What has actually happened to Joe Hart?

Once we'd established you did actually mean the box I don't think anyone really thought you were being daft anymore, but is a daft way of naming things.


Its interesting tbh, its only when I posted that I realized i had always called it the D when playing with friends. Just guessing but maybe its because as kids (or even now but more so back then), when you had to shout for a pen in hindi, you said its inside the D rather than the box, perhaps because its shorter and easier to say.
 
So he was referring to something that's not a D shape as the "the D", and not the pitch-marking commonly known as "the D" that is actually D shaped? I think he just got it wrong.

:lol:
 
Its interesting tbh, its only when I posted that I realized i had always called it the D when playing with friends. Just guessing but maybe its because as kids (or even now but more so back then), when you had to shout for a pen in hindi, you said its inside the D rather than the box, perhaps because its shorter and easier to say.



You remind me of when I lived in Darjeeling, you would see an Indian politician on TV, I used to be convinced they had no idea that they had just said दंड बॉक्स
 
The last three pages have been brilliant!

Anyway I'm not sure what has happened to him?

He was clearly the best goalkeeper in the league when City won the title. He has suddenly turned into Ben Foster after that.
 
feck me, I can't believe how much debate was had over the D. I thought it was going to be 3 pages of laughing at Hart.
 
The last three pages have been brilliant!

Anyway I'm not sure what has happened to him?

He was clearly the best goalkeeper in the league when City won the title. He has suddenly turned into Ben Foster after that.

I think it's just a very clear case of letting it all go to his head. He's no competition for his place, he's been England's number 1 and as such the media have been very kind to him regarding criticism, and we already know he's an arrogant bastard. I think the fact he keeps repeating the same sort of error (in which he goes all hero-mode) is more down to the fact he wants to prove how good he is by doing unnecessary things, and subsequently cocks up, rather than just getting on with it and doing what's needed.
 
So he was referring to something that's not a D shape as the "the D", and not the pitch-marking commonly known as "the D" that is actually D shaped? I think he just got it wrong.


:lol: This thread's odd tangent.
 
By the time this story reaches the red tops it'll be Nastasic's fault.


Amuses me when people post this despite there being relentless media coverage about Hart over this season and big debate over whether he should have remained number one for club and country.

Regardless then its hard to establish the degree to which either is at fault. Its largely dependent on the communication between the two which I don't think any of the replays show, if Hart called him to head it back, then yeah he's at fault entirely, if he told him to leave it or called for Nasatasic clear it then Nastasic is entirely at fault, or the more likely that neither committed to making a decision and ended up with the mistake, in which case both are at fault.
 
Amuses me when people post this despite there being relentless media coverage about Hart over this season and big debate over whether he should have remained number one for club and country.

Regardless of which ignores the fact that they actually are both at fault and should both take blame for the incident.

How is Nastasic in any way to blame? He certainly wouldn't have been expecting Hart to have been there and even if Hart had shouted Torres was too close for him to leave it.
 
:lol: This thread.

tbf to Varun, In India, the box is referred to as 'D' for some reason.
 
Amuses me when people post this despite there being relentless media coverage about Hart over this season and big debate over whether he should have remained number one for club and country..
Well I've missed that coverage - it's only very recently they've started questioning him.
 
How is Nastasic in any way to blame? He certainly wouldn't have been expecting Hart to have been there and even if Hart had shouted Torres was too close for him to leave it.


As I said in my post it largely depends on the communication - if Hart told him to leave it or clear it he shouldn't have headed it back and you can't really blame Hart - particularly as I say, if the instruction was to leave, if Hart told him to head it back then its Hart's fault. Or if as most likely happened neither really communicated anything, well then Hart shouldn't have committed himself and Nastasic quite clearly should have headed the ball out for, or at least towards corner rather than trying a header back to the keeper he can quite clearly see is not in a position to catch the ball.
 
As I said in my post it largely depends on the communication - if Hart told him to leave it or clear it he shouldn't have headed it back and you can't really blame Hart - particularly as I say, if the instruction was to leave, if Hart told him to head it back then its Hart's fault. Or if as most likely happened neither really communicated anything, well then Hart shouldn't have committed himself and Nastasic quite clearly should have headed the ball out for, or at least towards corner rather than trying a header back to the keeper he can quite clearly see is not in a position to catch the ball.

Whether Hart called for Nastasic to leave it is irrelevant. Hart charged out unnecessarily and Nastasic had to do something. Even if Hart had called for it, Torres was too close to for Nastasic to just let the ball go, but because Hart had gone all kamikaze there was nowhere for Nastasic to head it other than where he did. Had Hart not come charging out like a loon unnecessarily then there wouldn't have been a problem.
 
Well i'd have to disagree there then, on the replay i'd say if Nastasic did leave it, Hart would probably just about got there first given Torres would have been blocked off by Nastasic, to be fair there's no need for him to come but certainly its a communication issue that both could and should do better on. Regardless he certainly could have headed the ball further away from goal and towards the corner rather than lobbing it over Hart, he had time too but as is the situation he probably panicked. He certainly has enough time facing the goal to see the goalkeeper sprinting towards him to know that a lobbing header isn't the most sensible thing to do.
 
Its interesting tbh, its only when I posted that I realized i had always called it the D when playing with friends. Just guessing but maybe its because as kids (or even now but more so back then), when you had to shout for a pen in hindi, you said its inside the D rather than the box, perhaps because its shorter and easier to say.


The tagline :lol: :lol: :lol:
 
Hart fecked up big style, Nasty should have had a look (rule 2) but he did at least guide his header wide of the goal (rule 1).
 
0710es_hart.jpg
 
It's mostly, almost entirely Hart's fault. Stupid decision to come out when it was clear there was loads of backspin on the lofted clearance from Willian.
 
he ran down the pitch similarly to how de gea did yesterday, they both were looking to clear the ball but the only difference was that de gea was successful. 1 or 2 years ago de gea and joe would have been in opposite roles. Im very happy that hart and nastastic made this error.