Yep. Was evident more then ever yesterday and I think Gary Neville realized that too. We get in a lot of very good positions, and are solid throughout, have very good possession. But that clinical pass, the final ball, final piece of decision making whether it's a cross or cut back, or even pass before the last easy pass, is absolutely woeful. Most of the time the players just don't even attempt it. Our wingers pick up the ball in great positions, 1 v 1, and just turn back the vast majority of the time and recycle the ball. Or just over hit the cross or hit the first man. You look at the other top teams, and compare their final ball with ours, and it's absolutely worlds apart. That's a big reason our attack isn't working I think. Van Gaal has a very functional style, but our wingers are wank. Like mid table quality.
Memphis is young, adapting to the league, and while he was a good, consistent goalscorer for PSV last season, he was by all accounts still inconsistent. Young does the same thing always and has been our most reliable winger even though his final ball is shocking. Valencia the same, always hits the first defender. Lingard gets in so many good opportunities but ruins what feels like over 90% of them with a bad extra touch, or just bad pass. Mata can't beat a man and doesn't put really put crosses in, or useful ones. He's class on form, and that's why we were actually scoring in September when he was, but he's more the man to pass before the final pass as he does give it to wingers in good positions often. Our fullbacks bar Blind when he played there are hopeless with the timing of their overlapping runs and delivery. Rojo has a good cross on him but he's a center back at the end of the day playing left back.
Compare our wingers/fullbacks attacking wise to Arsenal, City, Bayern, Barca, Madrid... That's where the biggest difference is I think. Arsenal have Sanchez, Monreal on the left, Bellerin and then Ozil drifting around. All are very good attacking wise and have very good decision making and create loads of chances for them. City have Silva drifting, De Bruyne who is very reliable with his final ball, Kolarov who has a great left foot, and Sagna who is a good crosses at right back. Barca, Bayern and Madrid are obviously streets ahead in this regard.
United in the past had Giggs, Nani, Valencia (on form), Evra, Rafael, Ronaldo, Beckham, Neville, and then players like Young as the back up who we were all frustrated with, but is now our best winger. Shaw played a big part for us but he unfortunately broke his leg. He was one of the only ones in terms of the players who play wide to consistently be a threat that could fit in with the others in our past or other top teams. Martial on the wing is also capable of it, with memphis having the potential but still being to young/inconsistent for now.