Danny Welbeck | Arsenal player

Status
Not open for further replies.
Almost player playing for an almost team.

Would've been a very good squad option for us, to bad it turned out like this, but he's not top notch and he won't be.
 
Sanchez and Ozil failed to create any chance, not a lot he could do to be honest.
 
Doesn't work that way. A player is judged on all performances, you can't pick and choose which games he's judged on.

No, Welbeck can only be judged on the games when he plays well. It was the same when he was here. He gets special dispensation, you see.
 
The lad spends far far too much time receiving the ball in midfield when he should be further up, close to the penalty box.
 
Doesn't work that way. A player is judged on all performances, you can't pick and choose which games he's judged on.
Depends what you expect from your front men. For example if Falcao/RvP/Rooney had a game like he did today you would be gutted. With Welbeck because hes not at their level (and i dont think he ever will) this kind of performance is expected against top opposition.
 
I liked the kid, thought he had good spirit. Unfortunately, in my opinion, he has feet of stone and no real creative skill on the ball. Was not improving either, it seems to me he had reached his limits professionally. Hope he does well and wish him nothing but luck.
 
Depends what you expect from your front men. For example if Falcao/RvP/Rooney had a game like he did today you would be gutted. With Welbeck because hes not at their level (and i dont think he ever will) this kind of performance is expected.

HA! After all that's been written about him, I was expecting him to fart the ball into the back of the net
 
Depends what you expect from your front men. For example if Falcao/RvP/Rooney had a game like he did today you would be gutted. With Welbeck because hes not at their level (and i dont think he ever will) this kind of performance is expected.

I have seen RVP and Rooney have performances like that for United, it happens
 
I have seen RVP and Rooney have performances like that for United, it happens
Thats not my point.

My point is you dont judge performances Welbeck has against top opposition because hes not a top striker that you expect will get a goal against top defenses. Unlike Rooney/RvP who have proven they can score against anyone.
 
The Welbeck boom and bust cycle begins afresh. Nutmegs himself against Spurs and he's rubbish, then scores a hat trick and he's a god, awol against Chelsea and we're back to square one.

The truth is Welbeck is a good young player in development and will have good days and bad days. However, that doesn't suit the media who want to use him as a weapon against Van Gaal. Press hyperbole trickles down to the fans and you end up with those who want to make out selling him was the worst decision ever, and those who feel the best way to defend Van Gaal is to trash Welbeck.
 
Thats not my point.

My point is you dont judge performances Welbeck has against top opposition because hes not a top striker that you expect will get a goal against top defenses. Unlike Rooney/RvP who have proven they can score against anyone.
Rooney/RVP have had more than 100 games playing as a striker to prove they can score against anyone. Welbeck has had, what? 10? 15?
 
Anonymous today really.

Should never be judged on Chelsea away though

Would be a better argument if he hadn't spent the entire preceeeding season being judged solely on Real Madrid away.

Though I largely agree, he shouldn't be judged on either.
 
I mean if you want to say he wasn't good enough for United and use Chelsea away as an example fair play to you.

If you want to use a hat-trick against a piss poor Galatasary side at the Emirates to prove LvG made a stupid decision and he is Henry mark 2, then fair play to you.
 
Rooney/RVP have had more than 100 games playing as a striker to prove they can score against anyone. Welbeck has had, what? 10? 15?
How does that matter. Both Rooney or RvP in the early stages of their career had already shown they can score against anyone, something Welbeck didnt achieve enough

Que "he was playing on the wing"
 
Nothin special today. Was average on the ball, didn't convert his chances and looked lost in a game Chelsea dominated.
He's a good striker, but Arsenal bought another Giroud level striker when they should have bought a top class one.
Same old Wenger.
 
I'd almost guarantee that he'll net a brace in couple games' time and he'll be getting Thierry Henry comparisons again. If anything, the polarizing opinions about Welbeck seems to have gotten even worse with his move to Arsenal.
 
I'm a big fan of his, but today was the perfect demonstration of his struggles against a solid, defensively compact side where he struggles to get into goal-scoring positions and his movement is very lacking. Afford him space in behind and he can excel, but I just think there will plenty more anonymous performances from Welbeck against this type of opposition, although there are admittedly none better than Chelsea at executing this style.
 
Nothin special today. Was average on the ball, didn't convert his chances and looked lost in a game Chelsea dominated.
He's a good striker, but Arsenal bought another Giroud level striker when they should have bought a top class one.
Same old Wenger.
Which top class striker should Wenger have bought this summer.
 
Thats not my point.

My point is you dont judge performances Welbeck has against top opposition because hes not a top striker that you expect will get a goal against top defenses. Unlike Rooney/RvP who have proven they can score against anyone.

The criticism of Welbeck is a bit over the top. He used the ball well when he received it but but he never got the ball in areas where he could have caused Chelsea's defence problems.

The fact is Mourinho out-manuevered Wenger yet again! Arsenal could barely get their passing game going much less create goalscoring chances for Welbeck!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.