Jesus, not this again. I don't know where you got it into your head that I'm an Anderson fan, but I'm not. I remember you kept randomly referring to me defending him this summer when I'd never posted anything of the sort. Maybe you're thinking of someone else?
Either way, come back with an actual quote or piss off.
Nov 25, 2012
Lawman said:
As I have stated I like Anderson but too many people defend him blindly. Yes, he could be great but he has failed to do it in 5 years off being here. Injuries, form, selection issues whatever these are the facts. To suggest he will now be great and answer our problems in midfield is optimistic. Will he produce levels off consistency and stay fit given his track record? I think the manager might give him a try but think its more likely we will buy someone else. I say might because i'm not even sure Fergie hasn't already got other plans already.
Brightonian said:
1. This is the flaw at the core of your argument. You say over and over again that he's failed to do it in five years here, so he probably won't do it now. But you ignore the perfectly valid reasons we've given you why those five years are not necessarily indicative of his future.
2. This is a valid concern. If he continues to get injuries over the next five years the way he has over the last five, then he'll probably never contribute much more to United than he does now. If he manages to shake off the injury problems, however, I don't think consistently good football is something to worry about. During the last two seasons, his good games have far outweighed his average ones. And the good ones have been really, really good. His ratio of good to bad/average is no worse than Welbeck's or Hernandez'.