Alejandro Garnacho (out) | Chelsea make enquiries
- Thread starter Luca[4]
- Start date
He also looks awful from the games I have seen him in, very much a Werner type, very fast but abysmal end product on most occasions.Ouch, fairs though
Neither will Adeyemi but I guess he's cheaper
The fact that Rico Lewis is in 10th..Yes he was. Mainoo was 7th.
I don't think this is the final rating, is it?Yes he was. Mainoo was 7th.
Farewell appearance. Tears will be shed.
Apologies. I was confusing it with the ‘Kopa’ listYes he was. Mainoo was 7th.
Garnacho starting.
Yeah he's not very good. Think Dortmund will have mugged Napoli well and proper if they get anything close to €50m for him. Glad to see them doing it to someone other than United for once!
Yeah I dont think this potential move is being driven by Amorim at all. This is all on Ineos and Glazers.
This is interesting. A good performance tonight to try and persuade Napoli to spend the money on him you recon?
He’s only recently been getting into Amorims team though. If he can sell him for 60m and replace with a LWB and AM then he’d opt for that surely.
Will be pretty funny if he ends up starting against us next month and fecks up about 3 counters and gets brushed off the ball easily while Chelsea fans are confused.
If this goes through I think it's just going to be a matter of how much we end up regretting it. For a player of his age to have as much experience at a top club (at least in terms of expectations and exposure) and the output he already has I think is pretty rare and even with his inconsistencies he's still one of our more dangerous players and his pace and willingness to run in behind is something very few in our team can offer. If he develops as you would expect a young player to do and works on his weaknesses I can't see him becoming anything less than a very good player and potentially more than that too but even if we don't see a huge change in his game over the next few seasons he'll still have some excellent performances for Chelsea in that time and if they decide to move him on I expect they'll be able to demand a very similar fee to the one they're rumoured to be offering.
The only way this transfer would be good for us is if it was silly money and even then it'd be sad to see him go because I don't really have any confidence in us to go out and replace him or improve the team in other areas with any competency.
The only way this transfer would be good for us is if it was silly money and even then it'd be sad to see him go because I don't really have any confidence in us to go out and replace him or improve the team in other areas with any competency.
Starting line-ups the day before
not an insignificant perk.You don't think his preference would keep Garnacho and have an actual living breathing LB in the squad?
Maybe it’s all true that everyone is for sale and Chelsea are actually testing the waters. Strange move if we want to sell.
Amorim might see things different as well. Garnacho might find form and adjust to the new system.
I can see him stay at this point. Somewhat embarrassing if we sell a starting player. Let’s say he scores a couple of goals tonight. What then?
Because we gave him a huge contract and only him playing and scoring goals makes it worth it. Thats also when the bigger transfer offers will come in. Freezing him out will see us finding it far harder to sell him
Don’t forget him hitting the side netting from at least 2 chances.
Why? He'll just get lost amogst the other hundred or so wingers they already have.How or why are you still pretending to be shocked and surprised at people not wanting to sell a talented youngster to Chelsea?
He's not kicked as hoped, doesn't fit in the formation but we still shouldn't sell him
I'm convinced it's because of the Everton goal.
He's so overrated it's not true.
Don't forget we're selling them Sancho.
Found another one @Shark
I think it’s strange selling him. I believe he will learn the new system. It’s been like two months or so with Amorim. It’s not like Garnacho is the only player not playing good at the moment.
If we sell him it’s all Glazers/Ineos making money like a selling club would.
Pretty spot on really.
Since being dropped against City, there are clear signs he's adapting to the new system as well
Scholes didn’t even make his full senior debut until he was 20, for example. I can’t help but thinking this is a bad move. Garnacho is currently one of the only players who can score, Bruno and Amad being the others, and there’s no guarantee whoever we buy will work any better.
Snap their hand off and run.
If scores tonight and does the "cold" celebration, I might soil myself.
I think you meant to post this on the "pretty stupid takes" threadNani is one of the mot overrated players of all time for United.
Even Rashford was handsdown better.
Nani playing upfront with Hojlund instead of rooney would have been hilarious to watch
A purple patch of one season masked by playing as a squad player in arguably one of the two best United teams of all time.
He'll follow it up by kissing the badge, just to make us all guess
It only does for clubs in some very specific situations, which probably doesn't include United unless really high spending is planned. For most clubs PSR incentivices clubs to keep youth products and sell others.
You might be beting on the wrong horse, Rashy's your guy with a discount.
He's not the finished article yet. He has to earn his stripes by putting in the hard graft.
He's so overrated it's not true.
It sounds like sour grapes after Gernacho told them he prefers Chelsea.Ouch, fairs though
Neither will Adeyemi but I guess he's cheaper
I hope he puts a performance in tonight that shuts the short-sighted "sell him" numpties up!
This the last game then for o'l Roy Cropper face?
More likely he’s the new Welbeck and scores every time he faces us.
I can’t let go of the thought this wingbacks system is not the way United should play. It’s going to take 2-3 years of tough sledding to get a functioning Amorim team, and will we even like what we see then? We won under LVG and everyone hated the football style. Somehow this Amorim system has to be the be-all end-all, or we sack him and rebuild yet again — and Garnacho will still be only 24 when it happens!
Why don’t you actually back up your opinion with something substantial instead of just short statements that mean nothing?