Scandi Red
Hates Music.
- Joined
- Sep 25, 2022
- Messages
- 6,963
I really like him in CM.
I've honestly stopped caring where he plays. AM/CM/"wide" forward in 3-4-3... It doesn't matter, he'll just make it work.
I really like him in CM.
Nah feck it, it's worth the yellow some times to make it clear to the ref that he made a travesty of a decision. We need to be bigger cnuts sometimes and put refs under pressure for shit like that.Great performance, but needless yellow (he was of course fouled). Needs to learn from his red cards this season that we need him on pitch.
Another great game by him today. He ran his socks offPeople have tried this before where he has been compared to similar players, but somehow people don't want to change their opinion. Bruno's isn't disposessed more than similar players; his passing isn't more erratic, and he doesn't lose every tackle he engages in, like some would argue. According to stats, he's a very good and expansive passer; he works his socks off every game, wins the ball back more than players in a similar position and manages to come up with similar or better stats for goals and assists whilst playing in a far inferior team.
Stats are funny though - some years back posters argued that Carrick only had a high passing completion rate because all of his passes were sideways or backwards, but I think stats showed he played more forward passes than Xavi - not arguing he was a more expansive passer than Xavi, but still. People still won't change their mind.
The eye test would confirm that Bruno is a very good passer - he is a very expansive passer; some of those don't come off, sometimes due to a poor pass, but also sometimes due to a misunderstanding or sometimes down to a terrible run and decision making from a teammate.
Anyone arguing he doesn't work hard are taking the piss, but they do exist. Bruno regularly covers the most distance, and also regularly he wins the ball back deep into his own half. He's not great at defending, but sometimes just being there and getting a toe to the ball is enough to disrupt the flow from the attacking team.
He's a brilliant player, and in a better team where other players than him create more chances and manage to score, he would have even greater numbers, and he probably wouldn't have the responsibility of having to create everything for the team. United are currently quite useless without him.
Kind if agree, but didn't work today did it... refbkept dishing out cards like it was still Xmas *Dalot's were deserved though.Nah feck it, it's worth the yellow some times to make it clear to the ref that he made a travesty of a decision. We need to be bigger cnuts sometimes and put refs under pressure for shit like that.
Fantastic today! I actually loved that he was having a go at the ref. Showed passion and what he thought of a shambolic ref. Same with Maguire.Another great game by him today. He ran his socks off
I agree with this, my biggest issue with him has always been that he never played well in big games - he almost said as much himself after the Liverpool game that he needed a big performance. He’s been excellent the last 2 weeks. Hopefully he will keep up that level or close to it for the rest of the seasonHis last two performances have been brilliant. I think he was MoTM again today, with Maguire and De Ligt right behind him.
We, as a fan base, have often critiqued his big game performances, but today vs Arsenal he was really good, and I think last weekend at Anfield was his best performance in a United shirt.
What's notable since Amorim has come in is his increased positional discipline and he is taking that extre half second on the ball. Usually you'd say that's a bad thing, but for Bruno it's what many of us have wanted and I think Amorim is bringing out the best of him at the moment.
Maybe he's now entering his peak years with some much needed maturity on the pitch, bar that episode today. Think Amorim's words on leadership hit home for the likes of him, Maguire etc.
The finish was definitely exquisite. An absolute peach from a difficult position.World class finish, some people might think it was a simple chance but if you look at it properly he had to bend that around the defender. Bruno's gotta keep it up, been brilliant the last 2 games against top opposition
Why because he did throw a tantrum because he didn't get a call?This is one of the games im citing when the anti bruno brigade lose their shit when bruno complains to mainoo for a misplaced pass again, or when he raises his arms and rolleyes to the ref
He was singled out for the Liverpool game a lot, so that part doesn't really fit. Today, he had a good game, with no obvious mistakes but with a fantastic finish and a showing of containing himself and his temperament. I think, the performance against Liverpool was way better, todays views (also visible in the ratings) are very much influenced by the outcome of the match. I don't think, any team played particularly well but given the conditions, being away from home and with 10 man for such a long time, we did very well based on that.Think he epitomises United’s coverage in the media. When he’s sub par it’s blown way over the top and yet when he puts in displays like today and Liverpool nobody seems to mention it.
Pretty sure the mentions of that piece of play wasn't because he shouldn't talk to the ref but because he shouldn't throw a tantrum. Whether you think it is understandable or not, I would agree to you, doesn't matter because we had to deal with this bad ref and with this rather stupid yellow he had to walk a thin line for quite a long time. Which he did so well today - but we've seen it play out differently as well. If he had to make a last ditch tackle and then walk down the tunnel, we'd be at 9 men. So while the scene in this particular match wasn't an issue, even a reason to praise him for the level of containment he showed, the behaviour is not ideal.He’s also the captain. Literally the only player on our team who is allowed to talk to the referee. If he doesn’t complain then nobody else will. And it was a shocking performance by the ref.
So mental - yet predictable - that some fans use that as a reason to have a go at Bruno.
Definitely. Completely agree. Another reason to believe that we are seeing the beginning of a trend, which would be aweseome for whole team.Yeah, I can't be the only one who thought he was heading for another red. Credit to him though, reigned it in, channelled it and put it a second leader's performance on the trot. If it's fair to give the captain shit when we're all over the gaff, he has to get massive credit for leading 2 huge, passionate, heart filled team performances like the last 2 weeks. Good on him.
A lot of Bruno’s changes in style of play would be due to Amorim’s coaching team too. I feel they don’t get enough credit.
Yeah i think this is really what makes the difference in his performance. And kudos to Amorim for making this happenWhat's notable since Amorim has come in is his increased positional discipline and he is taking that extre half second on the ball. Usually you'd say that's a bad thing, but for Bruno it's what many of us have wanted and I think Amorim is bringing out the best of him at the moment.
More and more I am of the firm believe Bruno was playing as the manager asked of him
Think the midfield 4 are understanding their roles now - with Bruno specifically I get the impression he has reigned in his shooting and its benefitting the team a tonne. Could well be wrong but glancing at FBref he's made a remarkable change in attempts since Amorim came in.Another great performance from him today, seemed to be all over the pitch, energy levels are incredible, long may it continue.
Think the midfield 4 are understanding their roles now - with Bruno specifically I get the impression he has reigned in his shooting and its benefitting the team a tonne. Could well be wrong but glancing at FBref he's made a remarkable change in attempts since Amorim came in.
If you look at # of shots he's had, the only Amorim game he's been wasteful (7 shots) was Bournemouth which was a shocker - that's actually his most all season - but the next 10+ games are all ETH/Ruud. I feel like he's still getting the ball in similar situations as before but Amorim has definitely calmed him down a bit.
I disagree. Starting 11 every game, not a chance.This discussion is about whether he would get in their team, not whether they would buy him, he would get in their team if he was already there but they wouldn't buy him
Then here you have it, I disagree, there are multiple reasons he would not be an everyday starting 11. I would go into them, but you still wouldn't comprehend the "why".Like what @Red in STL mentioned, the discussion is about whether he would get in their starting XI, not whether they would buy him from their rival. If Bruno already at Liverpool or arsenal now, he would get into their starting XI over Curtis Jones & Odegaard.
If you replied to me saying ‘’I disagree’’ full stop and that’s it. I wouldn’t need to question it because it’s based on your opinion without bias reasons. The issue is that you started mentioning his age (which doesn’t matter since the likes of Robertson, Salah, and van Dijk are older than him), his speed (which is wrong because Bruno isn’t slower than Odegaard & Jones) and Robertson being Scottie, tough to the bone (which is very ridiculous reason).
Nah feck it, it's worth the yellow some times to make it clear to their ref that he made a travesty of a decision. We need to be bigger cnuts sometimes and put refs under pressure for shit like that.
The captain’s comments are great, but look at the captain’s proud look towards the end. priceless
I had countered your reasons and one of your response to my counters is ‘’Robertson being Scottie, tough to the bone’’. You had stated that yours is just based on your opinion without fact to back it up so you can stick with it.I disagree. Starting 11 every game, not a chance.
Then here you have it, I disagree, there are multiple reasons he would not be an everyday starting 11. I would go into them, but you still wouldn't comprehend the "why".