Messi fans: Again, scoring more doesnt make one better, or are you now saying that Lampard was better than Zidane AND Iniesta because he scored more?
Cristiano fans: silence again. But Cristiano is better because he has more Balon Dor votes. Messi fans: again, cant always go by that, otherwise are you saying that Lampard AND Gerrard were MUCH better than Scholes because they destroyed him in Balon Dor voting (in fact, he never got a single vote in his career).
Cristiano fans finally respond: Well sometimes Balon Dor is wrong, look how Sneider got cheated by Messi in 2010. Messi should have 4.
Messi fans: but hold up. One minute you are swearing by The Balon Dor and using it to big up Cristiano, then the next, youre doubting its accuracy. Which is it?
Cristiano fans: Again, no response.
Messi fans: what quality as a footballer makes Cristiano better?
Cristiano fans: Well, how about heading and off the ball movement.
Messi fans: Muller had better heading and off the ball movement than Diego, did that make him better?
Cristiano fans: again silence. Hes another one, Cristiano is more clutch.
Messi fans: Muller was more clutch than Diego. Was he better?
Cristiano fans: silence. But Cristiano has proved it in different leagues, so hes better.
Messi fans: again not definitive. Or are you now saying that Marcel Desailly is greater than Beckenbauer, Moore, Maldini AND Baresi because he proved it in different leagues? Zola better than Roberto Baggio? Evra better than Maldini?
Cristiano fans: silence again.
Breaking down their arguments is like childsplay.
I can do it the same to prove Bebe is better than Maradona
Maradona fans: Diego is better because he has has won more .
Bebe fans: but that argument is not definitive, otherwise didnt Muller win more than Diego? Was Muller therefore better? Sergio Ramos has won more than Baresi. Who is greater?
Maradona fans: no answer. But hold on, he's better because he scores better, esp in the CL.
Bebe fans: Again, scoring more doesnt make one better, or are you now saying that Lampard was better than Zidane AND Iniesta because he scored more?
Maradona fans: silence again. But Diego is better because he has more Balon Dor votes.
Bebe fans: again, cant always go by that, otherwise are you saying that Lampard AND Gerrard were MUCH better than Scholes because they destroyed him in Balon Dor voting (in fact, he never got a single vote in his career).
...
Just replace "Ronaldo" with "Maradona" and "Messi" with "Bebe" and do the rest, imagination is
@Tostao_80's strong points after all.