Good analysis, I think your conclusions are in line with the reality Ole has to deal with. My feeling is that he is doing the right things but receiving criticism for the mess that previous coach exchanges have caused.
I really hope he gets a couple of years to build something new, to get rid of him now would be idiotic. It's naive to think it's a quick fix.
This.
Those of you who have gone into a new company and tried to change things from the performance to the culture of the workplace will know how difficult it is. But you all have been given time and will not be judged twice a week unlike in Ole's case.
We have tried every way possible. There are only so many orifices.... Get a traditional British sort. Then go long term and get a philosophical sea change sort then when that didnt work, we needed a quick/guarantee win type to relief some pressures by winning.
Now we are stuck with the ensalada of 'talent.'
What manager in the world can implement his vision and style with that ensalada? No one.
By getting Ole, Woodward is back to taking a long term view of now, re-building the club ie developing its new/old identity.
Now, what's the first thing you need to do? Chop off those who you think will not ft your new identity. Plus they need to reduce the wage bill as mentioned earlier. At least Woodward will have some positive news to announce later.
If you look at his next step, addressing the highest operational priority, the defence and change 50% of a back four, I would say Ole's choices have been pretty good.
In fact, all three buys so far have been pretty good -- considering that it would be his first transfers and the amount of pressure on Ole and his team to get it right must have been incredible considering the clusterfeck performances towards the end of last season.
So far I think he has taken the simple but most logical steps given the financial and organisational constraints.
Implementation of his ideas/philosophy etc is another issue. But that was never an overnight job as some so naively think it was meant to be. Football teams consist of people. It aint some lego set.
Our problems run deep and will not be some quick fix. We will just need to go through the pain to hope things get better.
If Woodward chickens out based on social media pressure then he's a fool -- then I am sure we will be back to short term fixes again. He'll need another 'quick win.'
The grass isnt always greener either -- those of you pining for Poch, need to ask yourselves, what has he done? Has done well in clubs that have no pressure to win. ZERO Pressure.
The moment there were some expectations on Poch to win silverware, he has a meltdown making odd statements.
Not Poch, then Nagelmann? Another fella who has managed in clubs with no pressure to win every week never mind silverware. We will keep go after the lastest hottest managers.
Bottomline is that there are no quick sure answers. But to start shouting for one of our own to get the sack after ONE transfer window is just stupid.
It says more about yourself than anything else. One you clearly have never been in a culture change environment at work.
Secondly, if you are so willing to throw out one of your own means that loyalty is meaningless and its all about 'winning' -- then you need to question yourself because then its starting to sound Trumpish and you should then go start supporting City or now Liverpool and come back when United starts winning again.
Finally, there just aren't many who can do well under high-pressure situations ie the necessity to win jobs. Play nice football, sure there are quite a few out there. FFS even Chris Wilder can be considered innovative but can he win silverware?
Ole's got the toughest job in the world right now. Fatch.
If we cant stick by one of our own, even within three transfer window, who can we get? Some egotistical guy who thing only he can fix this mess? Or some greenhorn who has no idea what its like at United never mind managing the scale of the place -- he crumbles after a year then we sack him?
There are many options left for Woodward to be honest. He isnt kneejerking by going with Ole. Its a long term plan with Ole otherwise, the United job becomes a poison chalice.