Didnt know Rashford is the most expensive striker in the league.
Harry Maguire | Signed
- Thread starter davidmichael
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik and Imran are here to talk about a frustrating 2 points dropped at Crystal Palace. They then discuss the regeneration of Old Trafford. Finally, Nik is joined by special guest Michael Statham from the Football Oranje podcast - who gives us a more in depth look at our EL opposition FC Twente, and then runs through the (many) Dutch connections currently at United.
- Status
Anyone who watched VVD consistently would have known how good he was. Most simply didn't because he played for Southampton and Celtic before them. I've seen plenty of Maguire for Leicester and to suggest he's comparable to VVD is ridiculous. I'm trying to stay optimistic and positive on this signing but the number of people overhyping Maguire here who clearly haven't watched him very often is making it difficult. They'll be the first to turn on him if he falls below their expectations
Based on the limited times I have watched him - English Mat Hummels feels like the appropriate comparison.
In order for that to happen we actually have to find people prepared to buy them and match their wages. Which is Easter said then done.
Thier isn’t even vague rumours of any one been interested in any of our centre backs.
My god, he isn’t anywhere near as slow as Hummels, jeez.
He isn’t anywhere near as good on the ball either.
If he ends up playing for us he will inevitably be overrated. Be prepared. And, considering that VVD plays for the great Liverpool, la, means he will be underrated.
Is this a done deal? Who all are reporting this except the Simon fella?
What Stam says about him when he was at Celtic suggests otherwise and makes me not be able to understand why we weren't at least looking him after such praise.
“Virgil made a good impression when he played his football in Holland. But some of the big clubs in my country were really not sure about signing him.
“That has been Celtic’s gain. He has been playing at a high level in the Champions League and Europa League and showing his qualities.
“I have watched some of the games he’s been involved in, and Virgil has been impressive. He is a big guy and is physically strong, reasonably fast and has a good mentality.
“He also uses the ball well, and can make good combinations with his feet. He has the ability to play for a big team in England, for sure."
Happy with this if true. Its telling that there was actually less objection on here last summer when we decided to sign nobody and feck our season than when we sign a decent CB because we may have over paid somewhat. Priorities eh 
Will be happy with this, we need leaders with a good mentality, he is very good with the ball at his feet, brave and determined. The fee is high but the reality is we have a shitload of injury prone and erratic CBs who might as well not be here some of which we can be shifted now and reduce the net spend on this transfer, abu media will still hone in on the cost but whatever, Ole doing some good business to correct deficiencies in the squad.
Stam got it right.
I'm sure many ex players rate Maguire as well. I'm not saying Maguire will be as good as VVD, mind you.
Still no reliable source.
Personally not convinced City were interested and if they were they walked away because the fee didn’t reflect his ability and thy have to pay a premium for home grown talent. I’d be concerned if weakening Leicester was a major factor in signing a player for potentially world record fee.
It’s not reasonable because the money Is spent poorly and excessively, we won’t be winning league for a while, it’s just reality of our current situation.
Fantastic news. He has leadership qualities, he's as safe a buy as it gets and his strengths align perfectly to our weaknesses, Lindelof's weaknesses too.
He is as a standalone talent worth 80m? No
Is he worth that amount considering our desperating and the aforementioned factors? There is absolutely no doubt about it.
I have no words for the people who have watched our defence for the last 7 years and don't want this signing. Out of your minds the lot of you.
He is as a standalone talent worth 80m? No
Is he worth that amount considering our desperating and the aforementioned factors? There is absolutely no doubt about it.
I have no words for the people who have watched our defence for the last 7 years and don't want this signing. Out of your minds the lot of you.
Agreed.
He will definitely do well here but he won't change us as much as Van Dijk transformed Liverpool. We have far too many holes in our setup.
If it is what Ole wants then it is what needed to be done, as there is no point in having a manager if he is not backed.All about patience my man
I'm not convinced with Maguire but if this is what Ole wants as well so be it.
If we pay it, he's worth it.
correct, less money in pockets and more on the pitch.
Paying 60 upfront and 20 add on seems fair in this market, especially with the United tax - especially if it's the player OGS really wants.
For people that are not too thrilled with the cost, think it's only going to sting more when they end up seeing Smalling partner with him regularly. End of the day, he end being the constant next to whichever defender is performing the best. Lindelof had a good period but, when we started to lose our way at the end of last season, he was the weaker link in that pairing.
But, our problem defensively to me was more with right back and Matic. Right back is sorted but, need to sort out defensive mid or at least make sure that our midfielders don't leave us exposed like they tended to do last season - that includes Pogba.
For people that are not too thrilled with the cost, think it's only going to sting more when they end up seeing Smalling partner with him regularly. End of the day, he end being the constant next to whichever defender is performing the best. Lindelof had a good period but, when we started to lose our way at the end of last season, he was the weaker link in that pairing.
But, our problem defensively to me was more with right back and Matic. Right back is sorted but, need to sort out defensive mid or at least make sure that our midfielders don't leave us exposed like they tended to do last season - that includes Pogba.
You know what? That’s a great point.
It looks like we’re paying the extra 15/20 millions just for that alone, we’re severely lacking in leadership.
We’re signing a captain lads!
http://www.redcafe.net/threads/we-need-to-sign-a-captain.447626/
To be fair though, less and less holes. RB week and truly plugged, Maguire coming in would seriously upgrade CB, we’re addressing serious weak areas signing by signing
Good point as I think VVD is arguably the best in the world and even if Maguire comes here and does well I don't think he will ever be anywhere as near as good as VVD.
Fairly happy with all this. I feel Leicester have every right to ask for that much for a player who is coming into his prime. Not really annoyed at the price. Just hope he can come good for our defense.
Who else though? If I gave you £80m who would you sign instead?
The best response i saw anyone make to the "too high a fee" post that has been made 176 times in this thread alone is would you prefer the glazers cream that off instead.
No? Thought not.
No? Thought not.
Maguire is more like Pallister and I liked Pally
I’d say after the move yes, but in the months before the move there was plenty of people saying he’s so average at attacking that they’d rather have Meunier.
Aerial dominance and ball playing yes. Pace no.
But it is £60m and then some performance based add-ons up to £20m. If he performs well, no one will care about the add-ons, if he doesn't, the team won't do as well and the fee will be closer to £60m So whats the issue? Where else should we look? Everyone suggests either young players who have a much higher risk or an OAP from Spurs who will demand a very high wage and we'll have a similar problem like Matic only one or two years down the line.
At this point, anyone mad at this signing is delusional and hopeless. They may need putting down.
We need to realize that any improvements to our positions is a good thing. We will always be taxed higher prices. Deal with it little bitches. We also need to accept our current status and focus on getting to the next step of success and stop having expectations that we will buy nothing but superstars at discounted transfer fees and finish on top. We need to quit measuring our dicks against the Real Madrids and Barcelonas of this world.
We need to realize that any improvements to our positions is a good thing. We will always be taxed higher prices. Deal with it little bitches. We also need to accept our current status and focus on getting to the next step of success and stop having expectations that we will buy nothing but superstars at discounted transfer fees and finish on top. We need to quit measuring our dicks against the Real Madrids and Barcelonas of this world.
I remember reading at the time that Pally was the fastest player in the league which shocked me at the time
The Glazers take their money either way.
Because inexpensive quality defenders who want to be here just grow on trees.
I'm not sure about this one, geebs. Hope it works, though.
Spot on. Its going to be refreshing watching us play with a CB who can bring the ball out of defence.
Not sure about in the league. But seems to have been in our squad. Which when you had some pacey forwards sounds amazing.
Top speed over distance versus acceleration probably.
£80m is a fecking joke. Can't pretend to be happy with this. It's not as if we're getting prime Pique.
- Status