Anthony Martial image 9

Anthony Martial France flag

2016-17 Performances


View full 2016-17 profile

5.9 Season Average Rating
Appearances
42
Goals
8
Assists
8
Yellow cards
3
Status
Not open for further replies.
It's the Mourinho effect. Spend a lot, win one title in 3 years, and then screw over the team in the long run shipping away all your best young talent. Nothing new to see here. He's a control freak with an ego. If you follow his plan then great. Otherwise he points you to the door. Terrible management, but if it gets you a title once in 3 years, I think most people at the club will take that.

Of course we would...a title?...of course...deary me. Martial is not a bloody Cantona and actually....he hasn't set the world alight this season when he has played. Also his agent is a total c%£t....
 
This. Sold Mata and De Bryune to keep Oscar. Present day Oscar is in China whilst the other two are still playing regularly for top sides
Same side is about to win their 2nd League in 3 years. :lol:

The 1st Chelsea side he built lasted a decade.
 
People are standing up for Martial but I think many of you are forgetting that Mkhi was in a similar position 2 months ago... Even then Mourinho stated that the attitude of both players and the demeanour of their agents is totally different.

Fast forward a few months and Mkhi is an almost certain starter every game while Martial get an appearance here and there... Not saying that Mourinho couldn't have managed Martial better, but some of you are just too eager to criticize him.
 
What has that got to do with Martial? Or are you another one of those armchair psychologists?

There's no other reason Martial isn't playing other than not applying himself. If he doesn't respond to Mourinho's challenge and agitates to leave he's not the right type of player to have at the club. Mkhitaryan has risen to the same challenge and is thriving. The suggestion we should back players who don't want to work hard and earn their spots over a manager who is trying to establish a culture in a team that has underachieved for 4 years is absurd and it is completely how you end being weak and brittle like Arsenal do.
 
He sold them and won the league ffs

Sold them and could not break down the small teams ,finished third realised that he needed creative players then bought Fabregas. If you remember well that season Chelsea could beat all the big teams but failed when faced with small teams that parked the bus.
 

I simply think this is what is happening here. I can't think of another explanation. There is no way in hell, Mourinho would want rid of Martial, given the level of our squad.
 
Against Championship sides

Wigan FA Cup
Liverpool
Reading FA Cup
Hull (Subbed on in the 59th minute)

His 1 goal and 2 assists came in the FA Cup against Championship sides. Against Liverpool he did feck all..
He can only perform agiant the team Jose plays against. You can't challenge him to show he deserves to start, then respond to him playing well by saying "lol but those teams I played you against were shit. Off to the bench you go."
 
There's no other reason Martial isn't playing other than not applying himself. If he doesn't respond to Mourinho's challenge and agitates to leave he's not the right type of player to have at the club. Mkhitaryan has risen to the same challenge and is thriving. The suggestion we should back players who don't want to work hard and earn their spots over a manager who is trying to establish a culture in a team that has underachieved for 4 years is absurd and it is completely how you end being weak and brittle like Arsenal do.

There is nothing to suggest this is the case. You're speculating in an inherent move to support the manager you think you should be backing.
 
People are standing up for Martial but I think many of you are forgetting that Mkhi was in a similar position 2 months ago... Even then Mourinho stated that the attitude of both players and the demeanour of their agents is totally different.
I think the reason why it feels different is that Martial has had a good run of games whereas Mkhiki hadn't even had a run of games.
 
This. Sold Mata and De Bryune to keep Oscar. Present day Oscar is in China whilst the other two are still playing regularly for top sides

Fergie sold Pique to keep Evans. It's all about circumstance - Oscar was deemed the best fit for the tactics Mourinho was using, which is why he sold Mata then and has kept him now.

I really hope Mourinho finds a way to resolve his issue with Martial, whatever they are. I'm inclined to believe it's a grudge of some kind, because he's looked more dangerous than any other player we've stuck out on the left, but I'm hoping that it's Mourinho's way of testing Martial's mentality and driving him to become better, because that's the only way that this ends well for us.
 
We should be complaining about that Ashley Young sub more than anything else. In fact, there was no reason not to bring Martial on at around the 60th minute mark considering the game was done.

Other than that though, I don't think Martial has done enough this season to show that he deserves a starting spot over some of our match winners.
 

I simply think this is what is happening here. I can't think of another explanation. There is no way in hell, Mourinho would want rid of Martial, given the level of our squad.

And I'm sure it's the same with Shaw
 
Rashford is great coming off the bench or even playing up top but he's a pretty hopeless starter from the left wing. I just can't understand what's going on. Just sort it out blood hell.
It just goes to show that this has nothing to do with merit. Martial has been one of our better players of late and easily the best left winger. Rashford has been pretty crap. Yet Mourinho benches or drops the former in the last two games and starts the latter.
 
There is only one loser here if this situation continues and it's not our manager.
It doesn't have to be Martial either. He may go elsewhere and tear it up and become the world beater he can.
 
We should be complaining about that Ashley Young sub more than anything else.
It's probably nothing more than Jose doing his usual thing of rewarding under-used players for their attitude & hard work. He often regrets, publicly, that he can't give everyone regular games.
 
So in other words, he can only improve players he himself buys? He cant improve players that were already in the team when he came in because they werent 'his choice'? Conte's done it with his whole team, and Pep's doing it with average players like Sterling.

And maybe Martial is just concentrating on spouting off via his agent rather then getting his head down and doing what is asked of him.
 
We should be complaining about that Ashley Young sub more than anything else. In fact, there was no reason not to bring Martial on at around the 60th minute mark considering the game was done.

Other than that though, I don't think Martial has done enough this season to show that he deserves a starting spot over some of our match winners.

Rashford deserves a starting sport? Does Lingard? Both have been awful when starting games off that wing.
It just goes to show that this has nothing to do with merit. Martial has been one of our better players of late and easily the best left winger. Rashford has been pretty crap. Yet Mourinho benches or drops the former in the last two games and starts the latter.

Absolutely. There's no way Rashford and Lingard are playing left wing on merit over Martial. Call it "protecting" him or whatever it is that Jose thinks he's doing but it's not merit based. He'll suddenly throw in Martial in March, realize he's actually pretty good and then pretend like it was a masterstroke like he thought his Mkhi treatment was.
 
Minutes given in last five matches:

ThxMgbg.png
 
In fairness, in terms of the Young sub, it would've been pointless to stick on Martial with that little time left. Even with 20 mins left it would've been pointless. Not much interest from either team to really do anything apart from letting the clock run down.
 
Everything @Damien has posted clearly shows that Martial has been performing well of late and out performing many of our other attackers. He simply deserves to play. Jose better not feck this up.

Rashford deserves a starting sport? Does Lingard? Both have been awful when starting games off that wing.


Absolutely. There's no way Rashford and Lingard are playing left wing on merit over Martial. Call it "protecting" him or whatever it is that Jose thinks he's doing but it's not merit based. He'll suddenly throw in Martial in March, realize he's actually pretty good and then pretend like it was a masterstroke like he thought his Mkhi treatment was.
Sad part is Mkhitarian was at least frozen out and hence you couldn't point to his good form. Martial on the other hand has shown good improvement but is still ignored. P
 

I simply think this is what is happening here. I can't think of another explanation. There is no way in hell, Mourinho would want rid of Martial, given the level of our squad.


Good response on the matter by José to be fair.

I hope him and Martial are communicating properly and have some sort of plan to ease him back into the line up. However, i'm still not happy with how Mourinho has handled this since he has gone further than he did with Mkhitaryans situation, and Martial is very much needed at the moment since Rashford isn't good enough as a starter. At least these comments hints that the relationship between them hasn't totally broken down.
 
He's got 4 goals and 3 assists in his last 7 starts. What more do you want?

His agent hasn't said anything since December.
Yeah, but he should just shut up, work hard and play well. Or something.
 
Good response on the matter by José to be fair.

I hope him and Martial are communicating properly and have some sort of plan to ease him back into the line up. However, i'm still not happy with how Mourinho has handled this since he has gone further than he did with Mkhitaryans situation, and Martial is very much needed at the moment since Rashford isn't good enough as a starter. At least these comments hints that the relationship between them hasn't totally broken down.
That's the most important thing in this whole issue.
 
I dont care if Martial is lazy during training or whatever the reason may be. If he performs better than others in a match, he should be in the start 11. Easy as it is
 
Sounds like you think Martial's welfare is more important than the club. He's one of many players. If the manager selects him then great. If not, then he should work his way back into the squad (assuming he's a fighter) and do whatever is necessary to get back into the mix.
Agree with this but there is something really fishy with Mou and young talents. Just look at Rashford, half the player he was last year..

Martial hasnt done anything worse than other players this year but Mou has come out and said he needed to be sensational to be in the team..

Fellaini isnt a United player and Young is leaving but still no minutes for Martial..

Glad we won but something is not right..
Miki is 28 and this worked with him but a 20 year old and French not sure.
 
Mourinho is a short term manager. He acts and thinks like a short term manager.

You can argue that the cost of persisting with Martial might be high in the short term but the potential benefit in the long run is massive. The long run is not something that matters that much to Jose. There is no shame in that, we knew what kind of manager he is when we hired him.
 
Rashford deserves a starting sport? Does Lingard? Both have been awful when starting games off that wing.

Neither deserve the spot any more than Martial does, but I guess that's where attitude rather than ability gives them the nod over Martial.
 
Something's happening off the pitch, even when Martial puts in a good perfirmace he's usually dropped for the next game.

He needs a run of games even when he's not playing well stick with him the end result will be worth it.
 
Some on here clearly have issues with Mourinho and are just jumping on any chance to criticize him. From what I've seen this season, I trust him 100% to do right by this football club. I don't buy all this unfair treatment of Martial bollocks. There's no reason to think Mourinho is doing anything other than man-managing Martial in the best interests of both himself and the team. Reading the comments, I wouldn't be surprised if many of you just want him to feck off out of OT. It's quite sad really.
 
Mou has come out and said he needed to be sensational to be in the team..
That alone tells us that something is up. Jose said that Martial would have to be 'magnificent' to make the team...a team in which no-one else is playing magnificently. The over-strong, sarcastic wording suggests to me that Mou is unhappy with Tony (or his people).
 
Good response on the matter by José to be fair.

I hope him and Martial are communicating properly and have some sort of plan to ease him back into the line up. However, i'm still not happy with how Mourinho has handled this since he has gone further than he did with Mkhitaryans situation, and Martial is very much needed at the moment since Rashford isn't good enough as a starter. At least these comments hints that the relationship between them hasn't totally broken down.

The comment is on Miki how does that hint anything as far as the relationship with martial is concerned.
 
Feckin hell, win a match and the main topic is who didn't play.

Personally disappointed he played no part, but 2 threads at top of home page are both about Martial. Crazy stuff...
 
That alone tells us that something is up. Jose said that Martial would have to be 'magnificent' to make the team...a team in which no-one else is playing magnificently. The over-strong, sarcastic wording suggests to me that Mou is unhappy with Tony (or his people).

The standard used on Martial is absurd. And then using miki as the reason why he wasnt playing when he doesnt play on the left...its just all very dramatic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.