Nickosaur
Full Member
- Joined
- Mar 9, 2011
- Messages
- 12,138
Do not want. Plays a sideways pass there? He's clearly shite.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9ca3e/9ca3e6d4f897eb666da8d04a07c00b2ecb9fac32" alt="LOL :lol: :lol:"
Do not want. Plays a sideways pass there? He's clearly shite.
The usual weekly Carvalho gif routine (yesterday´s game):
![]()
He did so well bulldozing through those players, I knew the final pass was going to be a disappointment. Through ball down either flank would have been grand Will!
Fellaini is already doing this job and is going to be fulfilling his potential soon.
Do not desire.
Except he is totally unproven in the PL so it's pretty much impossible to tell at this point.This kid is already streets ahead of Fellaini
Except he is totally unproven in the PL so it's pretty much impossible to tell at this point.
All good until his missed the glaring through ball. Just think if Fellaini had done that?The usual weekly Carvalho gif routine (yesterday´s game):
![]()
Unlike fergie I don't think Moyes has the luxury of signing young talents for our midfield who might be great for us in the future. He would be better off trying for gundogan or kross who are better experienced and performed at the top level. I might be totally wrong though.
All good until his missed the glaring through ball. Just think if Fellaini had done that?
Except he is totally unproven in the PL so it's pretty much impossible to tell at this point.
Agreed. Fellaini is also an established Belgian internacional. Carvalho doing the first steps on the Portuguese national team. I´d be more cautious before doing that kind of statements. Carvalho still has alot to prove.
It is quite simple, the PL is of a higher quality than the top flight in Portugal. Playing well in Portugal is no guarantee that you can play equally well in the PL. Hence "unproven."
Don´t think you are wrong, but the question is can you lure kroos to United? Without Champions League appeal? If so, i´d obviously prefer Kroos obviously.
What is top flight?
From what we've experienced there's an enormous gap between playing with Everton or Aston Villa and playing for a club like Manchester United. I thought watching Fellaini, Cleverley and Foster (who did great at smaller clubs) play at United would have taught us that.
Why wouldn't he be willing, if we pay him the wages he wants. Also, he is a united fan, isn't he. But I should say after reading comments from Munich fans, I don't think he will leave
The Portuguese first division.
I have no idea what you are talking about.
He's never said that he was a United fan.Why wouldn't he be willing, if we pay him the wages he wants. Also, he is a united fan, isn't he. But I should say after reading comments from Munich fans, I don't think he will leave
He's never said that he was a United fan.
I still have no idea what you are talking abut. I don't think you do, either.
I will repeat myself, just because a player is performing well in the Portuguese first division, does not mean that he will be able to replicate that level of performance in the Premier League. Because the PL is of a higher level.
What part of that do you disagree with?
No idea if he is an United fan. I´m just skeptical he would leave Bayern for an United (at the moment, under this Moyes phase) without Champions League football. Don´t think it just revolves around wages, if it does, then United (with all the financial power) obviously can get him.
What has Everton got to do with anything?
This kid is already streets ahead of Fellaini
Except he is totally unproven in the PL so it's pretty much impossible to tell at this point.
Terrible decision with the final pass there.
Mentions of Everton in those two posts? Zero.
I give up. I blame myself, I really should know better.
I'll take a bulldozer with a shit football brain over a couple of still objects.Terrible decision with the final pass there.
You replied to Fellaini's post by saying that its difficult to judge Carvalho since he is not EPL proven. I only highlighted that since the gap between the EPL big clubs (ex Man United) and smaller ones (ex Everton) is enormous, then using the EPL proven thing as a way of judging a player is wrong.
In my opinion Fellaini and Carvalho are at the same level in terms of whether they can succeed at OT or not. Fellaini has the advantage of being older, he's got more experience at national level and had been in England for enough time to say that he can settle in Manchester . Carvalho seem more technically gifted and hes a Lisbon talent ie he's used to pass to feet football which makes him more suitable at United as opposed to Fellaini whose used to the Moyesy 'Everton way'. However if you ask me whom I prefer at OT Id say the latter.
Except he is totally unproven in the PL so it's pretty much impossible to tell at this point.
Don´t think you are wrong, but the question is can you lure kroos to United? Without Champions League appeal? If so, i´d obviously prefer Kroos obviously.
He's a large black man who plays centre midfield, so obviously Viera.To those who watch him, what sort of player is Carvalho exactly? Who does he compare to?
Kroos and Carvalho are two different players though, Kroos isn't a defensive midfielder.
To those who watch him, what sort of player is Carvalho exactly? Who does he compare to?