United fans usually say De Gea is a world class keeper and you expect him to make the majority of his great saves. Mignolet... Not so much.
Liverpool 2014/15 | WARNING: Contains strong amounts of Scouse nonsense
- Thread starter Wumminator
- Start date
United fans usually say De Gea is a world class keeper and you expect him to make the majority of his great saves. Mignolet... Not so much.
ROFL ! Looks again ... ahahahhahahaha !!
What ? Park two double decker buses ? Don't think LvG would do that
It's still not luck if a keeper makes a good save though.
What ? Park two double decker buses ? Don't think LvG would do that
No, come to Anfield and win.
This is what I expect too. We were a little too naive at OT. Made a lot of chances, which we failed to convert, but also over-committed when we went forward.
When you look at the potential battles it's fascinating :
Young + Blind vs Sterling + Can
Di Maria + Valencia vs Moreno + Sakho. I'd go with Moreno over Johnson simply because of his pace, though if he continues with his fouling that will be a major concern.
Sterling / Sturridge / Coutinho / Lallana vs Jones (or will Rojo return ?) / Smalling / Carrick / Blind / Valencia
Rooney + Mata + Fellaini vs. Skrtel / Can / Sakho
Henderson / Coutinho / Allen / Sterling vs. Carrick, Herrera (perhaps) / Fellaini / Blind / Valencia
Both keepers in form.
Last edited:
In the PL this season only one keeper has more clean sheets than Ming (11) ... Forster (13). Though I know it's a team effort of course.
But no one actually said anything about luck though, that was you. You begun by saying Liverpool 'could had should' have won by more but somehow you completely disregard the chances Swansea had by claiming it was good goalkeeping so it doesn't count. Surely it works both ways no?
Any chance of Lovren starting?
Except only one of those 'efforts' I listed for Liverpool were actually saved ! Same goes for those Swansea two 'chances' that were high, wide and mighty that the poster listed as chances. And of course I only listed those LFC chances to add a balance to the poster saying Swansea should have been 1-1 at worst .. whilst completely ignoring the more (and better) chances we had to score. More chances should equal more goals, assuming conversion rates is roughly similar.
I bloody hope not !
I'd prefer to bring Flanno or Johnson in at RCB if for any reason one of Skrtel/Sakho/Can can't start. Though that's a little unfair on Flanno who is obviously going to be off the pace and not match-fit (and maybe a little unfair on Lovren who has been showing some very positive signs of improvement).That's why I'm asking.
Hope he will somehow.
Barring a freak training ground accident though I'd expect Skrtel/Sakho/Can to start. Can was pretty horrendous yesterday though .. it wouldn't be a massive surprise to see Johnson replace him at RCB. Though I expect BR to give Can the benefit of the doubt and assume he's not going to play back to back games like yesterday. His calmness when under pressure on the ball could be vital.
So basically Lovren plays when Sakho isnt available or?
There's also the off-chance Lucas could see action .. though there's no way he'll start of course.
Pretty much. I think the back three for this season is established. Maybe we will see some changes at RCB in the Summer if BR decides to move Can into MF more.
So therefore it's lucky when mignolet makes good saves? For 2-3 months straight. Right.
If Can doesn't start, I'd expect Lovren to go in ahead of Johnson.
Depends on the keeper and the save. If Mignolet produced some of the saves De Gea has made this season it would be luck, because it's not in his repertoire. The same save can be somewhat lucky for Mignolet but not lucky for De Gea. Just like the same 35 yard rocket wouldn't be luck for Ronaldo, but would be luck for Phil Jones.
See above. Against Swansea it was a combination because the finishing should have been much better.
Lovren was crap against Blackburn; not sure what you are watching.
No..Mignolet's in form, DDG is just fantastically good. Form or no form!
I'm going to spend some time getting my head around that because your logic is seriously unfathomable.
Ming, BTW, is renowned for his shot-stopping and agility, it's the basics; commanding his area, distribution and aerially, where he needs to improve (and has visibly done so since Xmas).
I'm judging his improvement from watching every minute of every match he's played. I'm guessing you can't say the same.
I'll still take that
It's a bit like United though isn't it? Stats say one thing while the eye says another. Perhaps like United around the end of last year, "your luck is due to run out" and you'll get the results your performances deserve.
You need to judge better then. He's been crap, same as he always has been.
Seriously ? Like wasn't he one of the top CBs in the Pl last season ? So not "same as he always has been" then.
No.
He was decent last season. Nowhere near one of the best.
And as we've seen this season, the PL isn't exactly a haven of great centre backs.
Hell, Southampton are far better defensively this season then last.
To be honest against Swansea he made a couple of good saves but they weren't what I'd call lucky. It was more down to poor finishing than anything else (from Gomes, Shelvey and Sigurdsson particularly).
But I'd say the logic is pretty straight forward.
Lucky - that's exactly the point I was making. And you can't quote 'poor finishing' either because that goes even more for us yesterday !
Your logic is flawed because Ming is an excellent shot-stopper (shot-stopping being the whole basis of your argument). He has far more FUs in other areas though than De Gea, and is generally poorer in most other aspects of keeping. But you can't knock his shot-stopping.
Yep. Can't leave out our best performer, Joe Allen. Best player on the park against City, Southampton and Swansea. Henderson has been good and he's taken the plaudits on here and in the media, but it's the Welsh Xavi who deserves them.
He was poor against Blackburn, but there have been definite improvements to his game recently. He's not calamity Lovren anymore. Had a good second half against City. Doesn't offer anywhere near what Sakho does though.
He was a very good centre back last season. Top 6-7 in the league, definitely, and arguably the best before January. He's been a massive failure for us.
My overall point was that luck is dependent on the talent of the player in question. De Gea and Mignolet could make the exact same save and because it'd be an 8/10 save for De Gea rather than a 3/10 save for Mignolet one would be fortunate whereas the other wouldn't. Therefore if a poster said Liverpool were lucky last night it isn't necessarily double standards to suggest United haven't necessarily been lucky in a similar situation in our matches. Although Mignolet is a good shop stopper, he's still miles behind De Gea who I'd say is comfortably the best in the world in that aspect.
Personally I thought Liverpool were lucky last night but not because of fortunate goalkeeping, because of poor finishing. I don't think Liverpool had any simple chances that they missed, but Swansea had a couple.
I think that is generous, but even if it were the case, top 6-7 in the PL isn't exactly mighty praise.
You can try justify his signing all you want but most on here did say it was a crazy purchase at that price at the time, though certainly people didn't expect him to be this rubbish.
You think it's generous that he was arguably the best defender before January? Here are some posts from his thread in the middle of November.
And most of this thread thought he'd be a good signing (granted, there are a few who said he would not be).
https://www.redcafe.net/threads/dejan-lovren.384190/
fwiw I said/thought he was the best CB outside the top clubs, and therefore the best to buy for those clubs if they wanted a player already in the prem.
But he's been poor. He also dropped his level as mentioned in the thread where it was pointed out he had some poor matches
But he's been poor. He also dropped his level as mentioned in the thread where it was pointed out he had some poor matches
The first thread was made in November, when him and Southampton were certainly flying. If that's the most recent you can find for him it's not great.
And the second thread, "most said", really? Most of what's on the second page, the one active when you signed him, is Utd posters saying he's not that good and not worth the fee, and you defending him from those comments
Well so far I think almost all of your players have struggled to adept to life under Rodgers, so I probably wouldn't count him out before the end of next season if he keeps playing like shit.
Were do you get that from? Can, Moreno, Lallana and Markovic have fit in very well, it's only normal they needed some time to adapt at first. Lambert and Balotelli always had a high probablility of failing at Liverpool and Lovren has been a bad signing so far, yeah.