Longer I play, the more I like the game, PS4/Xbox One fiasco aside, this is a really great game, I don't understand people saying next two things:
1: "City feels dead" - I disagree, City feels very much alive and is best looking video game City I played in probably, insane attention to detail! Also big vehicle variety.
2: "There is nothing to do outside Map markers, no incentive to explore" - This one I don't get, I found tons of stuff outside marks, found some texts that opened side quests, easter eggs, rich item caches, unique Bikes/rides etc.
I know people are angry and disappointed, but let's not go overboard criticizing things that are not there just because of that.
And people should stop comparing RDR2, which is basically a flat wasteland, with this game, which has insane verticality compared, this game is much more demanding because of that.