Keir Starmer Labour Leader

and the problem with this is what exactly?

I am not going to get into a debate with you sir. I read your posts about the subject and you sound extremely uneducated about the subject so I am not going to waste my time.
 
I am not going to get into a debate with you sir. I read your posts about the subject and you sound extremely uneducated about the subject so I am not going to waste my time.

Convenient. Talk only to people you agree with and insult those who question you.
 
and the problem with this is what exactly?
Because morally it's wrong? We saw what happened in 2003 when the UK blindly followed the US's lead. It's just another example of Starmers fence sitting and cowardice.
 
Because morally it's wrong? We saw what happened in 2003 when the UK blindly followed the US's lead. It's just another example of Starmers fence sitting and cowardice.


Morality and politics huh? That's an interesting path to go down.

What benefit other than morality do we get from recognising a Palestinian state as opposed to our relations with our biggest partner being maintained?
 
I dunno if it's just this site or what but it feels like labour are being examined far more closely than the Tories and are pretty much being treated like they are already in power.

Dunno if it's because everyone has accepted they will win and have started early or what but I rarely see anyone actually examine the Tories record on stuff or future policies. It's all just scandals and campaign feck ups and gaffs.

Just how it feels to me generally.
 
I dunno if it's just this site or what but it feels like labour are being examined far more closely than the Tories and are pretty much being treated like they are already in power.

Dunno if it's because everyone has accepted they will win and have started early or what but I rarely see anyone actually examine the Tories record on stuff or future policies. It's all just scandals and campaign feck ups and gaffs.

Just how it feels to me generally.

There's clearly a bit of this and, if the Conservative party wasn't such a shit show, it could have been quite damaging to Labour.
 
I dunno if it's just this site or what but it feels like labour are being examined far more closely than the Tories and are pretty much being treated like they are already in power.

Dunno if it's because everyone has accepted they will win and have started early or what but I rarely see anyone actually examine the Tories record on stuff or future policies. It's all just scandals and campaign feck ups and gaffs.

Just how it feels to me generally.
Because they are a dead duck in this election and therefore irrelevant. And it's not like Labour are offering anything significantly different.
 
Morality and politics huh? That's an interesting path to go down.

What benefit other than morality do we get from recognising a Palestinian state as opposed to our relations with our biggest partner being maintained?
Like I said this is the same attitude that dragged the UK into an illegal war.

Recognising Palestine has been done by many other European countries and they haven't fallen apart.

If you separate morals from politics you end up with guys like Trump and all the other lunatics that have been elected into power recently all over the world.

Just because something is broke doesn't mean you don't try to fix it.
 
I dunno if it's just this site or what but it feels like labour are being examined far more closely than the Tories and are pretty much being treated like they are already in power.

Dunno if it's because everyone has accepted they will win and have started early or what but I rarely see anyone actually examine the Tories record on stuff or future policies. It's all just scandals and campaign feck ups and gaffs.

Just how it feels to me generally.
I'd say that most of the people who are critiquing Labour strongly are left leaning, and would want to vote Labour. They are finding it difficult because one or more Labour policy cross their red lines. They find Tories abhorrent and don't need to repeat how much they despise them.
 
Like I said this is the same attitude that dragged the UK into an illegal war.

Recognising Palestine has been done by many other European countries and they haven't fallen apart.

If you separate morals from politics you end up with guys like Trump and all the other lunatics that have been elected into power recently all over the world.

Just because something is broke doesn't mean you don't try to fix it.

I think too many people are over-estimating the importance of Palestine to the majority of people in the UK.
 
I dunno if it's just this site or what but it feels like labour are being examined far more closely than the Tories and are pretty much being treated like they are already in power.

Dunno if it's because everyone has accepted they will win and have started early or what but I rarely see anyone actually examine the Tories record on stuff or future policies. It's all just scandals and campaign feck ups and gaffs.

Just how it feels to me generally.

It happens to anyone but the tories, both on this site and others. The Lib Dems get sounded out for the coalition all the time despite it being long gone abd different people.

Meanwhile the tories do something worse most weeks, and it gets forgotten by the press. It'd be great if they were all perfect, but there's definitely more analysing of the left / centre.
 
It happens to anyone but the tories, both on this site and others. The Lib Dems get sounded out for the coalition all the time despite it being long gone abd different people.

Meanwhile the tories do something worse most weeks, and it gets forgotten by the press. It'd be great if they were all perfect, but there's definitely more analysing of the left / centre.

There would also be more criticism if Redcafe had more tories. The Trump thread is at it's most active the couple of times per year someone defends him, for the same reason.
 
It happens to anyone but the tories, both on this site and others. The Lib Dems get sounded out for the coalition all the time despite it being long gone abd different people.

Meanwhile the tories do something worse most weeks, and it gets forgotten by the press. It'd be great if they were all perfect, but there's definitely more analysing of the left / centre.
Tbh I think that's down to the acceptance that the Tories are hopelessly woeful, and frankly we're fatigued by the constant onslaught of scandals. So it's natural that we hold the opposition to more scrutiny since the hope and expectation is they would offer us a far more positive outlook, and not trap us into another decade of misery, cronyism and corruption that we've sadly been accustomed to.

As for the press' motivations - well I think that answers itself.
 
Morality and politics huh? That's an interesting path to go down.

What benefit other than morality do we get from recognising a Palestinian state as opposed to our relations with our biggest partner being maintained?
What a disgusting outlook on life.

"Who gives a feck about the 10s of thousands of dead kids, who gives a feck about the 2 million people in an open air death camp, what's in it for me?"
 
Convenient. Talk only to people you agree with and insult those who question you.

Where did I insult you? But for the sake of tge argument. Sure, I will tell you why, 1- it's the right thing morally to do. 2- following the US blindly will end up just like Iraq war and apartheid SA. And most importantly 3- it's the UK mess in the first place it created decades ago.
 
Where did I insult you? But for the sake of tge argument. Sure, I will tell you why, 1- it's the right thing morally to do. 2- following the US blindly will end up just like Iraq war and apartheid SA. And most importantly 3- it's the UK mess in the first place it created decades ago.


You think it's ok to call people you disagree with uneducated?
 
What a disgusting outlook on life.

"Who gives a feck about the 10s of thousands of dead kids, who gives a feck about the 2 million people in an open air death camp, what's in it for me?"


oh look, strawmen that help you avoid the hypocrisy of basing your political decisions on morality alone.
 
You won't like it when they come back with a vengeance, led by Farage or someone like them. It's going to take a while, but it will happen.

Of course I won't. But then I'm used to not liking it so there's no great change. So....for this small brief respite - feck 'em.
 
Of course I won't. But then I'm used to not liking it so there's no great change. So....for this small brief respite - feck 'em.

Yeah it's fun to see them destroyed, but I saw that with repubs when Obama was elected and look how that turned out.

Are you one of those weirdos who's determined to be miserable under Starmer too?
 
Yeah it's fun to see them destroyed, but I saw that with repubs when Obama was elected and look how that turned out.

Are you one of those weirdos who's determined to be miserable under Starmer too?

Not really but I'm not particularly hopeful. You one of those airheads that gets driven to his next opinion on the dashboard of Starmer's Volvo?
 
Are you one of those weirdos who's determined to be miserable under Starmer too?

All we're doing with Starmer is returning back 10 years to when cockwobble Cameron was on the throne. Can't wait...

There's a reason why he's collecting Tory MPs like Pokemon and pushing out anyone remotely left leaning. Tories aren't destroyed, they've just assimilated Labour from the inside.
 
Yeah it's fun to see them destroyed, but I saw that with repubs when Obama was elected and look how that turned out.

This is Starmer's biggest task and the reason why so many people are sceptical. We know that centrist neo-liberalism might work for a bit butv tends to collapse in the face of rising populism (see France, USA, even here etc) My problem with Starmer is that he seems to represent that and that will lead to the rise of the right.

I liked and voted for Corbyn's policies as many did, but he was a weak leader, Starmer seems to be made of sterner stuff, but he is playing to small the c conservative majority. My hope is that he is making the Labour party as small a target as possible to woo those voters and get into power with a large majority and once in, they'll begin to shift towards the left. People need to see government really working for them and that means proper socialist policies, otherwise it'll just be seen as more of the same and we will eventually end up with a Farage or Badendoch as Prime Minister. A Cameron-lite government, which lots of people fear from Starmer, would create even more fertile ground for populism.

I'm lucky enough to live in a constituency where the Greens stand a very real chance of winning and as a result I will be voting for them as I want parliament to be as left of centre as possible. If I was in any doubt about Labour's victory, I would switch my vote to make sure we got rid of the Tories, but thankfully that doesn't seem to be an issue. My hope is that the Lib Dems beat the Tories and become the party of opposition, but that's probably just a dream, unless we have another D-Day moment.
 
You won't like it when they come back with a vengeance, led by Farage or someone like them. It's going to take a while, but it will happen.

Yes definitely.
Politics, especially with 2 main parties is cyclical.
After the sheer struggle of the mountain of problems, ever government gets worn down and the public gets fed up of the failures and broken promises.

At some point this is going to happen to Starmer/ Labour and the Tories will again appeal to the voters.

And I would not write off Boris from making a reappearance. They will have do anything for it not to be Farage. But who knows eh.
 
I think too many people are over-estimating the importance of Palestine to the majority of people in the UK.
Maybe so, but that wasn't what we were debating.

Even though the UK do have a responsibility to help resolving it giving their history in the conflict.
 
You think it's ok to call people you disagree with uneducated?

I did not call you uneducated? I called you uneducated on the subject, "the Palestanian", a conclusion I built upon your prior interactions. I am sorry if I offended. That was not my intention.
 
Maybe so, but that wasn't what we were debating.

Even though the UK do have a responsibility to help resolving it giving their history in the conflict.

You expect too much of the UK - given it’s self-imposed isolation after Brexit, there is no way it will go directly against a key US policy. Neither have most of the other West European nations for that matter (unlike the invasion of Iraq in 2003).

As for Starmer, it’s simple voting tactics - the sad truth is that most British people don’t really care that much about this issue while taking an anti-Israeli position risks re-opening the anti-Semitic narrative of the Corbyn years. Also, there is no obvious strategic rationale for the UK to support Palestine (unlike Ukraine). It’s not morally defensible but since when did morality dictate national policy?

I fully get why some voters will defect to the Greens over this issue. Maybe I would too but my MP was dismissed from the shadow cabinet over this issue and so it seems right to support him.