Ole's_toe_poke
Ole_Aged_Slow_Poke
- Joined
- Jan 7, 2009
- Messages
- 36,846
There are a few options, but he'd be a brilliant signing whatever the case.Would this signing mean we're switching to our 4231? Di Maria and Januzaj out wide, Mata behind presumably Rooney (since he's captain now)
RVP plays where?
Maybe he plans to play him up front in Robben's world cup role in the 352? Either way you'd think our strikers are going to be shafted.
If we play him at wing back I think I'm gonna give up.
So either Mata starts wide
There are a few options, but he'd be a brilliant signing whatever the case.
Either a 4-2-3-1:
Carrick - HerreraSo either Mata starts wide and Rooney in the middle or Januzaj does and one of the strikers is on the bench.
Januzaj/Mata - Mata/Rooney - Di Maria
Rooney/Van Persie
Or a 4-3-1-2 diamond type thing, with Di Maria playing the same role he does for Madrid:
Rafael - Evans - Smalling - ShawEither way, it gives us options, and he's the type of player we're crying out for in attack but personally I'd take the first because of the width it gives us.
Carrick
Herrera - Di Maria
Mata
Rooney - RVP
In the first it's a 4-2-3-1/4-3-3 but I just wasn't bothered putting the defenders. Probably should have. Anyways, I know, that's what I was thinking with the second formation. It's a very similar midfield to Madrids trio of last season, but up front instead it is different. Instead of Ronaldo and Bale on the wings with Benzema in the middle, it'd be Mata at the tip of the diamond, behind Rooney and RVP who drift to one side when Di Maria goes wide going forward, and the fullbacks overlapping.It would be a waste of Di Maria's talents if we play him as a wing back. Moreover, lets not forget LVG himself has said he will revert to his favoured 4-3-3 if he gets a specialist winger as good as Di Maria. Naturally that would mean a 4-3-3 with 2 wingers flanking a forward (Rooney/RVP). However, that wouldn't be the optimal usage of our resources, thus I envisage a 4-3-3 like the latter formation of yours.
Think of how Milan used 4-3-1-2 or the diamond with the likes of Seedorf and Kaka providing enough penetration and ability to 'stretch defenses' without necessarily playing orthodox wingers. Di Maria would be perfect in the left sided midfield role, primarily staying in the middle but also capable of making those driving penetrative runs in the left handed channels when necessary to provide width. Imagine Herrera and Di Maria in our midfield, so much drive, energy, industry, tenacity and creativity. Carrick would be perfect at shielding the defence and being the outlet who can recycle and retain possession whilst also being capable of starting off moves from the deep. I know we lack pace and drive in our front three but with a much improved midfield behind them, they can truly shine and elevate their game up a notch with runners from the deep to support when neccessary. With our current first team, opposition teams have to target and nullify our relatively static front three to stifle our attacking game considerably. The threat from deep both creatively and penetrating drive wise is relatively non-existent barring Herrera who is still settling in. Swansea probably made it a point to target Herrera and prevent him from dictating the game with some harsh challenges to disrupt him.
If we really do lack the width we could sub off one of RVP or Rooney and put Januzaj in while pushing Di Maria forward into a wider role. Mata could be brought off to accommodate another central midfielder.
Its all just hypotheticals but Di Maria is a player who can genuinely transform our gameplay and our midfield completely.
With Herrera and Di Maria's workrate, that formation (or similar) will work really well.--------Roo/vanp----------
Mata---------------Januzaj
----diMaria--Herrera----
----------Carrick---------
Shaw----------------Raf
-----Benatia--Jones-----
-----------deGea---------
Love to see us move to that system,with the rigt signings of course,given our pretty exposed flws at the back,a quality cb is essential.
Has a bit of everything in theory,width,pace,creativity,reliant goalscorers.
Id still want a crafted defensive midfielder as well,even a stop gap like Blind<bolster midfield numbers> untill Carricks fully fit and back to his best hopefully.
Hed be a serious signing to be fair,given how versatile he is,ghosting wide and centrally,hed free a lot upfor all those around him,ontop of his underrated workrate.
Oh I don't know when you spend more than 100m Euros to buy a certain James Rodriguez and Toni Kroos, who happen to play the positions Di Maria play, where does Di Maria fit in?Di Maria could be our Ozil if nothing else, though I don't know why Real Madrid is willing to sell in the first place. (I haven't followed this "saga" so I don't really know anything about this)
*sigh* that explains it.Oh I don't know when you spend more than 100m Euros to buy a certain James Rodriguez and Toni Kroos, who happen to play the positions Di Maria play, where does Di Maria fit in?
--------Roo/vanp----------
Mata---------------Januzaj
----diMaria--Herrera----
----------Carrick---------
Shaw----------------Raf
-----Benatia--Jones-----
-----------deGea---------
Love to see us move to that system,with the rigt signings of course,given our pretty exposed flws at the back,a quality cb is essential.
Has a bit of everything in theory,width,pace,creativity,reliant goalscorers.
Id still want a crafted defensive midfielder as well,even a stop gap like Blind<bolster midfield numbers> untill Carricks fully fit and back to his best hopefully.
Hed be a serious signing to be fair,given how versatile he is,ghosting wide and centrally,hed free a lot upfor all those around him,ontop of his underrated workrate.
That's bullshit. How would Ladyman know what Di Maria told his family?Interesting snippet from the piece by Ladyman...
Di Maria is aware of United’s capacity to pay big wages and has told his family of his surprise that the English club’s offer outstrips anything made by other suitors, including mega-rich Paris Saint-Germain of France
Maybe he spoke to one of Di Maria' family members?That's bullshit. How would Ladyman know what Di Maria told his family?
I refuse to get sucked in.
what silly news.Interesting snippet from the piece by Ladyman...
Di Maria is aware of United’s capacity to pay big wages and has told his family of his surprise that the English club’s offer outstrips anything made by other suitors, including mega-rich Paris Saint-Germain of France
--------Roo/vanp----------
Mata---------------Januzaj
----diMaria--Herrera----
----------Carrick---------
Shaw----------------Raf
-----Benatia--Jones-----
-----------deGea---------
Love to see us move to that system,with the rigt signings of course,given our pretty exposed flws at the back,a quality cb is essential.
Has a bit of everything in theory,width,pace,creativity,reliant goalscorers.
Id still want a crafted defensive midfielder as well,even a stop gap like Blind<bolster midfield numbers> untill Carricks fully fit and back to his best hopefully.
Hed be a serious signing to be fair,given how versatile he is,ghosting wide and centrally,hed free a lot upfor all those around him,ontop of his underrated workrate.
No one is paying 100 million for him. More like 40-50.
No one is paying 100 million for him. More like 40-50.
It is understood United have told the Argentine that, with performance-based incentives, they will pay him around £200,000 a week. Over a five-year deal that would take United’s investment to £100m when a transfer fee of around £50m is included. A
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/fo...ngel-Di-Maria-Old-Trafford.html#ixzz3AitOVjhD
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook
I'm seeing posts where people are questioning the logic of the signing of a world class player because we play a 3-5-2 hence my earlier post.An, that makes more sense.