Gareth Bale | Signed new contract

Status
Not open for further replies.
I agree he would be wonderful at United but who would you leave out? We have Giggs/Park on the left and Nani/Valencia on right for this season and the next. And we still have Obertan, Bebe, Cleverly and Welbeck. So where is Bale going to play if he comes here?

Obviously he would be playing on the left wing or like in a Ronaldo role. It's ridiculous to say we got Park because he's not even half the player. Works well in games where you need to sit tight but hardly has the flair and speed of Bale.

And then Obertan, Bebe and Cleverly - they're not even close to holding a spot in the first place. This quantity thinking is absolutely ridiculous. It's the quality that matters and that's why SAF is not running his legs off to get crap transfers like Joey Barton and God knows what names comes up on the caf at times.
 
I agree he would be wonderful at United but who would you leave out? We have Giggs/Park on the left and Nani/Valencia on right for this season and the next. And we still have Obertan, Bebe, Cleverly and Welbeck. So where is Bale going to play if he comes here?

Park - not that good on the LW.
Giggs - not up to playing well enough week in week out. Also, would your ideal situation be to wait until he has left before looking at replacing him?
Obertan - Fergie said he sees him as a forward.
Bebe - Fergie said he sees him as a forward.
Welbeck - is a forward.
Cleverley - an option there, but imo more likely to make it as a more central player, not a 442 winger imo.

As for Valencia/Nani... yeah, arguably two of the best wingers in the league but we lack proper cover for them imo. Adding Bale to the squad would allow us to rotate Nani and Valencia (along with Bale)

I would be delighted if we signed Bale, as I do think we need another quality option for the wing, but I don't think it is absolutely required that we sign a player of his quality, as we already have Valencia and Nani on the wing. A player like Ashley Young would be a decent shout imo, Downing also (actually left footed which would be a bonus).
 
Park - not that good on the LW.
Giggs - not up to playing well enough week in week out. Also, would your ideal situation be to wait until he has left before looking at replacing him?
Obertan - Fergie said he sees him as a forward.
Bebe - Fergie said he sees him as a forward.
Welbeck - is a forward.
Cleverley - an option there, but imo more likely to make it as a more central player, not a 442 winger imo.

As for Valencia/Nani... yeah, arguably two of the best wingers in the league but we lack proper cover for them imo. Adding Bale to the squad would allow us to rotate Nani and Valencia (along with Bale)

I would be delighted if we signed Bale, as I do think we need another quality option for the wing, but I don't think it is absolutely required that we sign a player of his quality, as we already have Valencia and Nani on the wing. A player like Ashley Young would be a decent shout imo, Downing also (actually left footed which would be a bonus).


Doing well until you mentioned him. He's useless
 
Where does the idea of Park not playing well on Left has came from, people have short memories, he became one of our most important players before leaving for the Asia Cup, ofcourse I would like to sign a young left winger, but if we don't sign anyone and than I'm happy with the wingset of Park, Valencia, Obertan, Nani and Cleverly for next season.
 
Where does the idea of Park not playing well on Left has came from, people have short memories, he became one of our most important players before leaving for the Asia Cup, ofcourse I would like to sign a young left winger, but if we don't sign anyone and than I'm happy with the wingset of Park, Valencia, Obertan, Nani and Cleverly for next season.

well for me, I simply don't rate Park all that much (harshly maybe). I like his workrate and running, but I think his final ball is very poor. He gets into great positions in the final third but screws it up or slows things down too much. I would also say he is better through the centre and on the right than he is on the left. I would say the left is his weakest position.
 
[/B]

Doing well until you mentioned him. He's useless

I said the same before the start of last season (yes, I know he was injured at the start of last season) but I think he has improved since making his Villa debut. I thought he was an average signing for Villa, but i think the improvement in his game has been huge and has justified the money they spent on him.

Again, not saying he is better than Nani or Valencia, but I do think he would be a good addition to the squad.
 
well for me, I simply don't rate Park all that much (harshly maybe). I like his workrate and running, but I think his final ball is very poor. He gets into great positions in the final third but screws it up or slows things down too much. I would also say he is better through the centre and on the right than he is on the left. I would say the left is his weakest position.

I think his best performances came on the left side, and yes your rating for Park is indeed harsh. It's a bloody shame that he had to go to Asia Cup because he was having his best season(in terms of end product) atleast.
 
I think his best performances came on the left side, and yes your rating for Park is indeed harsh. It's a bloody shame that he had to go to Asia Cup because he was having his best season(in terms of end product) atleast.

i remember him going through a similar patch in the 08/09 season - he became a real vital player for us. Slipped back in a good squad player though last season, imo.

I do think he is an important member of the squad - one of the best squad players around, I just don't think he is good enough as a first choice player consistently. Too much of a headless chicken most of the time, loads of running but a lot of the time it is just running.

For me, his passing is average, his crossing is average at best, his control is ok, finishing ok. No part of his game, imo, apart from his workrate is outstanding. He is a solid player that we could improve upon. There are, however, a load of players I would look to move out of the club before I looked at selling him.
 
Fair enough, but with Valencia and Nani around, I don't think we need that many established wingers as they're already first choice when fit(special talents like Sanchez, Hazard and Bale are exceptions), which makes Park very important as he is happy to sit on the bench and we'll always get a 6.5 performance out of him whenever we need him and he is a big match player.

Don't think we really need Bale to be honest, atleast not on the price mentioned, Center of the midfield has to be a more pressing concern for us IMO.
 
Fair enough, but with Valencia and Nani around, I don't think we need that many established wingers as they're already first choice when fit(special talents like Sanchez, Hazard and Bale are exceptions), which makes Park very important as he is happy to sit on the bench and we'll always get a 6.5 performance out of him whenever we need him and he is a big match player.

Don't think we really need Bale to be honest, atleast not on the price mentioned, Center of the midfield has to be a more pressing concern for us IMO.

I would agree with you on that - I would say I priorities this summer should be 1. GK. 2. CM and then look at the LW. As such, 40million on Bale would be foolish, as we have more pressing concerns than a left winger. However, I was just commenting on where we could fit Bale in (imo, at the expence of most our winger options). When looking at a LW, a squad option is all we really need, and as such I think Young or Downing would be decent shouts.
 
we have more chance of buying modric IMO. he'd be cheaper.

Not that much cheaper I fear. Would be a better buy for United too. A creative central midfielder. not as combative/defensive as we would normally have in central midfield, but certainly puts his shift in and has shown he can play cetrally in a 442. Don't know that we have a CM player that could effectively partner him though - think he needs a more sitting/combative player beside him like Palacios, and apart from Carrick we don't have that really.
 
I get why some are keen for Bale to come here, but would you really want us to pay £40M for him rather than £20-25M for Sanchez or Hazard?
 
I get why some are keen for Bale to come here, but would you really want us to pay £40M for him rather than £20-25M for Sanchez or Hazard?

Would certainly prefer Bale over Sanchez. Bale is a player that could (and does) play LW in a 442. Sanchez could not and does not.

Can't comment as much on Hazzard, but my impression is that he is more of a central player with a left foot rather than a winger.

If we sign a winger, it should be one that will be comfortable playing a 442; as that is what we will most likely play.

As a further point on Sanchez, from what I can see he would basically play the same position/role as Welbeck, so I don't see room for the both of them in the squad. Signing Sanchez would mean selling Welbeck imo. Now, that might be exactly the right thing to do, but I would like to see Welbeck given a chance. I will be very interested to see how he does when he comes back from injury, was his pre-injury form a flash in the pan, or a true showing of the player he is becoming - big test for him.
 
Hazard's right-footed but completely at home on the left.
 
Would certainly prefer Bale over Sanchez. Bale is a player that could (and does) play LW in a 442. Sanchez could not and does not.

I don't think it would be a stretch for Sanchez to play on the left in a 4-4-2, and he is more versatile all round than Bale IMO.

Can't comment as much on Hazzard, but my impression is that he is more of a central player with a left foot rather than a winger.

If we sign a winger, it should be one that will be comfortable playing a 442; as that is what we will most likely play.

Just to clarify you feel the left winger needs to be a left footed out and out winger? As when Hazard plays from the left he is more of a floating playmaker than a traditional winger.

As a further point on Sanchez, from what I can see he would basically play the same position/role as Welbeck, so I don't see room for the both of them in the squad. Signing Sanchez would mean selling Welbeck imo. Now, that might be exactly the right thing to do, but I would like to see Welbeck given a chance. I will be very interested to see how he does when he comes back from injury, was his pre-injury form a flash in the pan, or a true showing of the player he is becoming - big test for him.

Welbeck's main role is as a striker, Sanchez plays on the wing or as an advanced AM or #10 if you like. I don't think one would effect the other.

Proven at Champions league and PL levels. So yes.

Much more reliable punt. (I'd still love Sanchez aswell!)

Bale being proven in the PL is certainly his strongest asset over the other two.

Hazard's right-footed but completely at home on the left.

Has Hazard been playing from the left this season for Lille?
 
I get why some are keen for Bale to come here, but would you really want us to pay £40M for him rather than £20-25M for Sanchez or Hazard?

I agree with the sentiment but their clubs will be looking for 30+ easy so it isn't a question of them being 20 million apart.
 
Has Hazard been playing from the left this season for Lille?

I'm pretty sure that's what he's done every season. It's certainly been where he's played this season. He isn't a winger and making him so would limit his game but I don't think that his tendency to drift centrally is a problem with Evra or Fabio behind him, and we've shown we can be successful with Giggs doing so.

Wouldn't expect us to get him though.
 
I'm pretty sure that's what he's done every season. It's certainly been where he's played this season. He isn't a winger and making him so would limit his game but I don't think that his tendency to drift centrally is a problem with Evra or Fabio behind him, and we've shown we can be successful with Giggs doing so.

Wouldn't expect us to get him though.

I thought so, I haven't seen him as much as I'd have liked so I wasn't sure if he'd also played as more of a #10, but when I saw him he was playing as a floating playmaker from the left, much like Modric did at Spurs at first, or as you say like Giggs has done for us.

Maybe not but he fits in with the United ethos I'd say.
 
Bale would certainly be a strong signing. The prospect of playing Rooney flanked by Nani and Bale in a 433 is mouth-watering.
 
I think we'll sign Sanchez and Arsenal will sign Hazard, for anyone who has seen them regularly who's the better prospect?
 
I think we'll sign Sanchez and Arsenal will sign Hazard, for anyone who has seen them regularly who's the better prospect?

I would pick Hazard because he is younger and he can play centrally better than Sanchez can.
 
I would love Bale and he definitely seems like a united sort of player, but our priorities should be GK and CM for starters, if we sort those two positions out and still have £40-50m left to spend on Bale then awesome.
 
But he is. Serie A, just like Zizou and Ronaldinho were.

Though yes we don't really need a Bale. Sneijder/Schweinsteiger for central midfield please :drool:
Sneijder doesn't play central midfield. He has two central midfielders covering his backside everytime.
 
Gareth Bale insists he would have no qualms about moving abroad to play.

Tottenham's Welsh star was talking to the Spanish media ahead of Spurs' Champions League first leg with Real Madrid on Tuesday.

Ever since Bale's stunning hat-trick against Inter Milan earlier in the season, he has been the talk of Europe, which inevitably has led to him being strongly linked with Real Madrid and Barcelona.

Bale has just signed a new long-term contract at White Hart Lane, but he admits the thought of moving to the continent does not frighten him.

"You never know [what will happen] but I have no fear about leaving the country," he told AS.

"If there is a great opportunity then that has to be considered seriously.

"I left home when I was 15, if I leave the Premier League, learn another language and see another country then I will grow as a person."


Bale admits that ever since his treble in the San Siro he has been talked about but he insists he does not think about what is reported.

"I try not to think about it, my team-mates joke a lot about it," he said.

"I am playing the best football of my career with Tottenham, and it just seems like they are talking about someone else when people are talking about how much I would cost and who would sign me."

Football365


This summer will be a nightmare.
 
According to 'Arry, Bale is worth as much as Ronaldo :lol:

Gareth Bale announced his arrival on the world stage with his performances against Internazionale this season. Photograph: Tom Hevezi/AP
Harry Redknapp has suggested it would take a world-record transfer fee to prise Gareth Bale from Tottenham Hotspur in the summer after the Wales winger said that he was open to the prospect of a switch to a leading continental club.

Bale has been declared fit to face Real Madrid here in the Champions League quarter-final first-leg after hamstring trouble, and the Spanish team are one of those who covet him. Internazionale, the Italian champions, are chief among the others, although Bale would lean towards Spain for his big move.

Redknapp, however, has made it clear he would fight hard to keep his prized asset because cashing in would send the "wrong signals" and trigger the disintegration of what he has built at White Hart Lane.

"Manchester United sold Cristiano Ronaldo [to Real] but they got an offer of £80m," Redknapp said, highlighting the record fee. "He's Portuguese and this is more his lifestyle here than Manchester may have been. So in the end, it was good business. I'm sure it would have to be that kind of money for Bale. :wenger:
It would be an amazing figure if you ever sold him. But how do you replace a player like that? It's very difficult. We wouldn't be wanting to sell a player like Gareth Bale at this time, when we're trying to build the club."

Bale, who has catapulted himself to global prominence with his performances in this season's Champions League, agreed fresh terms on his White Hart Lane contract last month. His deal now runs until 2015. But his comments to the Spanish newspaper AS on the eve of his team's tie against Real were not what Tottenham's fans might have wanted to hear.

"You never know," Bale said, on the possibility of a move abroad, "but I'm not afraid to leave the country. If a great opportunity arises, you need to seriously consider it. I left home at 15. If I leave the Premier League, I'll learn another language, I'll know other people, another country. I will grow as a person. There aren't more British players abroad because the league is very strong but now yours [La Liga] has got Cristiano [Ronaldo], [Lionel] Messi…"

Redknapp said that the Tottenham chairman, Daniel Levy, would deal with the inquiries for Bale and it feels as though the 21-year-old's remark about needing to consider a great opportunity if it arose has added a new dynamic.

"Sure, players have the power," Redknapp said, "and the day that Gareth comes in and says that he wants to go, or the agent says that he wants to move on, there is very little you can do about it. But I don't see that happening. Maybe he just didn't want to sound unambitious. If people ask him whether he wants to play for one of the top European clubs one day, I am sure that he would. But I don't think he is ready to do that. He arrived at the airport today in Madrid and the press are swarming all over him. But he is still learning the game."

Redknapp has personal experience of the disarray that can result from when a club decides to sell their star players. "I had it at West Ham," he said. "We let Rio [Ferdinand] go and then Frank [Lampard] and the rest followed. If you are looking to build a club, you can't be selling Gareth as then [Luka] Modric wants to go and someone else wants to go. Then, you end up where the club was four to five years ago, finishing halfway up the table.

"I have not seen Gareth's quotes and I have not spoken to him about them. Agents will always turn players' heads. If someone is going to come along and offer millions of pounds to move him and he is going to get fantastic wages, it is difficult not to get their heads turned. But it is part of football."

José Mourinho, Real's manager, said that he had long known that Bale would become an "amazing player". But he added: "Tottenham buy well but they like to sell very, very well. So I think the amount of money involved [with Bale] is not easy to buy. We have players for that position. We have Cristiano [Ronaldo], Marcelo."

Tottenham have been boosted by the return to fitness of the central defender William Gallas, who is set to start, but a clutch of other injuries have left Redknapp to suggest that he will name only six substitutes. For Real, Ronaldo, Angel Di María and Marcelo have been declared fit while Kaká is set for a surprise return to the substitutes' bench.

"We are the big underdogs," Redknapp said. "I've said all along that the two Spanish teams are the favourites. But we are not just coming here to turn up. The dream is still there for us all and we want to make that dream come true. We want to go all the way."
 
According to 'Arry, Bale is worth as much as Ronaldo :lol:

He's worth what they'd agree to sell him for.

It would take a massive bid for Spurs to even consider it,

I agree he's not even near the player Ronnie was when he went for that fee, but if anyone wants him it would have to be a ridiculous offer.
 
He'll be found out soon enough, the speed merchant. He's not anywhere near good enough technically to be considered among the best.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.