Lionel Messi

Status
Not open for further replies.
I dont personally see Ronaldo getting much better, maybe he'll improve his attitude but as for his strenghs i think they are peaked, his pace, power etc
That is where you are wrong.

1. Ronaldo has never had an attitude problem. When it comes to football he is a consumate proffesional. Not even Messi trains as hard as Ronaldo does.

2. Ronaldo's strengths are not his pace and power. His real strengths are work rate and his all round game. Like most players his pace and power wont be getting better beyond age 24. But you can rest assured his passing, shooting, heading and vision will simply get better as he gets more experienced. So will his anticipation. Because unlike a player like Messi or Rooney he wasn't super mature aged 17. So he has more room for rapid improvement.

For me he'll never match his feats for United, the 06-08 was the best of Ronaldo.
That is because you dont think very highly of him as player, unfortunately. That's why you have even entertained the thought of Kaka out performing him in La liga.

Is Ronaldo a United legend? after his 6 years at the club?
He should be. He won't be classified as one by fickles fans because he left though.

Messi though, he can't be stopped.
Messi is will be a Barca legend because he will never leave. Not because" he can't be stopped"
 
Also i didnt know 2 fantastic seasons make you a legend at a club....

Also chief if you can give me one example of another player with your "he wasnt mature young so has room for rapid improvement" theory i'd be interested to here about that.

because frankly Mr Rubberman it sounds like bullshit to me.

Ronaldo doesnt have a bad attitude? I may be pigeonholed as the ultimate anti-Ronaldo caf member but the whole world is aware of Ronaldos attitude and petulance. It's common knowledge, even the majority of United fans were getting fed up with that side of him.
 
You're making that up. We can only judge by what happens to the pitch and Ronaldo had a big attitude problem last season.
I'm certainly not. Fergie who has trained him for the last 6 years says he has never had a problem with Ronaldo in training, has often praised the lad's work rate in training and has said time and again the lad never missed a training session. His teamates have also never complained about him in terms of what goes on in the dressing room either. That is more than enough evidence for me to conclude he doesn't have an attitude problem.

The football games rarely if ever tells you the fulll story about a player's attitude.
 
Also i didnt know 2 fantastic seasons make you a legend at a club....
2 season above and beyond anything anyone has produce at that club before should. Especially when the rest of your years there were not shit either.
Also chief if you can give me one example of another player with your "he wasnt mature young so has room for rapid improvement" theory i'd be interested to here about that.

because frankly Mr Rubberman it sounds like bullshit to me..
2 names. Zidane and Henry.

Zidane below age 25 was just great potential. He was very immature in style and kind of a hot head. No one expected him to be an all time great. Just a very god player if he fulfield his potential.

Instead by the time he was 26, in just 2 seasons he went from what I described to the best of his generation.

Thierry Henry. Remember him at Juve? Or the fact that at 18 players like Saha, Kabe Diarwara:lol: and Kanu Nwankwo were considered better talents than he'd ever be? Years down the road after his massive flop at Juve. Just 2 years under Wenger he went from a failed winger to possible the best player to ever grace the premiership and was competing with the likes of Ronaldinho for world player of the year.

I could also bring up Ballack to. Below age 25 he wasn't that special either.

Ronaldo doesnt have a bad attitude? I may be pigeonholed as the ultimate anti-Ronaldo caf member but the whole world is aware of Ronaldos attitude and petulance. It's common knowledge, even the majority of United fans were getting fed up with that side of him.
You are confusing on pitch antics with his attitude to football. Those two don't go hand in hand. I don't believe people like Fergie and Scolari have reason to lie when the say Ronaldo is the consummate professional in training and in the dressing room. Ronaldo when it comes to training is 110% dedicated to it and has a fantastic attitude to it. It is because this dedication and his single minded desire to be the best around that he has improved at the rate at which he has.

If you were under the illusion that he fools around and is petulant in training then you are very mistaken. To accuse him of having a bad attitude, that needs improving for him to get better as a player is wide of the mark frankly. . What you see on the pitch hardly ever tells you the true story about a player. You of all people should know this. Just look at Eto'o. No one who watches him play only, would ever believe he is such a problem off the pitch.
 
I'm saying you get players who can do all those things but Ronaldo can do them all and that is why he is Ronaldo...

Goals and results? then why does Messi have a better careerwise goals per game ratio? why does he have a better medal haul despite being 3 years younger?

facts cal? he's better, i doubt you'll ever admit it even when their careers are over and Messi goes down as a legend of the game.

Messi has a better careerwise goals per game ratio because he started his career upfront, unlike Ronaldo who spent the first many years on the wing - surely it's pretty obvious!! Also most players in La Liga have better goals records, Forlan being the example.

He has a better medal haul because whether we like it or not, Barcelona have had some great great players in the last few years, even more so than United.

Who's better can only be a matter of OPINION, it cannot be FACT - when can you get that concept into your thick skull. :wenger:

Never mind the FACT that the best manager ever ever thinks otherwise.
 
I dont personally see Ronaldo getting much better, maybe he'll improve his attitude but as for his strenghs i think they are peaked, his pace, power etc

For me he'll never match his feats for United, the 06-08 was the best of Ronaldo.

Is Ronaldo a United legend? after his 6 years at the club?

I'd be surprised if he was.

Messi though, he can't be stopped.

Again, your opinions...

I hope Ronaldo doesn't get better because he no longer plays for United, but Sir Alex seems to think he'd get better - wonder who I should trust... Sir Alex or internet warrior FV... :confused:

Messi can be stopped, Chelsea did it very well, so did Espanyol actually, you just need to get your tactics right.
 
Torres being an example of how it can work the other way around Cal?

you state that goals/medals are all that matters then i prove with the fact that messi has a better goal record and medal haul you retort with "Who's better can only be a matter of OPINION, it cannot be FACT - when can you get that concept into your thick skull." You are one of a kind cal. One of a kind.

I wonder if you're really just a total idiot or are actually just a very good wum who in order to wind people up acts like a clueless 12 year old. I really cant work it out...

Yeah, i hope you take everything SAF says as fact, he's never been known to state anything other than the truth :lol:

Of course he can get better, it's just my opinion that he wont. At least not by much.
 
No one is questioning his professionalism, his attitude is being questioned. THey are different things, he is a great pro, no doubt but his antics on the pitch and the way he conducted himself last season at times was appauling.

That's right, Messi's attitude is great and he's cleaner than snow.

Wait, remember that youtube link I posted when he armed a goal?

No, but it's okay when Messi does it. Argie footballing legends should be allowed to use their arms to compensate for lack of height? :smirk:
 
Torres being an example of how it can work the other way around Cal?

you state that goals/medals are all that matters then i prove with the fact that messi has a better goal record and medal haul you retort with "Who's better can only be a matter of OPINION, it cannot be FACT - when can you get that concept into your thick skull." You are one of a kind cal. One of a kind.

I wonder if you're really just a total idiot or are actually just a very good wum who in order to wind people up acts like a clueless 12 year old. I really cant work it out...

Yeah, i hope you take everything SAF says as fact, he's never been known to state anything other than the truth :lol:

No, I merely pointed out that I respect his OPINION... again, you really do struggle with that concept don't you?? Opinions and facts - they are different things. :lol:
 
I've never claimed Messi was "cleaner than snow"...

he's following in the footsteps of every argie boys idol what can i say.

You go on and on about Ronaldo's supposed attitude problem but Messi has exactly the same problem.

In fact, I'm convinced that Messi dives more than Ronaldo.
 
You go on and on about Ronaldo's supposed attitude problem but Messi has exactly the same problem.

In fact, I'm convinced that Messi dives more than Ronaldo.

Sums you up completely, absolutely blind as a bat.

Cal? before this season you had a leg to stand on, now you dont. You're nothing more than a mild amusement for anyone who has a clue about football.

has anyone ever agreed with you about anything (other than other Ronaldo fan boys).

You deny Ronaldo has an attitude problem, but then you say Messi has the exact same problem... wait, who has a problem? doesnt Ronaldo not have a problem? so if messi has the same problem does that mean he also doesnt have a problem? :wenger:

Now Messi dives more than Ronaldo :lol:

one of a kind cal? you really are. :lol:
 
I think Ronaldo's attitude will keep him up at the top of the tree for many years to come. I don't think he's got an attitude problem, in fact I'd go so far as to say he'd be great influence on younger players.

He's a natural born winner and he's willing to work for it.
 
Football is a team game after all and despite what you may think a player cannot win anything for his team singlehandedly. It's a myth. Maradona didnt even do it.

As an individual Ronaldo was a phenomenon. He may not have had a brilliant club career but then neither did Maradona yet what he did do is far greater and will not be forgotten.

100% agree with you here.It pains me to see people looking at trophies and such to measure the greatness of a player, I could think of LeTissier who was a magician
 
Only idiots say that Trophies and Medal tallies equate to a player's individual greatness - it's an argument only people as blinkered as Cal make, funnily enough.
 
I think Ronaldo's attitude will keep him up at the top of the tree for many years to come. I don't think he's got an attitude problem, in fact I'd go so far as to say he'd be great influence on younger players.

He's a natural born winner and he's willing to work for it.

As a pro i'd absolutely agree, you would be hard pushed to find a player that has worked harder than Ronaldo. He is the product of a lot of talent and a shed load of hard work. Always last off the training ground and has that constant desire to improve. A great influence on a young player, to see how hard he works even when he's the best around.

However some of his behaviour last season was rubbish, walking off the pitch, the constant arm flailing, chastising team mates and all the little hissy fits he would have were frankly embarassing.
 
As a pro i'd absolutely agree, you would be hard pushed to find a player that has worked harder than Ronaldo. He is the product of a lot of talent and a shed load of hard work. Always last off the training ground and has that constant desire to improve. A great influence on a young player, to see how hard he works even when he's the best around.

However some of his behaviour last season was rubbish, walking off the pitch, the constant arm flailing, chastising team mates and all the little hissy fits he would have were frankly embarassing.

Attitude on the field is/was certainly a different matter. But the fact was he knew it was to be his last year at United, and he didn't particularly want to be there.

He's got the type of attitude that I'd want around Arsenal, and thankfully we've got Arshavin to influence players in the same manner.

You just can't beat natural born winners. They just want it more than others.
 
As a pro i'd absolutely agree, you would be hard pushed to find a player that has worked harder than Ronaldo. He is the product of a lot of talent and a shed load of hard work. Always last off the training ground and has that constant desire to improve. A great influence on a young player, to see how hard he works even when he's the best around.

However some of his behaviour last season was rubbish, walking off the pitch, the constant arm flailing, chastising team mates and all the little hissy fits he would have were frankly embarassing.

I agree a little but at the same time it's part of his personna.I don't think it will harm his career in any possible, he's too good for that.Besides now at a new club, it's a fresh start for him, we may not see the behavior he displayed at United a club which he wanted to leave a long time ago.I didn't that him wanting to leave was the reason for him to be a dick on the field but it could explain it a little
edit: Cesc explained it well too
 
Sums you up completely, absolutely blind as a bat.

Cal? before this season you had a leg to stand on, now you dont. You're nothing more than a mild amusement for anyone who has a clue about football.

has anyone ever agreed with you about anything (other than other Ronaldo fan boys).

You deny Ronaldo has an attitude problem, but then you say Messi has the exact same problem... wait, who has a problem? doesnt Ronaldo not have a problem? so if messi has the same problem does that mean he also doesnt have a problem? :wenger:

Now Messi dives more than Ronaldo :lol:

one of a kind cal? you really are. :lol:

Says the man who claims 2 seasons doesn't make a legend, but ONE is enough to announce Messi as the greatest player in the world. :rolleyes:

Has anyone agreed with you regarding Messi (other than other Messi fanbois)?

You and vijay are 2 of a kind...
 
2 season above and beyond anything anyone has produce at that club before should. Especially when the rest of your years there were not shit either.

Not shit but hardly brilliant either, i dont think 2 years at the top of your game make you a legend at a club, that's just me though.

2 names. Zidane and Henry.

Zidane below age 25 was just great potential. He was very immature in style and kind of a hot head. No one expected him to be an all time great. Just a very god player if he fulfield his potential.

Instead by the time he was 26, in just 2 seasons he went from what I described to the best of his generation.

Thierry Henry. Remember him at Juve? Or the fact that at 18 players like Saha, Kabe Diarwara:lol: and Kanu Nwankwo were considered better talents than he'd ever be? Years down the road after his massive flop at Juve. Just 2 years under Wenger he went from a failed winger to possible the best player to ever grace the premiership and was competing with the likes of Ronaldinho for world player of the year.

I could also bring up Ballack to. Below age 25 he wasn't that special either.

Big big differences, on the one hand Henry was actually excellent for Monaco which is why he got his move to Juve, Juve didnt know how to deploy him, keeping him on the wing where he was ineffective. We all know what happend when Wenger got him at arsenal. What age was he when he joined Arsenal? 22? 23? he made an imediate impact.

Zidane was a playmaker, generally a position that required more time to mature into. Whilst a manager will gladly have a young winger out wide they think twice before allowing a young orchestrator a free reign in the side. He was already a full france international before joining Juve.

It is very normal for a player in a central midfield position to enjoy his finest years between the ages of 25 and onwards, that is quite obvious to all.

Ballack at 25 was leading Leverkusen to the champions league final etc, and again as a central midfielder it is very common to mature and be a better player. As a winger it is much more common to get more playing time at a top side because you can afford to not be in games. A central midfielder must have disapline and that comes with maturity.
 
Kouroux/Cesc, i agree.

I wonder if that side of him will dissapear now that he is living his boyhood dream and happy in his new Madrid home. I'm not sure, i hope it does though.

Cal? Plenty of people are open to the fact that Messi has everything to be the best of his generation, i'd honestly say more people think Messi is the better player.

It's a credit to Ronaldo that he is even mentioned in the same breath.
 
Kouroux/Cesc, i agree.

I wonder if that side of him will dissapear now that he is living his boyhood dream and happy in his new Madrid home. I'm not sure, i hope it does though.

Cal? Plenty of people are open to the fact that Messi has everything to be the best of his generation, i'd honestly say more people think Messi is the better player.

It's a credit to Ronaldo that he is even mentioned in the same breath.

:lol: Fekin hell
 
Kouroux/Cesc, i agree.

I wonder if that side of him will dissapear now that he is living his boyhood dream and happy in his new Madrid home. I'm not sure, i hope it does though.

Cal? Plenty of people are open to the fact that Messi has everything to be the best of his generation, i'd honestly say more people think Messi is the better player.

It's a credit to Ronaldo that he is even mentioned in the same breath.
Seriously FV I know plenty of people who also think the same for Ronaldo.These views right now mean nothing as they are just random predictions
 
Thierry Henry. Remember him at Juve? Or the fact that at 18 players like Saha, Kabe Diarwara:lol: and Kanu Nwankwo were considered better talents than he'd ever be? Years down the road after his massive flop at Juve. Just 2 years under Wenger he went from a failed winger to possible the best player to ever grace the premiership and was competing with the likes of Ronaldinho for world player of the year.

Harsh. Henry was highly rated at Monaco and by the age of 20 helped them reach the semi-finals of the Champions League and had a good World Cup in 1998.
 
Kouroux/Cesc, i agree.

I wonder if that side of him will dissapear now that he is living his boyhood dream and happy in his new Madrid home. I'm not sure, i hope it does though.

I think it will spur him to reach the same heights of 06-08, at least.

He'll want to go down in their history for more than just being their record signing. You can bet your bottom dollar he'll want to be remembered in the same light as their greatest ever players.
 
The football games rarely if ever tells you the fulll story about a player's attitude.
That's the whole story the rest is just hearsay and speculation. Ronaldo wasn't arsed to get out of second gear for about 3/4 of last season only stirring himself when there was a free kick to be taken. He only really tried in the latter stages of the CL when there was a suitable stage for him.
 
That's the whole story the rest is just hearsay and speculation. Ronaldo wasn't arsed to get out of second gear for about 3/4 of last season only stirring himself when there was a free kick to be taken. He only really tried in the latter stages of the CL when there was a suitable stage for him.

Where he exposed Arsenal as the small boys they are trying to play in a mans competition?
 
You really have some serious issues in your life I'm afraid.Just because you are so sure of it that give it more credibility than it has or hasn't already

No need for that, it was a quote from The Big Lebowski....

anyway, i've never seen a player like Messi in my lifetime, i find it strange that others dont see what i see in him. From the age of 17 i've banged on about him as being the best player around and the fact that now with him about to pick up all the awards at the age of 22 (although everything he did to win them was done at 21) only confirms i was right then and i think i'll be proven right again.

Of course i'll wait and see but until then these discussions will always happen and you know for a fact that even if Messi was the best plenty of people would say he wasnt.

I think it will spur him to reach the same heights of 06-08, at least.

He'll want to go down in their history for more than just being their record signing. You can bet your bottom dollar he'll want to be remembered in the same light as their greatest ever players.

I hope it does, i'd love Madrid to be awesome with Ronaldo/Kaka/Benzema etc. It'll make for a fantastic La Liga in the coming years. El Classico is going to be epic!
 
No need for that, it was a quote from The Big Lebowski....

anyway, i've never seen a player like Messi in my lifetime, i find it strange that others dont see what i see in him. From the age of 17 i've banged on about him as being the best player around and the fact that now with him about to pick up all the awards at the age of 22 (although everything he did to win them was done at 21) only confirms i was right then and i think i'll be proven right again.

Of course i'll wait and see but until then these discussions will always happen and you know for a fact that even if Messi was the best plenty of people would say he wasnt.



I hope it does, i'd love Madrid to be awesome with Ronaldo/Kaka/Benzema etc. It'll make for a fantastic La Liga in the coming years. El Classico is going to be epic!
Of course he's been the best this last season, no one denies that
It's all "he'll be the best for a long time " that I think is pointless and using "plenty of people" as reference is meaningless as I could say "plenty of people" don't think this or that, would that give my view more truth ?
 
Not shit but hardly brilliant either, i dont think 2 years at the top of your game make you a legend at a club, that's just me though.
But one great season is enough to make you declare Messi has proved " the best of his generation" in your opinion? Sounds fishy to me that. :p
Big big differences, on the one hand Henry was actually excellent for Monaco which is why he got his move to Juve,
Lets be honest he was no better at Monaco than Ron was at Sporting lisbon.

Juve didnt know how to deploy him, keeping him on the wing where he was ineffective.
Actually tbf he was a good winger at Monaco. Capable of playing upfront.

We all know what happend when Wenger got him at arsenal. What age was he when he joined Arsenal? 22? 23? he made an imediate impact.
No. He took just under 2 years to go from being good to absolutely brilliant.

Zidane was a playmaker, generally a position that required more time to mature into. Whilst a manager will gladly have a young winger out wide they think twice before allowing a young orchestrator a free reign in the side. He was already a full france international before joining Juve.
Which is isn't the issue. The issue is before he hit 25 he wasn't all that. But in just 2 years, i.e age 25 and 26, he did wonders for Bordeaux and France, then Juve and was in not time the best on the planet.

It is very normal for a player in a central midfield position to enjoy his finest years between the ages of 25 and onwards, that is quite obvious to all.
Clearly. But going from good to absolutely great in a short time is what I was pointing out.
It happens more often than you were willing to admit.

Ballack at 25 was leading Leverkusen to the champions league final etc, and again as a central midfielder it is very common to mature and be a better player.
Which isn't the issue. Below 25 he was not even close to talents like Messi, Fabregas or Rooney. That is why his improvement was more dramatic and prounced. Players like Rooney and Fabregas will reach such heights much slower because of how mature they were when they were really young.

That is why I keep stating that a Ronaldo has much more scope for all round improvement than a Messi.

As a winger it is much more common to get more playing time at a top side because you can afford to not be in games. A central midfielder must have disapline and that comes with maturity.
But playing time is not the issue. It's rate of development that is. If it was just about playing time a player like Lennon would be as almost as good as Messi and Ron by now.

From what I've seen of the football world, players who are very mature at young ages usually take longer to make the next steps in their development. Because they don't really have far to go to be finished articles. Rooney and Fabregas are great examples of this. They wont improve at a rate of a Ron. Same as Messi. The things they are left reaching for are things which mainly experience and age brings. That is why you won't see a Messi a make a Roanld like quantum leap in development. He will instead just get more consistent, physically stronger and develop better awareness.

While players like Ronaldo or Zizou who were raw at young ages, tend to climb the chain of development super fast. Even in a period of 2 seasons they can go from good to fecking brilliant. Yet still have things to add to their games. Like can eb sen with Ronaldo. That is why even, for example, between 96 and 99 Zizou just got better and better, as he matured in all aspects of his play.
 
Harsh. Henry was highly rated at Monaco and by the age of 20 helped them reach the semi-finals of the Champions League and had a good World Cup in 1998.
Don't get me wrong. I'm not saying he was very poor. I'm just saying he was no where near as good as he become for Arsenal while he was still at Monaco. He just had good potential. But in a short period under Wenger he exploded into brilliance.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.