Willian at Man Utd?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I rate him v highly. Can see him not being completely happy given he seems below Hazard & Pedro in the pecking order - a fact that culminated in him starting against Spurs beg a 'gamble' by Conte.
 
Why did Moses get the nod ahead of him for the right flank?

Probably because Willian was in the team as an attacker at first when Moses first got played there. Moses was playing well and when Willian came back from personal leave (his mother died) he couldn't get back into the team as Pedro and Moses were playing well.
 
Yeah, let's just sign Bale and Douglas Costa. Willian has the right mentality to go with his skill set and Mourinho doesn't need to babysit his ass. Willian can also be a mentor and friend to Andreas Perrera
Are you suggesting signing Willian as squad depth or starting XI?
 
Are you suggesting signing Willian as squad depth or starting XI?

Depth. He shouldn't start over Mkhitaryan. He would be very good competition for Mata and can push Lingard down the order. United need quality depth and if that player is willing to come to United who has also played previously and won under Jose, then we should be for it.
 
Get why some would want to aim higher and perhaps look at a more exciting option, but some really over the top and strange comments here. "Devastated to sign him" - really?!
 
Get why some would want to aim higher and perhaps look at a more exciting option, but some really over the top and strange comments here. "Devastated to sign him" - really?!

Drama queens, drama queens everywhere!
 
I wouldn't mind him coming here, but Chelsea would want ridiculous amount of money. So no thanks!!
 
The money can be better spent on actually upgrading the squad, instead of buying a player whose level is similar to the ones we already have for that position.
 
Great player, liked him since he came to the prem. I would be quite happy to have him.
 
I like him, doubt Chelsea would sell though and can't see it being to us if they do.
 
Hope our club aren't stupid enough to sell him to you guys. In fact I'm sure they aren't.

I'm sure Willian isn't as happy as he was when he was starting every game, but he doesn't seem to be complaining. The opposite, really. Hope we don't even entertain the idea of him leaving unless there's a ridiculous offer from abroad.

Like Cahill, many of our own supporters hate on Willian unjustifiably. One of my favorite players in our side.
 
He's a good player, nothing more. Not needed. Didn't know he was 28 either :eek:

29 before the next season starts. Just what Mourinho wants, mature players.

He'll make him Valencia 2.0, likely to play him as wing-back in the place of Ashley Young. That's my prediction anyway
 
This rumour is like a turd that won't flush.

This will obviously never happen. Jose isn't stupid enough to sign him. He'll probably end up doing a Mikel or be sold to some tin pot Chinese team.
 
This rumour is like a turd that won't flush.

This will obviously never happen. Jose isn't stupid enough to sign him. He'll probably end up doing a Mikel or be sold to some tin pot Chinese team.
Comparing Willian to Mikel is an insult. Willian is one of the best wide attacking players in the league, even if he doesn't start every game for us.
 
Comparing Willian to Mikel is an insult. Willian is one of the best wide attacking players in the league, even if he doesn't start every game for us.

So good in fact that both Moses and Pedro keep him out of the squad.
 
He has 17 goals and 12 assists in 125 appearances. Let's calm down.

I didn't compare them as players obviously.



:lol:

OK pal!
Name some who are better. Hazard and Sanchez, of course. Mané is better. Our own Pedro is arguable. Sterling starts for City and he's better than Sterling. I don't consider Rashford or Mkhitaryan wide players.

Unless I'm forgetting someone, I'd have Willian over any others in the PL.
 
So good in fact that both Moses and Pedro keep him out of the squad.
What does a wingback have to do with Willian? He directly competes with Pedro not Moses. Conte clearly prefers Pedro but other managers (like Mourinho) would prefer Willian.
 
Name some who are better. Hazard and Sanchez, of course. Mané is better. Our own Pedro is arguable. Sterling starts for City and he's better than Sterling. I don't consider Rashford or Mkhitaryan wide players.

Unless I'm forgetting someone, I'd have Willian over any others in the PL.

Players I'd rather have out wide

Hazard
Sanchez
Martial
Sterling
Sane
Pedro
Mkhi
Mata
Coutinho
Mane


Off the top of my head. These are just from the top 6 clubs and the ones are better by a significant distance. There are feck loads of others I'd rather have as well.

He's a big standard squad player. You're welcome tobkeep
 
I agree. His attributes are:
  • Very good technical ability
  • Very fast
  • Great Passer/crosser
  • Very hard working
  • Tactically intelligent/team player
  • One of the best dead ball players in the world
He doesn't score too many goals but thats my only criticism of him, although he's a pretty good finisher.
He has half of these qualities.
Which ones doesn't he have?
Still waiting.
 
Still waiting.
He doesn't have 'very good' technical ability. He's not a 'great' passer. Tactically intelligent... Yeah, how are you measuring that? He's very fast, he works his bollocks off, and he scores free kicks. He's a respectable player, but there's not much more than that.
 
He doesn't have 'very good' technical ability. He's not a 'great' passer. Tactically intelligent... Yeah, how are you measuring that? He's very fast, he works his bollocks off, and he scores free kicks. He's a respectable player, but there's not much more than that.


Also, my quick analysis shows him to come out well.

Screen_Shot_2017-04-26_at_17.03.36.png
 
Players I'd rather have out wide

Hazard
Sanchez
Martial
Sterling
Sane
Pedro
Mkhi
Mata
Coutinho
Mane


Off the top of my head. These are just from the top 6 clubs and the ones are better by a significant distance. There are feck loads of others I'd rather have as well.

He's a big standard squad player. You're welcome tobkeep
Coutinho, Mata, and Mkhitaryan I would consider #10's rather than wingers. They aren't players who are as effective out wide. Their primary role as creators are very different to Willian's.

Forgot about Sané. Blows hot and cold as expected since he's a teenager.

Martial has missed out completely on your 18 multiple times this season, hasn't he? In a team that can't score goals that says a lot. Not on Willian's level.

Sterling is a headless chicken with zero end product. Not on Willian's level.

Our shit season last year must have made people forget how great Willian was last season. Scored in double digits this season still despite limited minutes.

Mourinho would love him there and he'd start ahead of Martial.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.