Rossa
Full Member
Way to go off topic. You instantly claimed I am stereotyping because of body features. Please do not speak/assume things on behalf of me.
For me Lukaku is one of the smartest players we have in our squad. His athleticism is not correlated with his intelligence.
For me, Bailly (currently) lacks the intelligence to be a world class CB even though he has the physical attributes whereas Lindeloff is physically weak whilst his intelligence in positioning/passing is better.
Way to take things too personal?
How do you know that Bailly lacks intelligence or just that his game in the past was like Giggs', that he has always been able to get back, outmuscle and out jump pretty much anyone, until he came to the PL. I don't agree that Lindelöf's intelligence is much better from what I've seen. Against Watford he started to dilly dallying when he should have just made a simple clearance - lack of good judgement. His runs forward are not very intelligent. He starts a run forward, stops and takes too long before he makes a pass - much like Smalling in that respect (though obviously better with the ball overall).
I do think you are stereotyping because one is physical and does not succeed - must be intelligence. The other does not succeed because of his lack of physical abilities despite his intelligence. Fact is, you probably know as little as me about their intelligence, which is next to nothing, so you are basing it on stereotypes. In fact, both players can be equally intelligent, but both may also struggle to adapt to the league.