André Onana | signed for United | On a flight to NYC

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hardly matters it's not as if we are making him no 1 going forward , we will just delay his departure till the time we get Keeper signing sorted .

Rather play Heaton.
As OP said, Henderson burnt bridges. And ETH doesn't seem like one to tolerate jerks..
 
If DDG leaves today then the absolute priority becomes GK, even if it means a season of Rashford starting as ST with Garnacho starting LW.
 
I don't think Henderson is welcome back regardless of our keeping situation.
Rather play Heaton.
As OP said, Henderson burnt bridges. And ETH doesn't seem like one to tolerate jerks..

I am not saying Play Henderson just suggesting that keep him till the time we get new No 1 sorted obviously it should be done before the competitive season starts .

Just for appearance sake.
 
We starting the season with Heston as first choice are we ? Henderson is as good as gone
This will happen 100 percent. We'll have just Heaton without backup. Godness knows what will happen if he gets injured.
 
I am not saying Play Henderson just suggesting that keep him till the time we get new No 1 sorted obviously it should be done before the competitive season starts .

Just for appearance sake.
Yeah I understood that, but I'm pretty sure Henderson has been told to clear his locker out when he left.
 
Because you either aren't capable or can't be bothered, here it is again for you. The agreements were well in place with Inter and Onana far in advance of EtH's name even being mentioned in rumours to come to us, it was signed off officially in January of 2022.

I see. So we were incapable of organizing anything before January. Thats amazing that the club didnt fall apart completely before that. Course you're probably just wrong
 
Relax. We’ll sign Onana. Simon stones just giving his personal opinion and is famous for being a negative bastard that loves pouring cold water over things.
 
I see. So we were incapable of organizing anything before January. Thats amazing that the club didnt fall apart completely before that. Course you're probably just wrong

Why would we go out and secure a keeper when we didn't even know who the manager was going to be? Go take your head for a shit.
 
De Gea doesn't save a lot of the "de Gea saves those" type of shots anymore so whatever. And besides, being strong in the air, quality passing out from the back and having a mentality where you relish the big occasions are all far more important for big clubs than just an elite shot stopper but who is woeful in those 3 aspects.
Think the problem with De Gea is that even still on occasion he has the ability to make saves only ten keepers in the world could make (and maybe Onana can't) but he will then concede possession in games United are dominating and allow a goal where you think "FFS Massimo Taibi saves those".

Can't put my finger on it but he's so cowardly and the opposite to clutch. Absolutely hates the physical stuff. It's a shame but as amazing as he's been on a personal basis, I now associate him more with things like his performance in Ole's EL Final - making no penalty saves and that embarrassing Arsenal goal a couple of seasons back where he was just lying on the floor after getting an accidental kick from Fred expecting play to stop and Arsenal just slot it in while he's rolling around. His peaks have been during the team's nadir - best keeper in the world when we're getting hosed but blunders come into his game as we improve. Really looking forward to having someone like Onana or Costa if it comes to it and we can hopefully start building up like every other modern team does.
 
I am not saying Play Henderson just suggesting that keep him till the time we get new No 1 sorted obviously it should be done before the competitive season starts .

Just for appearance sake.

More than appearance, the important point is to actually have a pre season with the number 1 GK.

We obviously have to keep Henderson till we actually sell him, so he will be in the squad. Maybe just won't be played at all
 
Then what was starting with Heaton all about .
Pre-season presumably. DDG is out of contract tomorrow and until we sign a new one most likely we need to play Heaton in the friendly games.

I wouldn't want to start Henderson in our pre-season as it makes zero sense. He's goner either way. Play reserve keeper or ideally get a new one asap.
 
I see. So we were incapable of organizing anything before January. Thats amazing that the club didnt fall apart completely before that. Course you're probably just wrong
You're still going with this? :lol:
 
Why would we go out and secure a keeper when we didn't even know who the manager was going to be? Go take your head for a shit.

Its called planning. Something you should do before posting. De Gea had been performing poorly, one of the reasons we were looking for a new manager. Of course you'll find an excuse for that too
 
He left on really bad terms from what I remember, then went public about it once he joined Forrest.
Yeah I remember that but weren't there reports of Ten Hag wanting him back in January after Dubravka left or am I imagining .
 
Pre-season presumably. DDG is out of contract tomorrow and until we sign a new one most likely we need to play Heaton in the friendly games.

I wouldn't want to start Henderson in our pre-season as it makes zero sense. He's goner either way. Play reserve keeper or ideally get a new one asap.
Oh My bad then ideally I wouldn't want Henderson to feature either if he doesn't have future here , get the new Keeper sorted out quickly and let him gel with the team as soon as possible .
 
Its called planning. Something you should do before posting. De Gea had been performing poorly, one of the reasons we were looking for a new manager. Of course you'll find an excuse for that too

Just so we are clear, YOUR plan would involve securing a goalkeeper (or indeed any player) who the eventual appointment might not fancy/doesn't fit into their preferred game model?

Thank feck you aren't in charge of any football club, let alone this one.
 
I think Onana is overhyped by the media. Good Goal keeper but nothing else. the fact that he may be good at his feet should be a bonus not a main requirement. A goalkeeper should primary be judged by how commanding he is ..able to make good saves..etc..Courtois may be a good example for that. Infact until recently a player who used his feet much was a considered a high risk goal keeper. I remember the Columbian goalkeeper ..Higuita.
I personally would renew Degea contract for a year and spend the money for other positions. we will have one more year not to worry about goalkeepers.
Isn't that one of his strengths? From the limited times I've seen him it's one of the qualities that stood out to me.
 
Just so we are clear, YOUR plan would involve securing a goalkeeper (or indeed any player) who the eventual appointment might not fancy/doesn't fit into their preferred game model?

Thank feck you aren't in charge of any football club, let alone this one.

Every club does this. Managers come and go just like the players. The club needs a structure and plan above that, plenty have directors of football for just that and others have owners that are heavily involved with who the players are and the manager needs to work with it. There are few clubs that let transfer windows go by because they havent decided on their manager yet.
 
are we the only club that agrees personal terms with players before agreeing a fee with the club? I use to think a bid would have to be accepted and then you talk to the player.
 
are we the only club that agrees personal terms with players before agreeing a fee with the club? I use to think a bid would have to be accepted and then you talk to the player.

Nope - Real Madrid did the same with Bellingham, and countless other clubs do it.
 
are we the only club that agrees personal terms with players before agreeing a fee with the club? I use to think a bid would have to be accepted and then you talk to the player.

Nope I think most big clubs do this as a way of avoiding wasting time. Imagine we spent ages chasing Onana only to find out he will only sign for us for a wage that we don't find acceptable or worse doesn't want to sign for us at all.

This is a complete guess but I think that's why you're not hearing about us chasing Kane. I reckon he told us he didn't want to sign here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.