I can totally see the logic in your post. What I can also tell you is that I always found Ronaldo rather unlikable. Even when he was here in his pomp, I respected what he could do as a player but I despised his histrionics and self centered attitude on the pitch. When he fecked us off for Madrid, again although I still respected his value as a player, I despised him further.
When you watch him over the years and you see his petty attitude, like barely celebrating his team mates score crucial goals in a CL final, only to then run off in wild celebration like he’d saved the day, after banging in a meaningless 4th goal from the penalty spot, it was hard to see beyond the narcissism. People say it’s what makes him a great winner, but all I see is “me, me, me, meeeeee” from him, all the time. And it got old about a decade ago.
Now, fast forward to the present, and here we have a player who considers himself undroppable, unable to accept his decline, who makes teams worse by his status being far removed from his contribution to a functioning team unit, and he is at it again. Not turning up for pre-season, trying to engineer a move because he is more important than the team. Ronaldo is always in it for Ronaldo. His numbers, his stats, his accolades. Fair play, he’s had enormous success doing that. A fabulous player in his prime, but now a complete white elephant.
I really hopes he leaves, as I think his presence will be a huge sideshow and distraction and be detrimental to the collective team ethos ETH is trying to instill. Ronaldo still has value as a player, but in a role that accurately reflects his ability to positively impact results. That’s as (a) a rotational player and (b) an impact sub when you are chasing a goal. But that value could only ever be extracted if he had humility about his decline. Which he doesn’t. So instead he’s just a middle aged man baby on massive wages with a god complex.
The timing of this is particularly poor, because as fans we’ve had 9 shitty years since SAF retired, and we are all desperately yearning for some collectivity, a functioning team unit greater than the sum of its parts. For unity and a strong collective will to all pull in the same direction to the best of abilities. Then we have Ronaldo throwing strops, thinking he’s bigger than the club, and only thinking about himself.
We never should’ve brought him back, and the sooner he leaves the better. A legendary player, but a really unlikable character. There is also the issue of some really disturbing allegations against him, but as those remain unproven, I’ll just say that I find them troubling but reserve judgement.
I think a moment that encapsulated so much of what I dislike about Ronaldo was what I saw in the euro final. He went off injured. His team went on to win the game. But for Ronaldo his team winning wasn’t his victory, it was maybe no victory at all, so he had to make it about him. There he was on the touch line, standing in front of the manager waving his hands furiously, shouting tactical instructions, directing players. If he wasn’t scoring the goal and leading his team to victory, he was managing them. The glory was his. But I would venture that they won in spite of his ridiculous pantomime muddling the messages of the actual manager. It’s just unbridled narcissism that means he can never see beyond his own reflection.
I’d suggest he go feck himself after his latest bit of theatre but I am quite certain he is way ahead of me on that one.