Kobbie Mainoo (out)

I think you'll find that other players in the same general predicament as Mainoo - namely the likes of Musiala, Endrick et al., are all going to command much more given their long term potential. He won't want to get locked into a long term low wage contract at a time when he sees Rashford, Bellingham, and others making far more. That's just going to happen, which is why i suspect he's more inclined to move this summer. That last thing he will want is to be trapped in a long term deal such as the likes of Gavi or Pedri until 2030 on a weekly wage he's not happy with, relative to what others are earning.
Musiala is far more established. Endrick signed for 80k a week. If I'm not mistaken if we consider say Martinelli, he was given a new deal at £150k a week for Arsenal after playing for them for a couple of seasons.

In no world is it reasonable to demand £180k a week from less than one season of football in your playing career. That is a massive problem and quite an unreasonable demand for both our standards and for rivals.
 
If he does start to actually show that, then sure. The Guardian headline seems to suggest otherwise, but others reporting this story seem to suggest he actually wants to stay, it's just getting that wage he desires.

Well if these stories are true then the genie is a bit out of the bottle at this point. It's about time that we start acting as a proper club. If a player/agent start leaking this sort of rubbish then he should be at the door.
 
I don't blame him asking that kind of money, he looks at someone like Mount, an average player that earns 250k per week and not even kicking a ball and must think to himself (I should be on more money than him).

But, we have to move away from these types of deals.
Then he didn't get the memo about the club will no longer be handing out contracts like Casemiro's and Mount's.
 
Then he didn't get the memo about the club will no longer be handing out contracts like Casemiro's and Mount's.

Those were established players who were first teamers in successful sides who won Liga titles and CL titles. What did Mainoo do exactly? Few months of good football followed by....?
 
Bye bye, won’t be missed. This time last year we were talking about “potential” for the future. And potential he has but so far boy you have done next to nothing. Is this because us fans big up too much our academy graduates? No idea, it’s a question. Garnacho the same, so entitled, you’ve done nothing boss. If you don’t want in, adiós, you’re not as good as the amount of followers you have, just because you play for United, make you think you are. You have so much to prove, you haven’t proved anything yet. You are not a superstar , you are a young footballer in a superstar club. Don’t mix it up.
 
Those were established players who were first teamers in successful sides who won Liga titles and CL titles. What did Mainoo do exactly? Few months of good football followed by....?

A winner in a cup final. Fairly memorably.
 
I actually feel that there's a principle involved and a precedent to set here but it definitely is not "we don't sell our promising academy players no matter what" but instead "we will no longer be offering very high wages to players off the back of one or two seasons of good football".

Hell, I don't begrudge Mainoo for asking for these wages. If another club is willing to pay it, why shouldn't he? I simply think that we have to look at the situation we're in right now and ask if we can afford to turn down 70 or 80 million (which affords us quite considerably more than that in PSR leeway this summer) for a player who, whilst showing a lot of promise, is still really yet to fully prove he's ready to make a big impact in our current manager's setup.

It'd be a gut punch to lose Mainoo, sure, but if we re-invest the fee we'd get for him smartly we could pick up two or three first-team players at a time when so many areas of the squad are in dire need of improvement. To my mind, the rational move here may well be to sell.
 
It is so sad. Not even our own best talents want to stay at United. Mainoo is, in my eyes, our biggest talent since Scholes.
 
Gavi is on 149k a week and Joao Neves is on 145k a week. At the 180k-200k bracket you'll find the likes of Camavinga and Pedri. I very much doubt that these sort of clubs would give that salary to a kid who had few months of good football in him

Sher didn't they sign Camavinga on huge wages directly out of the French league after 2 or maybe 3 seasons? Another good decision on their part. The fact thar Mainoo has broken into the England team and has shown a very special ability in the Euros, the PL and the cups (in flashes) makes him a fairly safe bet for them to say yes this guy is actually very special for his age, he clearly is too. We as fans are all just jaded from failure and the club is broke from getting too many decisions like this wrong but 200k a week is nothing to Real PSG or Barca to get the new English wonder boy out of the the PL. If he makes it its a bargain for Bellingham's international midfield partner. Also we probably aren't currently exactly in a position to demand as massive of a fee or telling them to feck off like we could if we were winning stuff and had lots of money knocking around.

If it was up to me I'd have sent Rashford packing instead of offering him 350. There would have been a similar lukewarm market for him back then I'm sure.
I'd give Mainoo 150 and a lot of achieveible add-ons as a "sensible" long term deal but other clubs can and probably will offer more up front because they have the wiggle room and he's an exceptional talent. We were one of the big fish but now we are going to have to suck it up for a few years. I'd imagine he's had his head turned and you can't blame him if he has
 
Looking forward to the summer.

It might be utter carnage in the transfer market in terms of ins and outs but it really needs to be done.

Club needs a total reset and a fresh start.

Anyone that is good enough and wants to stay is fine, literally anyone else can leave.
 
A smart move to leave his dream club at the first sign of strife. Right.
He's 19, he can always plan to run his contract down at whatever club he goes to and come back here if we figure our shit out by then. It doesn't make somebody not a supporter of the club to look leave when we are an absolute disaster. I'm sure he'd want nothing more than to stay here long term. But at the expense of your own career? The failure of the past 10 years and the toxic atmosphere around the club 100% will have effects like this and I don't blame any of the players for wanting to look after themselves. It's easy to be a one club player and play for your dream club when your club is winning your whole career like it was under Sir Alex. It's definitely not easy to do it when the club is where we are currently at, even pushing out the home grown players because of the FFP bullshit.
 
Well if these stories are true then the genie is a bit out of the bottle at this point. It's about time that we start acting as a proper club. If a player/agent start leaking this sort of rubbish then he should be at the door.
His agent has already shown himself to be a bit of a chancery, if the £200k pw stories are real.

He'd have to start scoring 20+ goals a season from midfield to be worth that.
 
Looking forward to the summer.

It might be utter carnage in the transfer market in terms of ins and outs but it really needs to be done.

Club needs a total reset and a fresh start.

Anyone that is good enough and wants to stay is fine, literally anyone else can leave.

Yeah but we know that won’t happen. We’ll sell the likes of Mainoo and possibly Garnacho whilst the likes of Casemiro and the rest of high rollers are still clinging to the club

There’s no way back for this club. The debt is too much and 12 years of reckless spending have left us absolutely fecked, we’ll be selling our better players to rival teams in the coming seasons.
 
He's 19, he can always plan to run his contract down at whatever club he goes to and come back here if we figure our shit out by then. It doesn't make somebody not a supporter of the club to look leave when we are an absolute disaster. I'm sure he'd want nothing more than to stay here long term. But at the expense of your own career? The failure of the past 10 years and the toxic atmosphere around the club 100% will have effects like this and I don't blame any of the players for wanting to look after themselves. It's easy to be a one club player and play for your dream club when your club is winning your whole career like it was under Sir Alex. It's definitely not easy to do it when the club is where we are currently at, even pushing out the home grown players because of the FFP bullshit.
Especially as our current manager doesn't seem to rate him as much as Ten Hag did - maybe in his "desired" position. I wouldn't blame him if he wanted a big fecking contract to stay at this current shit show or hell move, he won't be short of suitors.
 
Yeah but we know that won’t happen. We’ll sell the likes of Mainoo and possibly Garnacho whilst the likes of Casemiro and the rest of high rollers are still clinging to the club

There’s no way back for this club. The debt is too much and 12 years of reckless spending have left us absolutely fecked, we’ll be selling our better players to rival teams in the coming seasons.
We'll come back. It will just take more time than we thought or hope. Like you say, the only players we can truly make decent money on will be the actual players who are worth keeping. It's going to take a while to do this transition where we get rid of the worthwhile talents, struggle to get rid of the dead wood, wait for their contracts to expire, become a regular bottom half team and then slow rebuild by bringing in better and better talent to work our way up again before we are at a good point with the talent & the finances. That doesn't seem like a 1-2 year process. More like a 5 year process IMO, because it takes time to tear it down before it can be rebuilt.

And if we take the route of just keeping Mainoo, Garna and other talent who needs proper development... then I just don't think they'll actually develop properly as players here so the hypothetical value we all see in them won't ever reach the level it should.
 
Especially as our current manager doesn't seem to rate him as much as Ten Hag did - maybe in his "desired" position. I wouldn't blame him if he wanted a big fecking contract to stay at this current shit show or hell move, he won't be short of suitors.
Yeah. It's just called looking after yourself. No matter how much you love the club, his advisors really should be looking for his own interests and what will give him the best career as a footballer. And that absolutely is fecking off and growing elsewhere while the shit show works itself out here.
 
Can't help but think us offering him around Europe in January has helped turn his head off he really does want to leave.
 
Yeah. It's just called looking after yourself. No matter how much you love the club, his advisors really should be looking for his own interests and what will give him the best career as a footballer. And that absolutely is fecking off and growing elsewhere while the shit show works itself out here.
We've also shown we bring players back for big money in the past. Id love him to be a success here, but it seems like bad timing for him and us with Amorim. I think if Ten Hag was still here, we'd have more chance of keeping him. It's funny how we were told he would have broken through and been good under any manager, but he's looked like a shade of himself under this one.
 
I like Mainoo but trying to get 180k a week is outrageous for a 19 year old. He shouldn't be sold but if he wants to leave, then it's better to be that way. Mainoo is genuinely a big talent but no player in this squad is irreplaceable.

Man Utd should not give him those kind of wages. He needs to be a more established player to earn that.
 
Get rid.

Overhyped massively, too slow for Amorim's style of play.

It may very well be that he’s overrated, but I don’t get how/why people are so willing to “throw the sink” at/for a mythical style of play we are yet to see any substantial and/or consistent signs of here.

Amorim is still very much an unproven/upcoming manager too.
 
He was great for Ten Hags system but doesn't work for Amorims.

If the club decided to hire a manager that didn't want to build a system around two of its best young players (Mainoo and Garnacho), then it's on the club.

If the club are prioritising Amorim over Mainoo or Garnacho then you may aswell sell them and make some money for suitable players for the system.

If they end up selling these two and still sacking Amorim in the future then the club's double fecked. As the next managers system might have been perfect for Mainoo and Garnacho.

The club already made the decision when they hired a manager that wanted to play 3421.
 
It all comes down to who we decide to hang our hat on, either an unproven young player or an unproven young manager? The high risk high reward option is to go with the latter but sadly I have little faith in INEOS to make the right call either way, despite supposedly building a senior management team of ‘best in class’ individuals whose job it is to do exactly that.
 
We'll struggle to get 70 million. He's been pretty poor this year and that included playing in a midfield 3 under ETH. Seems to also be a little injury prone as well.
 
He was great for Ten Hags system but doesn't work for Amorims.

If the club decided to hire a manager that didn't want to build a system around two of its best young players (Mainoo and Garnacho), then it's on the club.

If the club are prioritising Amorim over Mainoo or Garnacho then you may aswell sell them and make some money for suitable players for the system.

If they end up selling these two and still sacking Amorim in the future then the club's double fecked. As the next managers system might have been perfect for Mainoo and Garnacho.

The club already made the decision when they hired a manager that wanted to play 3421.
Have to agree. It may be the correct decision long term, but stings a bit right now when they were pretty much our only hopes last season.
 
Musiala is far more established. Endrick signed for 80k a week. If I'm not mistaken if we consider say Martinelli, he was given a new deal at £150k a week for Arsenal after playing for them for a couple of seasons.

In no world is it reasonable to demand £180k a week from less than one season of football in your playing career. That is a massive problem and quite an unreasonable demand for both our standards and for rivals.

Endrick is 18 and won't be on those wages for long, irrespective of whatever deal he's currently on. As for Mainoo, you're paying for the future. Just just as clubs pay a lot for young players to transfer, the wages are going to follow a similar model.
 
Well no, it'll be lead by him. He'll be going to the club demanding a higher wage, not us wanting to tie him down longer (although we'll be in a position to react to ensure that, if we do want to keep him)
Any evidence of this, you might be right as I hadn't thought it would have come from his side?
 
Yeah but we know that won’t happen. We’ll sell the likes of Mainoo and possibly Garnacho whilst the likes of Casemiro and the rest of high rollers are still clinging to the club

There’s no way back for this club. The debt is too much and 12 years of reckless spending have left us absolutely fecked, we’ll be selling our better players to rival teams in the coming seasons.
Of course it’s a big if but if the Glazers leave anytime soon, things will slowly but surely be on the up thereafter until United start competing again.

If they stay and there’s no owner to tackle the debt then yeah it’ll just get worse and worse until probably we’re eventually relegated within the next decade

But I’m cautiously confident that INEOS wouldn’t have done the minority deal without a long term assurance that the Glazers will sell. I’m cautiously confident that INEOS will tackle the debt and put more money in when the Glazers are gone and I’m quietly confident that the Glazers would rather sell sooner rather than later because they can see the club going downhill fast
 
No the disgrace would be bowing to those rumoured/reported wage demands, paying someone of his limited achievements £180k a week.... Rashford all over again. But Rashford had achieved more in the game than Kobbie when he got his £200k contract.

Even demanding £120k a week would be outrageous, 19 and not even played a full season yet, questionable fitness and injury record.

Hopefully they get you in for your expertise and judgment pal.
 
Would be a blow, a bit of a damning one too. But if he wants to go, let him
 
Disappointing if the rumours of the wage demands are true.

If it is, he has to be shown the door.

I don't blame him if he wants to leave for footballing reasons, united is not a great place for young talent to thrive.
 
Mainoo isn’t deserving of what he’s asking for. Just because we’ve allowed previous players to be on high wages doesn’t mean he should. We’re trying to right our previous wrongs. People who feels we should bow down to him because he’s a talented homegrown talent are very naive.

If he wants to go, let him go. Mainoo isn’t bigger than the club’s new structure.
 
Ok it's like that is it. Luckily pub time.
yeah but whilst you’re there, just remember that mainoo has demanded 180k a minute to play for us, and then wants to use the money to install a spa and indoor swimming pool, to build the “kobbie mainoo experience.”
 
I’d love to do my job exceptionally well only about 10-15 times and get a 700% pay rise for it.
 
Mainoo 70 million
Garnacho 60 million
Rashford 40 million
Lindelof free
Evans free
Heaton free

Bar 1-2 loans (Antony perhaps) I can’t see anymore leaving . Our squad is thread bare and I’m not sure how much of that we will get to spend due to our financial state.

(we won’t be able to move Casemiro )
I’d be surprised if we did sell Mainoo also