Frenkie de Jong | The last muppeting lap

Frenkie to United?

  • Total voters
    2,033
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Nicoseth said:
To pick and choose which ones you believe and don't believe to suit your own whim is laughably naive.
Click to expand...

Seems to be the case here. Was it not that Gerard Romero bloke who said that Ten Hag and FDJ were in talks constantly, which is accepted as gospel here, but his other reports that Frenkie wants to stay at Barca are seen as 'Barca propaganda'

It might just be that he may not want to join us.
 
There is something about him which I am starting to dislike (based on nothing really), but he really seems like that very arrogant guy at school. Someone who has spent his entire life having smoke blown up his backside and believing his own hype. He is a good player, don't get me wrong but he's not some sort of transcendent player who will transform our team. He is very much a piece of the puzzle not the puzzle. We are not trying to sign Cantona.

Now I get that he will help the manager as he has played with him before and will work for the system he wishes to use. But if he doesn't come, he doesn't come. It's no big deal tbh. I also have concerns about him physically, looks really limited and lacking in physical prowess which, in La Liga, to look weak in La Liga is a bit off.
 
Nicoseth said:
Give it time. That's the trajectory this saga is on now. Choose to live in denial if you wish.
Click to expand...
I'll believe what I want to believe and you can believe what you want.

All tier 1 sources for United have said nothing. Tier 1 for Barca have said exactly what Barca want them to say.

People are melting down over one report and taking it as gospel truth. Yes the Athletic might be reliable, but they're not always going to get everything spot on are they? But because I decide to question the report I'm in denial?
 
KirkDuyt said:
The chairman of the Dutch players union has said FifPro should get involved because Barca is blackmailing him. The funny part is that this dude is basing this of the same sources as this thread.
Click to expand...
Are you sure?

And if he decides to stay without agreeing new terms, the abuse and alienation he’ll get will surely be moving toward unprecedented levels. You have to wonder how that would unfold.
 
Womp said:
Seems to be the case here. Was it not that Gerard Romero bloke who said that Ten Hag and FDJ were in talks constantly, which is accepted as gospel here, but his other reports that Frenkie wants to stay at Barca are seen as 'Barca propaganda'

It might just be that he may not want to join us.
Click to expand...

Everyone and their dog knows he wants to stay at Barca? How is that still used as a reason that this won’t happen. Rightfully or wrongly, him wanting to stay means feck all in this saga really.
 
At the end of the day if he doesn't want to come I'm fine with that. Don't want a player who cries about Barcelona all day.

I'm also fine with buying no alternatives. No one in the market seems like a significant upgrade. I'd rather we be responsible with our money and go for the right player instead of being saddled with a liability whom we struggle to sell 3 years down the line.
 
The amount of denial in relation to this deal is impressive. Player never wanted to join as has been repeatedly stated from the beginning but people simply regurgitate the same "why would we still be trying to sign him if he wasn't interested in joining" comment ad nauseum :lol:
 
Murder on Zidane's Floor said:
There is something about him which I am starting to dislike (based on nothing really), but he really seems like that very arrogant guy at school. Someone who has spent his entire life having smoke blown up his backside and believing his own hype. He is a good player, don't get me wrong but he's not some sort of transcendent player who will transform our team. He is very much a piece of the puzzle not the puzzle. We are not trying to sign Cantona.

Now I get that he will help the manager as he has played with him before and will work for the system he wishes to use. But if he doesn't come, he doesn't come. It's no big deal tbh. I also have concerns about him physically, looks really limited and lacking in physical prowess which, in La Liga, to look weak in La Liga is a bit off.
Click to expand...
At his full potential, he actually is. Whether that’s realised remains to be seen.
 
groovyalbert said:
I mean, they're not that unlikely scenarios are they?

Barcelona is a step down from Utd, that's the reality of it. Plus it's his dream club.

Why on earth would De Jong - or anyone -choose Europa over CL?

If recent comments are to be believed, he enjoys working with Xavi and maybe his relationship with both him and ETH has a similar pull.

I get that his is all speculative - but isn't everything that anyone's posting either here or largely elsewhere?
Click to expand...
Well he has had five / six seasons of it so it's not like he hasn't played it.
 
Dazzmondo said:
The amount of denial in relation to this deal is impressive. Player never wanted to join as has been repeatedly stated from the beginning but people simply regurgitate the same "why would we still be trying to sign him if he wasn't interested in joining" comment ad nauseum :lol:
Click to expand...

When has the player said he doesn't want to join? Should be easy for you to find seeing as though he's been stating it repeatedly
 
Judas said:
Everyone and their dog knows he wants to stay at Barca? How is that still used as a reason that this won’t happen. Rightfully or wrongly, him wanting to stay means feck all in this saga really.
Click to expand...

It means everything. You can't force the bloke to feck off. He can stay on his current wage, he can take a pay cut, he can sign elsewhere. This idea that he has no option but to leave Barca and come here is clutching.
 
Murder on Zidane's Floor said:
There is something about him which I am starting to dislike (based on nothing really), but he really seems like that very arrogant guy at school. Someone who has spent his entire life having smoke blown up his backside and believing his own hype. He is a good player, don't get me wrong but he's not some sort of transcendent player who will transform our team. He is very much a piece of the puzzle not the puzzle. We are not trying to sign Cantona.

Now I get that he will help the manager as he has played with him before and will work for the system he wishes to use. But if he doesn't come, he doesn't come. It's no big deal tbh. I also have concerns about him physically, looks really limited and lacking in physical prowess which, in La Liga, to look weak in La Liga is a bit off.
Click to expand...
That's the first time I've heard him called arrogant.

As for overrated, well he seems to be like the prime Matic people always long for, the way he brings a calmness to the pitch when in possession and setting the tempo for the match.
 
mu4c_20le said:
That's the first time I've heard him called arrogant.

As for overrated, well he seems to be like the prime Matic people always long for, the way he brings a calmness to the pitch when in possession and setting the tempo for the match.
Click to expand...
I dunno, just have that sense tbh. I did say it was based on nothing but just a sense.
 
Do people honestly expect the player or his agent to come out and say “I can’t wait to get away from this mess! They’ve really fecked me over” or something similar?

if he opens his mouth it’ll contractually be perceived as him wanting to leave and he will forgo his bonuses etc
 
It's obvious we are not his first choice. It's been Barca all along, and if not he would rather wait for one of the bigger clubs like City, Bayern, PSG etc to come for him.

He is no hurry, he will play the World Cup anyway no matter which position Barca plays him in.
 
Murder on Zidane's Floor said:
There is something about him which I am starting to dislike (based on nothing really), but he really seems like that very arrogant guy at school. Someone who has spent his entire life having smoke blown up his backside and believing his own hype. He is a good player, don't get me wrong but he's not some sort of transcendent player who will transform our team. He is very much a piece of the puzzle not the puzzle. We are not trying to sign Cantona.

Now I get that he will help the manager as he has played with him before and will work for the system he wishes to use. But if he doesn't come, he doesn't come. It's no big deal tbh. I also have concerns about him physically, looks really limited and lacking in physical prowess which, in La Liga, to look weak in La Liga is a bit off.
Click to expand...

What has Frenkie said? The article everyone is losing their mind over does not even attribute anything to him.
 
matsdf said:
They did give up Messi to be fair.
Click to expand...
NLunited said:
Except Messi
Click to expand...

Well that was probably more of an economic decision as they could not afford paying him €100m a year anymore. But from registering point of view they were able to register all players they brought last year despite everyone getting excited they wouldn't initially.
 
Murder on Zidane's Floor said:
Well he has had five / six seasons of it so it's not like he hasn't played it.
Click to expand...
To be fair it's a convenient excuse to use when a player is looking at a move from a CL to a EL club.

CL is the elite competition, where the best want to be. The thought that any player may want to move to a club that is in the EL is just unthinkable to most reporters. When a move isn't progressing its usually the CL reason that's used from what I've noticed.

He could go to Chelsea, play CL this season then get EL next year if Chelsea finish 5th. Is he going to hand in a transfer request if that happens?
 
sewey89 said:
When has the player said he doesn't want to join? Should be easy for you to find seeing as though he's been stating it repeatedly
Click to expand...


Literally 30 mins ago :lol: Also pretty much every report for the last month and a half has emphasised that he doesn't want to leave Barcelona, but don't let that bother you. Continue to dream by all means
 
Murder on Zidane's Floor said:
Well he has had five / six seasons of it so it's not like he hasn't played it.
Click to expand...

He's played in it, for sure, but going through the seasons he's had at a top level, he's never had a season starting in the Europa. Ajax failed to qualify a couple of times, but he's never had guaranteed Europa in July before.
 
Paxi said:


He doesn’t want to come.
Click to expand...


Funnily enough this was always the line from Spain wasn't it?

The line from England, via the Manchester press pack, has always been that United were confident it will happen, its all about monies owed blah, blah, blah. However, the press in Spain has been categorical that De Jong doesn't want to join Man Utd pretty much from the get go.

I don't blame United for trying to get De Jong. I imagine Ten Hag has told the club that De Jong could be crucial to making his system a success. Lord knows De Jong's a much better connecting midfielder than anyone currently at the club.

All things considered De Jong probably doesn't want to leave. A lot of players have been forced out of clubs before. Wesley Sneijder didn't want to leave Madrid, got forced out won a treble with Inter a year later. I can appreciate why United would be patient if the club feels, ultimately, we'll be the only out for De Jong in the end. Whether his heart is in it or not we need his skillset. So I get it...

...I just hope that we also have an appropriate plan B.

This is where I think he who shall not be named (or lese you risk derailing the whole thread) had a point.

When scouting players we need to identify people for whom Man Utd is the next logical step in their careers. Malacia, Martinez, Eriksen, in each case United was the obvious choice and an obvious bigger stage than the one they played on last season. Its similar to the way Sir Alex did it when building his last great side: Van der Saar from Fulham, Vidic from Red Star, Evra from Monaco, Carrick from Spurs, Ronaldo from Sporting, Rooney from Everton, Saha from Fulham. All of those players saw it as a step up for them, even though they were joining the club at the time when Mourinho's Chelsea was at its strongest, cos of the clubs they joined from.

Contrast this with trying to get players out of Barcelona...even if we think United are bigger there's always going to be a lot of players who don't. Especially when we haven't won a league for 10 years.

I'm hoping, at the end of the day, Barca tries to shove De Jong out of the door and we're there to scoop him up. However, I really do hope we've got a plan B in mind.
 
Murder on Zidane's Floor said:
He really really isn't. He's a system player. As soon as the system doesn't work in his favour his level drops massively.
Click to expand...
That’s not a statement with any value. System players are also all-time greats. And systems are catered to [some] players to enable them to thrive - there is no set rule a player has to be universally eclectic to make a huge mark on the game and in history.
 
golden_blunder said:
Do people honestly expect the player or his agent to come out and say “I can’t wait to get away from this mess! They’ve really fecked me over” or something similar?

if he opens his mouth it’ll contractually be perceived as him wanting to leave and he will forgo his bonuses etc
Click to expand...
@golden_blunder After todays developments, is it possible we can call you a piece of sh1t in an endearing loving manner without getting banned? :D

Golden Bunda Turd :D
 
Judas said:
Everyone and their dog knows he wants to stay at Barca? How is that still used as a reason that this won’t happen. Rightfully or wrongly, him wanting to stay means feck all in this saga really.
Click to expand...
How does it mean feck all? He's a Barca player under contract. If he doesn't want to leave he doesn't have to. And if he does leave he doesn't have to join us.
 
avgp_1 said:
It's obvious we are not his first choice. It's been Barca all along, and if not he would rather wait for one of the bigger clubs like City, Bayern, PSG etc to come for him.

He is no hurry, he will play the World Cup anyway no matter which position Barca plays him in.
Click to expand...
Yeah, looking like the di Maria saga again, let's hope it has the same ending at least. The manager was our only trump card, and that article just pissed all over it.
 
:lol: I can't believe posters actually believe United would ever confirm that De Jong doesn't want to sign.

There's unreal delusion on show in this thread. The writing has been on the wall for a long time.

Now it's time to start asking what the plan actually is because the weakest and possibly most important part of the team is going to be neglected once again. I wouldn't have minded if we have some of our youngsters a shot but it looks like they're all being loaned out.
 
Gandalf said:
Fair points but are Barca really that much better than United? Of the 2 clubs only one was knocked out in the group stages of last seasons CL and it wasn't United.

I agree Barca offer more of a guarantee of CL football but that is as much a function of the weakness of the opposition in La Liga, they would really have to screw up not to get top 4 as the drop off from themselves and Real Madrid to the rest of the league is enormous. Would actually be quite funny to see the Saudis rock up and buy a couple of La Liga sides so they can experience the joys of oil clubs as we have over the last 15 years.

He may like Xavi but even last season he was complaining that he was not being played in his preferred role and this was impacting his performances and now Xavi is telling him not only will he not be the deepest midfielder but he won't be in midfield at all as he is know a back up CB. I doubt he is enjoying that very much.

Two things we know for certain

1. Barca have no intention of keeping him on his current salary
2. Frenkie has no intention of taking a pay cut

It all points to a divorce however slow and messy and the whole issue of does he then come to United ultimately comes down to the fact that nobody else is actually interested in buying him right now no matter how hard Barca fluffer accounts try to wish Chelsea interest into existence.
Click to expand...
Dembele, Raphina, Lewandowski, Frenkie, Pedri, Busquets, Kessie, Araujo will definitely start for us. How many of our players start for them? Sancho?
 
Dazzmondo said:


Literally 30 mins ago :lol: Also pretty much every report for the last month and a half has emphasised that he doesn't want to leave Barcelona, but don't let that bother you. Continue to dream by all means
Click to expand...

And that's from the player himself is it? Has he explicitly told that reporter he doesn't want to come?

He hunted that particular guy out and said hey, I just needed to find you to tell you that I don't want to go to United and play EL. If this was genuine news, it would be picked up by everyone now as its pretty big news to be fair.
 
Dazzmondo said:


Literally 30 mins ago :lol: Also pretty much every report for the last month and a half has emphasised that he doesn't want to leave Barcelona, but don't let that bother you. Continue to dream by all means
Click to expand...

I suppose the option would be to just ignore the thread.

If I believed there was zero hope this will ever happen I just wouldnt bother reading about it
 
Status
Not open for further replies.