Israeli - Palestinian Conflict

Because israel hasn't opened the crossings into gaza which it had agreed to do as part of the ceasefire.

Doing so would put many lives at risk so I can't really blame them for not wanting to.

Then they shouldn't have agreed to open it in the first place.

Compromise is a part of any kind of peace process...

what kind of logic is this?

Yes compromises are necessary but you shouldn't agree to something that you never intend to comply with. It's a fundamental breach of the agreement and makes it void.

Have Israel not opened their borders as part of this cease fire?

I actually don't know, and I suspect there are multiple different accounts of everything that happened in the last few weeks.

I was arguing the logic of your point defending Israel in a hypothetical situation where they agreed to something as part of the peace agreement then didn't bother to comply with it because it was something they negotiated away, not the substance of anything that's actually been agreed.

About an hour later, Izzat Al-Rishak, a member of Hamas' political bureau, posted the details of the understandings between Israel and the Palestinian organizations on his Facebook page:

* Israel will cease all its activities against the Gaza Strip in the sea, land and air, including the incursions and assassinations.
* The Palestinian organizations will cease their activity from Gaza against Israel, including the rocket fire and border attacks.
* The border crossings to Gaza will be opened, facilitating the movement of people and transfer of goods. This move will take effect after a 24-hour cooling-off period.
* Additional issues will be negotiated if necessary.

I'm sure that you didn't expect that any agreement included opening the border crossings for all Gazans to enter Israel at 21:00. The agreement possibly includes easing the restrictions on movement of people and goods but as you can see that was supposed to happen 24h after calm is reached.

That won't stop some individuals from justifying unprovoked launching rockets at civilians. Perhaps not surprisingly, these are the same individuals that justify Assad's massacre of 30,000 of his own people.
 
The Lebanese army disabled a rocket on Thursday which was primed to be fired into northern Israel and said two others were launched late on Wednesday but fell short of the border.

An army statement said the incidents all took place near the southern Lebanese town of Marjayoun, about five km (three miles) from Israel's northern border. (Reuters)
 
It seems to be holding, save for a few idiotic rockets fired late last night. There were car horns beeping and people out on the street celebrating in Nablus when the ceasefire was announced last night.

The Lebanon thing is worrying. The last thing anyone needs is Hezbollah kicking off :(

Unlikely to be Hizballah, although they wouldn't shed a tear.
 
Very good piece on Gideon Levy - either the most hated or admired man in Israel (depending on your own perspective):

www.independent.co.uk/news/world/mi...n-israel-or-just-the-most-heroic-2087909.html

Is Gideon Levy the most hated man in Israel or just the most heroic?
For three decades, the writer and journalist Gideon Levy has been a lone voice, telling his readers the truth about what goes on in the Occupied Territories.

Very good piece indeed. The Independent readership can't make its mind so the "newspaper" confirms that Gideon Levy speaks the truth. Meanwhile, facts may suggest otherwise:

Haaretz, Gideon Levy, and the Israel apartheid canard
 
Very good piece on Gideon Levy - either the most hated or admired man in Israel (depending on your own perspective):

www.independent.co.uk/news/world/mi...n-israel-or-just-the-most-heroic-2087909.html

Long, but very good read.

I found this to be quite interesting:

“We had now two wars, the flotilla – it doesn’t seem that Israel has learned any lesson, and it doesn’t seem that Israel is paying any price. The Israelis don’t pay any price for the injustice of the occupation, so the occupation will never end. It will not end a moment before Israelis understand the connection between the occupation and the price they will be forced to pay. They will never shake it off on their own initiative.”

It sounds like he is making the case for boycotting Israel, but his position is more complex. “Firstly, the Israeli opposition to the boycott is incredibly hypocritical. Israel itself is one of the world’s most prolific boycotters. Not only does it boycott, it preaches to others, at times even forces others, to follow in tow. Israel has imposed a cultural, academic, political, economic and military boycott on the territories. The most brutal, naked boycott is, of course, the siege on Gaza and the boycott of Hamas. At Israel's behest, nearly all Western countries signed onto the boycott with inexplicable alacrity. This is not just a siege that has left Gaza in a state of shortage for three years. It's a series of cultural, academic, humanitarian and economic boycotts. Israel is also urging the world to boycott Iran. So Israelis cannot complain if this is used against them.”

He shifts in his seat. “But I do not boycott Israel. I could have done it, I could have left Israel. But I don’t intend to leave Israel. Never. I can’t call on others to do what I will not do... There is also the question of whether it will work. I am not sure Israelis would make the connection. Look at the terror that happened in 2002 and 2003: life in Israel was really horrifying, the exploding buses, the suicide-bombers. But no Israeli made the connection between the occupation and the terror. For them, the terror was just the ‘proof’ that the Palestinians are monsters, that they were born to kill, that they are not human beings and that’s it. And if you just dare to make the connection, people will tell you ‘you justify terror ’ and you are a traitor. I suspect it would be the same with sanctions. The condemnation after Cast Lead and the flotilla only made Israel more nationalistic. If [a boycott was] seen as the judgement of the world they would be effective. But Israelis are more likely to take them as ‘proof’ the world is anti-Semitic and will always hate us.”
 
Is Gideon Levy the most hated man in Israel or just the most heroic?
For three decades, the writer and journalist Gideon Levy has been a lone voice, telling his readers the truth about what goes on in the Occupied Territories.

Very good piece indeed. The Independent readership can't make its mind so the "newspaper" confirms that Gideon Levy speaks the truth. Meanwhile, facts may suggest otherwise:

Haaretz, Gideon Levy, and the Israel apartheid canard

So I take it he fits into your "hated" category then, fair enough.
 
Levy certainly speaks some sort of truth. Whether it's the absolute truth (if one exists) or his truth, that can be argued. One way or another, that truth is not popular and he is a big target of hate.

And just in order to be completely truthful, I'm working in the same newspaper he does (but in the sports section).
 
Following on from RK's post.

An indiscriminate rocket fired at civilians at any time is an illegal act in Islamic jurisprudence.

Thanks, and RK it was on facebook.

On Hamas, they don't care about the plight of the Palestinian people, they don't care about saving lives either, they need to be defeated, by Palestinians, a revolution. Not a foreign invasion, which will leave the people worse off then they are at the moment.

I know it's basically impossible now, and too dangerous.
 
Thanks, and RK it was on facebook.

On Hamas, they don't care about the plight of the Palestinian people, they don't care about saving lives either, they need to be defeated, by Palestinians, a revolution. Not a foreign invasion, which will leave the people worse off then they are at the moment.

I know it's basically impossible now, and too dangerous.

Absolutely agree Jake. Give a Palestian politician who wants peace a chance to meet with a representative of Israel, then they will get somewhere. However, if Hamas continues to have a stranglehold on Gaza, then they are putting innocent Palestian lives at risk, and Hamas, to be honest, don't give a fig about the people they are supposed to represent at Gaza.
 
542608_386140444801280_1721019496_n.jpg
 
In the long term you could say it is costing Israel its legitimacy. Thirty years ago few outside the ME questioned its right to exist as a Jewish state. Now you just need to look at this one thread to see it's an open question, if not currently a very practical one.

In the end, Israel's legitimacy is the name of the game here.

A government that cared about its people's welfare in the here-and-now could get rid of the siege, gradually, by stopping hostilities/importing weapons. Israel doesn't want Gaza, and it doesn't want to lay siege to it, it just wants it to feck off.

But that means surrendering its dream of a nation in all of Palestine. And it was elected on a platform of carrying the fight to Israel (as well as not being corrupt like Fatah).
I think their reasons must be to do with internal politics, including b/w them and other militant groups like IJ. And maybe Iranian demands. It only seems to strengthen Netanyahu's hand so I don't see how it benefits them coming up to an Israeli election, unless they want Netanyahu there.

They know exactly what's going to happen - the Israelis will take out their infrastructure and kill loads of people while hitting as many rockets/tunnels as they can. They also know it will generate a load of outrage across the world, which at least strengthens their hand in the PR battle. But everyone except the yanks already hates Israel, I don't really see what good it does them in the short-term.

They must have their reasons.

I doubt they're stupid so I assume they have their reasons. Partly it may be to keep the struggle alive in the West and the Arab street, since Israel withdrew its army and settlements 7 years ago and a partial siege isn't all that newsworthy.

But it's probably more to do with complex factional reasons, internal and external.

What they are is not stupid but extraordinarily cynical. Their strategy actually involves their own women and children dying.

These are excellent posts.
 
So I take it he fits into your "hated" category then, fair enough.

I am not sure hate is the right word. Gideon levy-style self-hating deserves pity more than anything else. Like Pappe, he has given up on the truth in order to promote his anti-Zionism by vilification of his own nation. There are many other critical voices in Israel, and there is no need to cite the pathologically self-hating individuals to make a point. In doing so, I think people emphasize the extent of their own bias that will prevent reaching common ground with ordinary Israelis.
 
The Palestinian authorites have never missed an opportunity to miss an opportunity. They have failed spectacularly yet continued in their failed strategy year after year.

How can anyone be so stupid? If a tactics thats not working you change tactics not double down and 50 years later have a whole lot less than what you started off with.
 
An ironic twist to our earlier discussion on the immigration laws in the Jewsih state:

Shin Bet arrests Tel Aviv bus bombing suspects

Cleared for publication: A man suspected of carrying out the bombing attack on a bus in central Tel Aviv Wednesday was apprehended by Israeli security forces within hours of the attack.

The suspected terrorist was apprehended in a joint operation conducted by the Shin Bet, Israel Police and the IDF. Twenty-nine people were injured in the attack.

The Shin Bet said Thursday that the terrorist, an Israeli citizen who previously lived in the West Bank and was allowed to settle in Tayibe under the family reunification law, was recruited by a terror cell from the village of Beit Liqya, near Ramallah.

The terror cell members used a car belonging to the suspect's employer to transport the explosive device into Tel Aviv. The employer, an east Jerusalem resident, had no knowledge of the plan.
 
An ironic twist to our earlier discussion on the immigration laws in the Jewsih state:

Shin Bet arrests Tel Aviv bus bombing suspects

Cleared for publication: A man suspected of carrying out the bombing attack on a bus in central Tel Aviv Wednesday was apprehended by Israeli security forces within hours of the attack.

The suspected terrorist was apprehended in a joint operation conducted by the Shin Bet, Israel Police and the IDF. Twenty-nine people were injured in the attack.

The Shin Bet said Thursday that the terrorist, an Israeli citizen who previously lived in the West Bank and was allowed to settle in Tayibe under the family reunification law, was recruited by a terror cell from the village of Beit Liqya, near Ramallah.

The terror cell members used a car belonging to the suspect's employer to transport the explosive device into Tel Aviv. The employer, an east Jerusalem resident, had no knowledge of the plan.

Is that basically saying he is an Israeli Arab?
 
IOF shooting a young Palestinian in Khan Younis today near the border fence today. A 20 year old was killed and many others were injured.

https://www.facebook.com/GazaTVNews/posts/389413734467725

If Palestinians had broken this cease fire there would be retaliation expected and 'justified' within moments from Israel. But if this side were to respond?

Taking the border fence down constitutes a breach of the agreement. The nature of the fragile calm is that the first few days after an agreement of any sort will be used to test how the limits can be stretched. Kindergarden stuff really. That idiot probably got too excited for his own good.
 
That is shocking. HR what are your views on this?

Shocking? The Israeli democracy at its very best. If you are a provocative cnut trying to spark violence while ignoring law-enforcing officers you're likely to get arrested whether Jewish or Muslim.

There was a right-wing Jewish march there, and judging by the counter "Allahu Akbar" chants at the back there was a bunch of Muslim protesters there too. The last thing the Jersualem police needed there was that Yank cnut and his camera man.
 
Is that basically saying he is an Israeli Arab?

This means he is a Paelstinian from the WB who got an Israeli citizenship through marrying/family ties with an Israeli Arab. The racist apartheid state grants citizinship to its enemies.
 
Anyone able to recommend a non-biased documentary on the history of Israel/Palestine/Jews/Arabs and that region?