Why does it always end up back here?
24
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 51
- Clean sheets
- 13
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 6
- Status
Why does it always end up back here?
Because it’s important to understand why we brought in Onana. This argument was all the rage at this time last year, with no thought whatsoever given to the primary attribute required of any top keeper…shot-stopping.
Over/under 100 for how many times @lex talionis has posted that strawman?
It wasn't even mentioned that much. It has mostly been brought up by posters looking to make a cheap point about us not playing out from the back this season either.
This fecking clown is one of the biggest reasons the season went tits up and ultimately the manager losing his job. Fecking idiot put in the worst Champions League keeping campaign of all time.
Man City 1:2 Man Utd
Some good saves but that goal was a shocker.
Otherwise a solid enough performance.
Otherwise a solid enough performance.
Still undecided on him but thought he earned that feck up today after keeping us in it at times,still shocking for the goal but the whole team played well.
Did really well, shame about the goal but made some great saves otherwise.
I thought he had an very good to excellent game. Good saves, good in the box but unfortunatly he did let in a weak goal again. So in the end i dont think you can rate his game as great because of that...
That left handed save from Walker was superb. Shame about the goal but he did well throughout. As did the whole team. He's a character.
I'm sure he will be No1 next year but what other club would accept a GK who for every 10 saves, throws one in
We won't be able to sell him.
We can coach him to improve but he won't improve much.
Something's off with his feet.
Seems a great guy and makes some top saves at times but those soft goals he lets in feel like that they will stop him from being good enough at top level.
Thought he was really good apart from the one howler, so I suppose it somewhat balances out.
Could have been man of the match aside from the goal, overall pretty good.
Great game apart from the huge mistake. Very lucky that didn't cost us
Very good today and made some really good and key saves, should have done better on their goal though.
Too many mistakes in him for me. I like his personality but we need better. I would prioritize other positions but we would need to improve upon him soon.
Sorry, but no. Made one very good save, one dodgy punch when he should have caught a cross, and am awful error which was the goal. He was otherwise fine. It was a 6/10 performance at best.
It sucks at times to be a keeper. One mistake and that dominates discussion. It was a bad mistake but apart from the mistake he had a very good game.
The Walker save was incredible. Needed an extremely strong hand to keep that out.
Real shame about the one he let in. Apart from that, he had a very good performance, but that's mainly what we will end up discussing.
He has so much of what we need from a modern keeper but unfortunately, he always has a mistake in him.
I don't want to be argumentative but how was he 'very good'? His distribution was ok, made one very good save and pretty much everything else aside from the mistake was forgettable.
Good but we got to get a better, consistently reliable keeper next season
Watched the ball the entire way for their goal and still let it in. He's not the right keeper for an ambitious team. If we aren't ambitious, we can keep him i suppose.
He saved us. Feck that error. We won. I've been highly critical of him, but there is a very good keeper there
How? One very good stop and...not much else. Certainly nothing else exceptional.
His distribution was better than ok, the very good save was actually a great save.
My anti-Onana credentials are well established here, but when the man has a good game apart from a bad mistake — which I acknowledge is somewhat like asking Mrs. Lincoln what she thought of the play — it has to be called as it is.
Quality today. Some of the high claims were brilliant too. Small error for the goal but he was brilliant
I just think he's a bit of a dodgy keeper.
Capable of great saves but loads of errors too
Capable of great saves but loads of errors too
Hes was good today for most of the game. But he has an error in him as he again showed today.
It wasn't a great save imo. Wasn't that far away from him and, like most he makes, he made it look more spectacular than it was. I'll give you his distribution being better than just ok, but it wasn't particularly noteworthy. All in all, we need to get rid but we definitely have bigger fires to fight so I wouldn't be sad to see him in nets next season.
Good enough. Takes grit and fortitude to move on from the horrific start of the season. Need to improve what is in front of him.
He's great in 9 out of 10 actions, but that 1 action will be terrible and it might cost him being ever considered a top keeper.
That's not true though. He may be adequate in 9/10, but great is an enormous reach
He had to spoil what otherwise could have been an enjoyable injury time period.... where did 7 minutes come from??
Top man again.
City's tactics of just offloading to Doku to run at AWB second half would eventually yield something. Overall it was a great performance and strong character to say we're coming here to win, he made the saves and we won against that cheating fabrication. .
City's tactics of just offloading to Doku to run at AWB second half would eventually yield something. Overall it was a great performance and strong character to say we're coming here to win, he made the saves and we won against that cheating fabrication. .
Two very good saves, both from Walker. Very good and calm with his feet. Made some punches and hold on to a corner in the dying minutes of the game. His first season has been very up and down, but I'm willing to give him a year more before I make my judgement. He has something. And all this negativity has to stop
And adequate is also an enormous reach, he’s capable of brilliant saves and passes. If you want to be pedantic then 5 great actions, 4 adequate actions and 1 terrible action.
He's just too bulky for a goalie. He needs to get leaner and it should help with some of those awkward dives that miss
- Status