SteveW
Full Member
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2013
- Messages
- 7,194
Sounds like Mourinho is getting a good return out of him when he plays him, no? I'm not saying its down to Mourinho but i'm just suggesting stats can be twisted, they are not completely objective, just watch the game, obviously martial can be class but there are many games he isn't and many games he doesn't involve himself enough in, which isn't good enough to be a guaranteed starter
On the flip side Rashford was our best player in the last game playing in the same position so are we not hampering his momentum too, by dropping him? we have three players out wide who have played well in their most recent games in mkhi martial and rashford, so they are competing for two spots. Your argument is basically martial has the most talent give it to him, because he hasn't been in such good form that he's earned one of the spots automatically rashford last week was better than either of martials last two performances but not as good as him tonight. That doesn't foster good competition for places in the squad and doesn't let players know if they work hard in training they will get a spot. Martial was good today and I would start him and Mkhi against Hull, but he has had games where he hasn't played well hence we have looked elsewhere for a solution, Mourinho isn't some newbie who doesn't know what he is doing, he is creating a certain competitive edge in the squad and Martial will step up with it hopefully. He had long, poor patches last season as well, and it pays to have alternatives around who can play
Yeah good point every player who has played well the season before has walked into a new league and hit the ground running, its why I've got both Di maria and Falcao shirts, Players take time to adapt, Mkhi was working on that got injured came back and worked his way up the pecking order, he did a good job and now whenever he plays he stands outs.
I understand where you're coming from but it equates to saying just play the best players, squad dynamics are a lot less straightforward than that.
We aren't going to agree on this.
It's going to be very difficult to agree if you feel the need to change the subject every time you realise I might be right about something.
Your argument has changed quite a bit in the last few hours. It's gone from Martial's been shite all season and doesn't deserve to play to "isn't Jose getting a good return from him" So do that mean he is playing well? It's getting confusing.